4 ms·

A is not true. There have been many studies on eye witness testimony that disprove everything your saying. The reality is that our brain fills in many, many gap

A is not true. There have been many studies on eye witness testimony that disprove everything your saying. The reality is that our brain fills in many, many gaps. B, you completely missed the point. Just completely missed the point to read that sentence the way you wanted to, "many of the details are completely meaningless to the premise that is presented" has nothing to do with memory. That's why it starts with "Even if we believed someone could have a memory this crystal clear...." So why are you even bothering to argue about memory with me when I gave the memory the benefit of the doubt in my argument?

tjoff 11y ago
A: Which was my point... Just because memory isn't reliable doesn't mean telling something in detail from memory is a tell-sign that it is fake. It just means that those memories could be wrong or, subconsciously, made up. As I said, I just wanted to comment on that. And that because of the way you gave the memory the benefit of doubt, considering the circumstances anything else could have been equally suspicious. Also, it's not hard to imagine he doesn't really believe he'll find her and typing it up serves a purpose of its own. It could also be something he just wanted to share. Again, I'm not saying it's real, just that I didn't think the arguments I commented on was particularly convincing. Sorry?