3 ms·
These are certainly fair questions to ask. On the other hand, it seems likely that the infrastructure and automation of a new generation of vehicles might end
by Silhouette 11y ago
These are certainly fair questions to ask.
On the other hand, it seems likely that the infrastructure and automation of a new generation of vehicles might end up much more efficient than what we have today. Better co-ordination between vehicles and response to changing conditions is likely to improve the overall efficiency of the system. Reducing the risk of accidents and the resulting congestion and delays could be a big win for efficiency as well.
It seems conceivable that these sorts of effects could more than compensate for, say, the environmental cost of doubling average commute distances, making the overall change a net benefit even with some increase in commuting range. People are still going to want to keep commutes within a limit they personally find tolerable anyway, so there is always going to be some bound on how much extra distance gets covered as a result of automation making commutes more traveller-friendly.
Of course there are also other benefits from things like reducing accidents, but I'm just considering the efficiency of the transport system and its likely environmental impact here.
- Steltek 11y agoHow much more efficient? Aren't most of the promises of automated cars predicated on having dedicated highways, forbidding hands-on driving? Is that ever likely to happen inside of a decade? And once we do get there, is the earned capacity from full automation going to equal other options, in both cost and efficiency, that we could be pursuing now? I don't think it's reasonable to block real progress with illusory claims that in a decade or two, cars may finally stop killing people and ruining the environment.
- Silhouette 11y agoJust to be clear, I'm not in any way suggesting that a viable, fully automated system will be happening any time soon, nor that we shouldn't fix more immediate problems more immediately. I was just responding to the valid question of whether more automation would just promote longer journeys and in doing so make some things worse than they were before.