4 ms·
Do those in charge actually want accurate predictions? The hurricane is going to go where it is going to go, the model has no impact on the realworld path. If
by sandworm101 11y ago
Do those in charge actually want accurate predictions? The hurricane is going to go where it is going to go, the model has no impact on the realworld path. If we know the path with certainty then those in the path can take appropriate measures. But what is we enjoy those measures and want to do them regardless of where the storm will actually hit?
What a storm might be approach the executive branch of the local government goes into emergency mode. Emergency funds are spent on preparations. Some government workers are sent home. Schools might be closed. Evacuation orders may be issued. Town mayors and, importantly, state governors all go on TV to talk about these preparations. The local executives get to do their lord-and-master thing. If the storm hits, they looks like heroes. If it doesn't, they still look like dutiful public servants concerned for the safety of their public. Some people enjoy a good disaster rehearsal, especially if they get to be the one in charge.
Imho the private sector, specifically the insurance, travel and tourism industries are the ones who want accurate models. That isn't to say that prediction should be privatized. The government is probably in the better place to handle forecasting. But the demand on politicians for better models/funding arises from industry, not any noble desire to avoid widespread emergency declarations.
- ghaff 11y agoAnd if you do the disaster rehearsal thing too many times without anything happening, i.e. cry wolf, the next time no one pays any attention, Katrina or Sandy hits, and a lot of people die that didn't need to.
- sandworm101 11y agoAnd then the politicians go on TV and lament that people should better listen to authorities, that they were the wise ones. My point is that an unpredictable offshore threat advantages local elected officials. Their careers are advanced by both the false alarms and the disasters.
- ghaff 11y agoThat is complete and utter nonsense. No one is basically ever happy with the government response to severe weather events. Leave aside hurricanes. Ask any number of Massachusetts officials who are no longer in their positions because of transit and other failures during blizzards last winter.
- sandworm101 11y agoHow many elected officials in executive branches were replaced? Functionaries, non-elected government employees, are often wrongly blamed. It is the elected reps, specifically those in the executive branch (ie Chris Christie) who turn the unpredictability of storms to their advantage.
- MaysonL 11y agoMost of the Katrina damage was due to Army Corps of Engineers failure in the decades preceding it.
- greenyoda 11y agoThat's a good point, but it's not just a question of people paying attention the next time - putting a large city into disaster mode has a huge economic cost. For example, in preparation for Hurricane Sandy in NYC, the entire transit system was shut down to keep subway trains out of tunnels that were expected to flood, and it took quite a while after the hurricane for all the trains to be running again. This made it hard for people to get to work after the hurricane (even in areas of the city that weren't flooded) and cost businesses a lot of revenue. If politicians routinely shut down the transit system for hurricanes that never actually hit the city, they wouldn't be very likely to get reelected.