4 ms·
I mean, it's almost a moot point. Each year the number of native apps I run goes down by a couple, and the number of webapps I use go up by a few. Native apps
by brianwawok 11y ago
I mean, it's almost a moot point. Each year the number of native apps I run goes down by a couple, and the number of webapps I use go up by a few.
Native apps I use right now?
Chrome - Already native compiled
IntelliJ - Full JIT mode, but due to the fact I start it once and run it for a month, not a huge deal.
Command line unixy stuff - Already native compiled
(On gaming computer) Games - Already native compiled
I mean desktop apps DO exist, but just not that many to use day to day... from what I have seen of the windows app store, I can find 20 colors of calculator apps, but nothing that impressive.
- pjmlp 11y agoFor me it goes the opposite direction. On mobile only apps. The Web is for reading stuff. On the desktop the same thing, except for all those forums and travel booking websites that don't offer me a choice. Messaging, email, productive software, work related stuff all native software. Exception being when some customers do require web projects.
- mwcampbell 11y ago> all those forums and travel booking websites that don't offer me a choice. So you would prefer to have the friction of an app store, or even just a platform-specific native executable, for every little service? And of course there's also the friction on the developer side, especially when submitting to app stores which act as gatekeepers. Sure, native apps have better performance and often a better user experience all around, especially mobile apps. But your comment about forums and travel booking websites has got me thinking that we should really try to solve the performance and UX issues of the web platform rather than retreat to native apps. Edit: Yes, I've taken both sides on the web versus native debate. I recently posted that JavaScript-based mobile web apps are second-class compared to AOT-compiled native mobile apps. I attribute my latest flip-flop to the fact that just last night I went through the tedious process of submitting a new app to the iOS App Store -- an app that could probably have been a web app. So now I want the web to win.
- pjmlp 11y ago> So you would prefer to have the friction of an app store, or even just a platform-specific native executable, for every little service? Yes, every time I have the option to do so.
- mwcampbell 11y agoWhy exactly do you prefer a native app whenever you have the option?
- pjmlp 11y agoExecution speed and integration with OS features.
- MereInterest 11y agoIf I have an executable that is running on my system, I know that it will continue to run tomorrow. If I am using a web service, I don't know whether it will continue to exist. If it is running locally, I can manage my own backups, my own settings.
- SyneRyder 11y agoI'd prefer this in many cases as well. I can use web versions of Evernote, Pocket, OneDrive, Email, but I would much rather use their platform specific native executables. It's a better, faster experience that integrates better with the device I'm using. I could watch Netflix in my web browser, but the Windows 10 app is faster & smoother. It even irritates me when the Kindle Android App drops me out to a web browser to browse the store & buy more books, instead of just letting me do it all from within the app.
- pdkl95 11y ago> So you would prefer to have the friction of an app store, or even just a platform-specific native executable What friction? apt-get install $PACKAGE_NAME Native apps will always be far superior to the web, because the web browser (at least, any with that claims to care about security) is required to maintain a separation between the "page" and the browser that frames the page, or you trivially enable "phishing" and other UI-impersonation attacks. Native has far more flexibility. Personally, I absolutely hate the jitter every time Javascript (or most other VMs) decides to GC for 50ms or more, and will go out of my way to avoid it. > app stores which act as gatekeepers So stop supporting those gatekeepers, both as a developer and as a user. As long as people keep giving them money and market share, they will continue to gain power as gatekeeprs. > try to solve the performance and UX issues of the web platform That would require defining a new platform that isn't the web. The web is a document-based design, and while a lot of clever tricks have been found that let people pretend it's something else, all of the core components of the web (HTML, etc) are designed for documents. This is good - we need a way to freely exchange documents. If you want a way to develop applications that can be distributed as easily as documents are on the web, it would probably be a good idea to create some VM base portable application format that was actually free of stuff like HTML/CSS. An HTML replacement that worked more like a GUI toolkit would be much nicer for app development.
- mwcampbell 11y agoI gather that you don't run many apps on a mobile device. The shift toward mobile apps seems to be what's motivating the current trend toward AOT compilation.
- brianwawok 11y agorunning chrome on android right now. One of the 3 of 4 mobile apps I use.
- acdha 11y agoWeb Assembly is going to add an interesting hybrid: the actual native compilation will happen on the client but the app developer will have the ability to put significant AOT resources into optimizing the byte-code sent over the network.