2 ms·
Talk therapy works a lot better than placebo, but it doesn't matter what kind. Talking to one type of therapist works as well as talking to another type of ther
by pessimizer 11y ago
Talk therapy works a lot better than placebo, but it doesn't matter what kind. Talking to one type of therapist works as well as talking to another type of therapist. Even talking to a priest works as well as talking to a therapist.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo_bird_verdict https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dodo_bird_verdict
This article is more interesting for me in that it supports the dodo bird verdict. Cognitive behavioral therapy results have for a while been put forward as the exception. According to the article, those results have been inflated, and there are no exceptions.
edit: of course, if you consider a priest the control for the psychology industry - then it may be fair to say that established therapies have no better success than placebo. Is a priest a placebo?
edit: tl;dr
-----
"The most commonly studied of [talk therapies is] cognitive behavior therapy — in which people learn to identify and defuse automatic, self-defeating assumptions, like 'I’m unlucky in love' or 'I always choke' — and interpersonal therapy, which focuses on reshaping how people interact with others. These studies typically have subjects engage in weekly, hourlong sessions with a therapist for three to four months.
"The researchers found that 13 of these funded studies were completed but never published, usually because those who did the trials did not think a finding of no benefit stood much chance of being published. The team contacted each of the 13 investigators originally paid to do the work and requested their data. Once that data was included with those from the other, published papers, the effectiveness of the therapies dropped significantly — by about a quarter.
"'That seems to be the magic number, a quarter — about the same as you see in the pharma trials' of antidepressants, said a co-author, Dr. Erick Turner, an associate professor of psychiatry at Oregon Health & Science University and the lead author of the 2008 paper detailing bias in those drug trials."
- mattmanser 11y agoYour opening arguments completely disagree with the bottom quote. This isn't what you think it is. They're not saying CBT doesn't work or isn't more effective, they're saying it's not quite as effective as thought because people don't always report the failures. What's happening is that people who do a study that results in no positive benefit aren't publishing. But one study doesn't give the whole picture. There are many reasons why a singular study might show no benefit, a lot of them statistical reasons. What you need to do is look at all the studies, but the problem has been that the failing studies haven't always been published, which is bad science. So what's been happening is the published studies were: B NB B B NB B B B (6 benefit / 2 no benefit) When in fact the results were: B NB B B NB B B B NB NB (6 benefit / 4 no benefit) In science and statistics you have to report the false negatives too.