7 ms·
One of the designers where I work added 3D Touch to a prototype of a website he was working on this week. During a Demo session no one knew the feature was ther
by onion2k 11y ago
One of the designers where I work added 3D Touch to a prototype of a website he was working on this week. During a Demo session no one knew the feature was there until he told them. That's the hard bit about UI design once you go beyond visual things - people are conservative in the ways they interact with devices, so unless there's an indicator, or instructions, no one will find the fancy new UI feature. And if no one finds, and thus no one uses it, what's the point in spending part of your budget making it?
The problem is further compounded by 3D Touch not really having an obvious use case in most apps. What it'll do will vary from app to app. That means a user has to learn what it does over and over again, and how much pressure to use in each thing. What 'light touch' is in one developer's app will be different to another's.
3D Touch is great, and has loads of potential, but it's going to be hard to make it genuinely useful.
- bsaul 11y agoCompletely agree. Plus, you still have to design your ui so that the feature is accessible by other more obvious and available means. Those new interactions will always only be the equivalent of keyboard shortcuts. Nothing more.
- Cookingboy 11y agoIronically, flat UI MAY have made this problem more difficult to solve. Imagine if we were still on some sort of skeumorphism design on iOS, then we MAY be able to come up with some sort of layer/depth/texture visual hint that makes people want to press one area harder. I have no idea what that would look like, but on a random note, a bubble wrap popping game with 3D touch support would be dope.
- danieldk 11y ago3D Touch is great, and has loads of potential, but it's going to be hard to make it genuinely useful. I see one big exception and that is games. Phones are limited when it comes to controls and 3D Touch can be a welcome addition. Discoverability isn't as much of a problem for games, because there is usually a tutorial anyway. Of course, it will be a while before games will be designed around 3D touch, because older iPhones and Android phones.
- wingerlang 11y agoI always saw it as an interface like right clicking, which is genuinely useful.
- onion2k 11y agoLong press is a better alternative for that, and that's available on iOS (UILongPressGestureRecognizer) and Android (android.view.ContextMenu). The fact it's rarely used despite having been an available option for years might indicate it's not actually very useful.
- wingerlang 11y agoWhy is it a better alternative? And what makes you think it is rarely used?
- threeseed 11y agoLong press already has a meaning on iOS though. It means "rearrange". For example apps on the home screen, movies in my streaming app etc.
- arrrg 11y agoLong press is annoying to use. It’s just so, so, so slow.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- onion2k 11y agoWe're not born with the knowledge of how to operate things, but we do learn it very quickly. A two year old can use a touch screen because the way you interact with it is largely the same as the way you interact with the world - touch something and see things change. With most real world devices that you put pressure on to use it's the distance you push them that selects the input - e.g. a car accelerator pedal doesn't take more pressure to make the car go faster, it's dependent on how far you move it. They're not really pressure sensitive but pressure actuated. Pressure sensitive interfaces are unusual. Most people don't learn how to use them.
- mnem 11y agoI suspect you may find artists will disagree with you there. They've been using pressure sensitive interfaces for thousands of years.
- 6d0debc071 11y agoUse of pressure to control the behaviour of the tool there has: A) immediate graduated feedback (perhaps a learning point for pressure sensitive interfaces here?) B) is something that you have to learn to do well (an awful lot of people never do - most people aren't artists.)
- mnem 11y agoMy fingertip takes care of A. As for B, I do use pressure variance when writing and sketching diagrams, but I'm certainly not very good at it. It's useful for me, but not essential. All I was really pointing out that pressure sensitivity isn't an unusual concept. I'd be quite surprised if people didn't use it in a variety of situations each day.
- 6d0debc071 11y ago
- mnem 11y agoNo computer interfaces are intuitively obvious without prior training, whether that's through direct teaching or indirectly from culture or advertising. This is painfully apparent if you ever have helped someone who has never used a computer to use a computer. I've found the popup previews surprisingly useful across applications after expecting it to purely be a gimmick. It's especially useful on HN and other text heavy sites with links. I'm interested to see if web designers start designing for such previews - at the moment a lot sites previews are their banner adverts or other non-content related fluff. It'd be quite useful if you could make Safari popup previews in its reader mode to remove non-content items.
- ashark 11y agoiOS 6 was definitely way more intuitive than its successors, though. Skeumorphism and depth helped quite a bit (think the unlock slider versus "swipe the entire screen up, for some reason, according to some hard-to-read text") and so did its commitment to keeping the home screen prominently in view when not in an actual app, sliding folders open from the screen itself and sliding it up to show the task manager rather than covering it with those same two views the way iOS7 and up do. Earlier versions of iOS had a physicality to them that worked well to increase discoverability of their interfaces. The the "if it's not flat it makes me physically ill!" school of designers got ahold of it...
- rebootthesystem 11y agoUI's are becoming overloaded. Apple insists on not adding buttons to iOS devices or mice. You end up with double click, triple click, click and hold, click hold swipe, the volume button takes a picture, four or five finger gestures nobody knows, gestures in general, etc. At the limit dicoverability starts to approach voodoo. Not saying it's right or wrong, just stating a fact.
- muddi900 11y agoWasn't this the exact reason Apple was so strict about the one-button mouse for Mac OS and the menu bar? In fact, obfuscation is the exact reason Google ditched the menu button on Android? 3D touch does resolve the iOS issue of not having a back button(without adding any of the ambiguity I hope). I sincerely doubt regular users would use it. It would be like multitasking or the does cool 4-finger gestures on the iPad, something only power-users use extensively.