3 ms·
These threads always fucking suck on HN. Before you comment I would urge you to go find some reporting by the NYTimes of something you know a lot about - your
by DanBC 11y ago
These threads always fucking suck on HN.
Before you comment I would urge you to go find some reporting by the NYTimes of something you know a lot about - your favoured programming language or a company you work for, and see how well their reporting matches your understanding of the topic.
Here's the stuff that newspaper articles usually fail to mention in reports on therapy / drug studies
1) The definition of major depression has broadened and now includes a much greater range of people. The effect size of treatment is normally greater for people with more severe symptoms, although the relapse rate is also usually higher.
2) The way trials are run has changed, and many trials are not very good. One of the causes of this is odd regulation.
3) People seem to say that pills for psychiatric use are no better than placebo (not true) but that pills for physical health (eg hypertension) are better than placebo (true) but those people should also look at the effect size, which is often similar for both types of meds.
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20241/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20241/abstrac...
Anti-depressants vs placebo: http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20241/epdf http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20241/epdf
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20263/epdf http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20263/epdf
Pragmatic randomized controlled trial of long-term psychoanalytic psychotherapy for treatment-resistant depression: the Tavistock Adult Depression Study (TADS) http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20267/abstract http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/wps.20267/abstrac...
etc.
- icelancer 11y ago>Before you comment I would urge you to go find some reporting by the NYTimes of something you know a lot about - your favoured programming language or a company you work for, and see how well their reporting matches your understanding of the topic. The Gell-Mann Amnesia Effect. Which was coined of course by... Michael Crichton. Anyway, it's a good rule of thumb. http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-gell-mann-amnesia-effect-is-as-follows-you http://www.goodreads.com/quotes/65213-briefly-stated-the-gel...
- marincounty 11y agoI won't even comment on Therapy. I noticed you assumed, and rightly so, the uproar would be over psychiatic drugs? I don't have a problem with Therapy. Is hard to study, and at worst it doesn't seem to have any bad side side effects--besides on the wallet? We do get are feathers ruffled when Psychiartic drugs(mainly tricyclic, and hetricyclic antidepressants) are brought up. Why, because so many of us took them. I took them. My friends took them. I even encouraged a ex-girlfriend to take them. In my case they never worked, but I believed the literature, and thought I was just unlucky. I spent thousands on different drugs for depression and anxiety. I can't put a price on the side effects, and disillusionment. I imagine a lot of people are still on them. They were billed as the Wonder drugs. They were very expensive. Patients and Doctors were equally lied to by drug companies. They caused a lot of unnessary pain, and suffering. Too many people are still on them. I sometimes wonder if there's a correlation between some of these drugs and violence? I know if I was a prescriber, I don't think I would prescribe a heterocyclic Drug(Proxax, Zoloft, etc.). I just don't believe they work, but the industry is trying so hard to still justify their use--in selected patients--you know the "sickest patients seem to get a bit better--sometimes--in some situations?" If the history, and study of Erythromycin is in any way like the history, and study of Prozax; I will never take another antibiotic again. It's not that we hate all Psychiatric drugs, but some of them, especially the Happy Pills; were studied terribly, some even fraudently, and a lot of psychiatric patients are still very leary of a lot of these drugs; And so are the drug companies. I don't see any dancing pills in commercials anymore like I did in the 90's and 2000's? I just see ads by Lawyers. I don't see hubristic Psychiatrists advertising as "Chemical Imbalance Specilists" anymore. Psychiatry was hit hard by the deceitfulness of these drug comapnies. The profession just doesn't have the glamor factor anymore. Patients don't look at them the same way. I actually feel sorry for the honest ones, and the ones who keep their office visit prices reasonable. I couldn't imagine doing my residency in Psychiatry after graduation from med school these days. My fear is the wrong students will be admitted to Psychiatric residencies--students who weren't the best and brightest in medical school? So yes, there's usually an uproar when articles like this hit. I don't care if a particular drug is slightly better than Placebo; it's when they are so close to placebo, or not even close to Placebo when you include all the discarded/badly done studies, and all the metadata that boils my brain. They history of Proxaz makes makes a good read. Personally, I can't even read it anymore; it literally makes my head hurt. http://www.theguardian.com/society/2007/may/13/socialcare.medicineandhealth http://www.theguardian.com/society/2007/may/13/socialcare.me...
- pessimizer 11y agoPsychologists and pharmaceutical companies don't have any sort of inside knowledge of how statistics work. > Before you comment I would urge you to go find some reporting by the NYTimes of something you know a lot about - your favoured programming language or a company you work for, and see how well their reporting matches your understanding of the topic. This is an argument against all reporting by the NYT, based on a hypothetical shared feeling. This may be an obvious thing to say, but the reporting of many newspapers (including the NYT) about things that I know more than most about has often been right, and sometimes been wrong. They have sometimes been right in a frustrating way (I felt like they missed a deeper point), or wrong in an incompetent way. I'm saying this not because it is interesting, but because it is boring. Making an argument that since everyone who has some expertise has at some time felt like a story was wrong, therefore this story is wrong - is noise, not signal. The NYT is not making the case, it's showcasing the arguments of experts who share a particular opinion. I'm struggling to figure out how your list speaks to their arguments in any way. 1) and 3) seem like question begging, to a non-psychologist, and I don't know what 2) is an argument for, against, or about. What does effect size matter if the effect over placebo may not even exist? This is more like reading an article about some issue in real estate when you, and/or many of your friends and family partially make their living from that issue.
- DanBC 11y agoThe submitted article talks about therapy not being as effective as we used to think. My links explain why newer studies find less evidence of benefit, and whether that's a problem. These threads are always full of people saying "I didn't read the paper; I didn't read all of the article; but I disagree because my aunt once ..." It'd be nice if people downvoted contrarian anecdote, but they tend not to.
- chris_wot 11y agoI guess I'm just waiting for a headline that says "Study finding effectiveness of talk therapy is overstated overstated their findings". Now there's a headline that would make me read the article.
- dang 11y ago> These threads always fucking suck on HN. Please don't post things like that to HN. They only make threads suck worse.