3 ms·
I already know that a book on numerical analysis is likely to contain the answer I seek. The point of asking was to avoid a trip to the library since the workin
by jjoonathan 11y ago
I already know that a book on numerical analysis is likely to contain the answer I seek. The point of asking was to avoid a trip to the library since the working memory of someone who has been investigating differentiation techniques also likely contains the answer I seek.
- jacobolus 11y agoI don’t quite understand what your question is, so I’m going to assume you were trying to ask, “When would you not want to use automatic differentiation?” I think the main time you can’t get much out of automatic differentiation is when your function is a black box or approximation, e.g. it comes from measuring physical data, or is the output of some kind of simulation, etc. I’m not an expert though. You can get a lot of hits if you google related keywords (e.g. a query with both terms "numerical differentiation" "automatic differentiation" in quotation marks). But here’s a start, http://alexey.radul.name/ideas/2013/introduction-to-automatic-differentiation/#approximate-the-derivative_-dont_-differentiate-the-approximation http://alexey.radul.name/ideas/2013/introduction-to-automati... You can probably get useful advice if you ask on http://scicomp.stackexchange.com http://scicomp.stackexchange.com or similar.
- jjoonathan 11y agoSomeone who knows to bring automatic differentiation into a discussion about complex-step differentiation with the implication that they have already compared them and found one wanting (while implying that they may have missed something and are receptive to contrary opinions) already knows how CSD and AD work. This person also likely know how to use google, the library / amazon, and stack exchange (at the very least) but upon running a few simple queries has determined that the approximate effort to find an answer exceeds their interest in the subject. Unless someone else can use their own greater familiarity with the subject to provide an opinion or a pointer to a specific easily accessible resource (example: lloda's pdf link, counterexample: your book link) the line of inquiry will fizzle out due to the tyranny of cost/benefit analysis and having better things to do. I appreciate that you were trying to be helpful, which is why I'm trying to be gentle (and explanatory) as I tell you that you weren't.