4 ms·
While not conclusive, I give these guys credit for replicating a behavior fitting the "cheater" profile. But I am surprised that not spinning up the rear tires
by sandworm101 11y ago
While not conclusive, I give these guys credit for replicating a behavior fitting the "cheater" profile. But I am surprised that not spinning up the rear tires triggered that behavior.
The loss in power measured here will be very noticeable to diesel owners. Diesels have narrow power bands. You don't spend much driving time anywhere near the top hp zone. The torque curves are what matters. A 10% loss means you will probably have to rev up another 10%, say 3300 rather than 3000, to get at the same power. While a professional reviewer stepping into a car for the first time might not notice, the guy taking his personal vehicle in sure will. VW owners will not be happy if the coming fix reduces torque by this much.
I suspect this "cheat" is done by enriching the mixture a little to lower the temp and reduce NOx. Conversely, VW might have been running things too lean under normal operation. A lean (oxygen-rich) mixture burns hotter, resulting in more power and efficiency but much of that unburnt O2 ends up combining with N2 to form the nasty N0x junk. So if the fix means effectively pinning the cheat on all the time, fixed cars will probably end up burning more fuel with less top-end power.
- kw71 11y agoI know that a lean burning petrol engine will emit more NOx, but as an American who is not a truck mechanic I don't really know much about diesel. Does it work the same way in the diesel cycle? On the other hand, I am reasonably sure that more fuel = more CO2 emissions (or whatever emissions are catalyzed into CO2.)
- sandworm101 11y agoIt's the same basic chemistry. You've got O2+N2 (air) plus hydrocarbon (H-C=C-H sort of things) all mixed together and heated. Ideally all the 02 bonds with the H and C to form C02 and H20. If the mixture is lean and hot enough then there isn't enough H and C for all the O2 and it instead bonds with the N2 to form NOx. The only real difference with the diesel is that the hydrocarbons are longer, which is why diesel is thicker and less volatile. Diesel needs to be hotter to break down these longer hydrocarbons and this is achieved via a higher compression ratio (14:1 instead of 10:1). That extra heat is an issue for N0x production if the mixture gets too lean. But if the mix is too rich, with not enough 02 for all the H and C, then you get incomplete combustion. That black soot is essentially just carbon that couldn't find any oxygen to bond with. To avoid soot, so-called clean diesels run slightly lean and then rely on a catalytic converter to turn any N0x back into N2 and O2, but a dry cat can only go so far. BMW and others inject urea into the cat where it become ammonia (NH3). The O in the NOx grabs the H from the NH3 and the two Ns form N2. NOx + NH3 = N2 + H20.