3 ms·
Seems like the mistake the author is making is announcing something as a "product" when it's really still a "project." In principle, using the GPL license for
by CamperBob2 11y ago
Seems like the mistake the author is making is announcing something as a "product" when it's really still a "project."
In principle, using the GPL license for the reference code is OK if his intent is to encourage other people to build more refined, practical, and performant implementations. But the real problem with his choice of license is that a lot of people can't even look at the code for fear of tainting themselves legally. Given that there is no desperate market demand for a better-PNG-than-PNG, it wasn't a good idea to handicap the proposed format by saddling it with various restrictions and legal minefields.
If the reference code is strictly of proof-of-concept quality, which it sounds like it is, then there was no reason not to use a more permissive license.
- belorn 11y agoPeople should not be reading HN or any news at all if they fear committing patent or copyright infringement from just looking at code. You lock those people into a bunker without internet and just a computer to do the work, and after we call all be safe that it was legal.