4 ms·
Lactose tolerance is believed to have developed in the last 5,000 - 10,000 years. There was recently a news story about the Inuit having an adaptation that is a
by jerf 11y ago
Lactose tolerance is believed to have developed in the last 5,000 - 10,000 years. There was recently a news story about the Inuit having an adaptation that is at most 20,000 years old [1], and probably unique to them. The deeper we dig into genes the more stuff like this we'll find.
It wasn't a silly theory. It may be wrong, but it wasn't silly.
[1]: http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/22/science/inuit-study-adds-twist-to-omega-3-fatty-acids-health-story.html?_r=0 http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/22/science/inuit-study-adds-t...
- sandworm101 11y agoExcept that neither of those examples involve new substances. Lactose has been around for literally millions of years. Genes for dealing with it, or not, are part of what makes us mammals (ie things with mammary glans that nurse their young). And the gene found in the Inuit has not appeared recently. It exists nearly worldwide and is far older than its recent rise to prominence in the inuit. It has not evolved anew. Alcohol is new. While old genes may have evolved to deal with addiction generally, any gene specifically addressing alcohol could not possibly have evolved in the brief time the new world native communities were genetically disconnected from europe/asia/africa. I also seriously doubt that alcohol was predominant enough in any ancient population for it to have an impact on survivability. Only the rich could afford to drink that much.
- prutschman 11y ago> any gene specifically addressing alcohol could not possibly have evolved in the brief time the new world native communities were genetically disconnected from europe/asia/africa It could have been a spandrel.
- douche 11y agoWhy believe that it takes thousands of years to select and enhance a gene? We have selectively bred animals in decades to exhibit traits that were useful, and long before we had any concept of genetics. We have evidence of the production of beer dating back before the Pyramids - and beer and wine were staples of pre-modern diets in the old world, that everyone drank, at least in the form of watered wine and small-beer, as the drinking water all-too-often would kill you. Why should we not expect to see genetic adaptation in such an environment?
- sandworm101 11y agoYou are skipping through a few steps. The gene has to first appear. It has to be one of those many tiny little perturbations that appear every so often. It then has to give that organism some sort of advantage. For a gene controlling alcoholism, it would have to appear somewhere where alcoholism had some substantial impact on survivability ... and then spread out across europe, asia and africa giving some similar advantage to persons along the way else it die out. I might be open if the old world suffered from widespread alcoholism (to the point of impacting survivability across classes) for the last 20,000 years, but is just didn't. Producing alcohol takes proper effort and resources. You only get there one you aren't starving anymore. Egypt and a few other areas capable of sustaining intensive agriculture were not the norm.
- jerf 11y ago"For a gene controlling alcoholism, it would have to appear somewhere where alcoholism had some substantial impact on survivability" No, it doesn't. It needs to be a gene that has an impact on alcoholism, but the thing being selected for could be something else entirely. Consider sickle-cell anemia. If you just look at it as the "sickle-cell anemia gene" you'll boggle at how it spread as far as it did, but that's because it's also the "malaria-resistance gene". If alcohol is introduced into a population that did not have widespread, ready access to it for long time frames, there's no guessing in advance what could happen as it interacts with arbitrary other adaptations that have never "seen" alcohol before. I want to point out you keep boggling at how intrinsically impossible this all is, and I keep citing concrete examples of very similar things that happen. And I'll reiterate that my point is that it was a viable theory, until the facts contradicted it, not that it was certainly correct and certainly not that it's correct now. Simply that it was not a stupid theory. (Indeed, given that this is just one study I'd be glib even saying it's "disproved", it's merely one that we must Bayesian-update to a much smaller probability. But I wouldn't downgrade it to zero quite yet. We've got a lot of gene science left to learn. And as always happens, when we take a closer look, it always turns out to be more complicated than we thought...)
- jerf 11y agoThe point is that there is demonstrated large-scale selection effects on the relevant time frames, and I fully expect more to emerge as we learn more and our powers of perception increase. It was not a dumb theory. It was merely wrong. It's easy in hindsight to explain how obvious the correct answer is, but it doesn't count for much.