7 ms·
Is there an animal that does not fear death? I mean, try to swat a fly. Bees will swarm and attack if one of their swarm is killed or injured--it releases a phe
by snowwrestler 11y ago
Is there an animal that does not fear death? I mean, try to swat a fly. Bees will swarm and attack if one of their swarm is killed or injured--it releases a pheromone. Or look at how a dog or cat responds and develops under abuse. They know what a threat is, and avoid it, which implies an aversion to death.
I'm continuously surprised at what researchers are surprised by, when it comes to animal behavior. Once it became obvious that we are ourselves animals, the default hypothesis should be that everything we experience, other animals experience as well; that we are indicative examples of a consistent set. Then we could look for differences.
Instead, the presumption is that animals experience none of the inner life that we do. IMO this goes back to religious and cultural beliefs from Europe, not from any scientific basis. Other cultures don't think this way. If you told a Native American or Tibetan Buddhist that crows are aware of death and perceive their surroundings, they would probably say "yes, of course."
- ohitsdom 11y agoThat was my first reaction too, but I've come around since reading the article. What you're talking about is self-preservation, and of course animals display that all the time. This study shows that crows behaved differently when seeing an already dead crow, and they feared whatever person/animal was near the dead crow.
- scott_s 11y agoAgreed. What the researchers showed is that crows seem to have a recognition of death. That is distinct from having a self-preservation instinct. If you find yourself surprised by what scientists are surprised by, perhaps the fault is more likely to be with your own understanding of what the scientists are actually doing.
- WalterBright 11y agoIsn't that still self-preservation? I have no idea how self-preservation can be distinguished from fear of death, or even if there is any distinction.
- simonh 11y agoThey're tecognising an implied rather than imminent threat. Pretty much any animal will react to protect itself from a clear threat, but what these animals are doing is associating the death of one of their kind with something linked to it, but which itself on its own does not appear threatening or dangerous. They're making a cognitive leap most animals can't make.
- duderific 11y agoAgree. While crows are exceptionally smart, I bet if other species are studied, similar results will be found, with regards to understanding the concept of death. The one that gets me now is when people say something like "well I don't eat beef, but I am ok with eating fish because they are lower on the food chain." As if fish don't feel pain when they are killed. You either accept that what you are eating had to suffer when it died, and feel appropriate guilt (or not), or you don't eat any meat at all.
- politician 11y agoAre suffering and death intrinsically linked?
- gurkendoktor 11y ago> You either accept that what you are eating had to suffer when it died, and feel appropriate guilt (or not), or you don't eat any meat at all. Even if you only eat grains, you are responsible/guilty for mice being run over in the farming process, and then poisoned to defend storage of your grains. I don't see it as a binary decision, but as a spectrum. You can try to optimise for the least damage to sentient beings, but there's no way to get it 100% right. (I agree about fish though, nothing special about them that separates them from land animals.)
- nitrogen 11y ago"well I don't eat beef, but I am ok with eating fish because they are lower on the food chain." This is interesting, because many or most of the fish we eat are predators, while cows are herbivores. Fish are higher on the food chain than cows.
- byron_fast 11y agoI agree. It seems that much of studying animal behavior consists of confirming what farmers and hunters have known since 3000BC. I think chipmunks in my yard aren't much different than these crows, though they clearly can't recognize faces. Actually they don't really understand that legs and arms are part of the same being. Which makes me wonder about crows, which seem so smart but don't have much more brain mass than a squirrel.
- yareally 11y ago> don't have much more brain mass than a squirrel. Mass alone isn't a significant measure. It's the mass to size ratio[1], which for crows (EQ 4.1) is similar to chimps (EQ 4.2), with higher EQ generally denoting higher intelligence. For comparison, bottle nose dolphins are 5.9 EQ. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encephalization_quotient https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Encephalization_quotient
- byron_fast 11y agoYeah, true, otherwise whales would have fusion-powered underwater cities. I think in the case of crows they have really good eyes especially compared to chipmunks, who don't seem able to resolve anything other than movement beyond a few feet.
- yareally 11y agoYep, crows have pretty good eyesight. Speaking of chipmunks, I used to have one shamelessly come to the window where I would put some peanuts out every day for jays and chickadees. This particular chipmunk just couldn't help himself and tapping on the window wouldn't stop him from stuffing his cheeks (he'd just look at me for a moment and then carry on with stuffing). I would have to literally open the window to get him to run off and save some for everyone else. However, as soon as I look away (my PC at home is next to the window), he'd be back stuffing his cheeks again. Perhaps it just couldn't see me that well, as you said, heh. Crows will craft and use tools in the wild[1]. Their intelligence always surprises me, though I think most of us are predisposed to assume birds are not that intelligent when compared to other animals. I used to think that myself before making the study of birds a hobby. Crows snip into the leaf edges and then tear out neat strips of vegetation with which they can probe insect-harboring crevices. These tools have been observed to come in three types: narrow strips, wide strips and multi-stepped strips—which are wide at one end and, via a manufacturing process that involves stepwise snips and tears, become narrow at the opposite end. Studies show that New Caledonian crows are capable of meta-tool use, at a level rivalling the best performances seen in primates. One such study involved putting food in a box out of the crows' reach. The crows were given a stick that was too short to reach the food. However, this short stick could be used to retrieve a longer stick from another box, which could then be used to retrieve the food. This complex behaviour involved the crow realising that a tool could be used on non-food objects, and suppressing the urge to go directly for the food. It was solved by six of seven birds on the first attempt. This behaviour had previously only been observed in primates. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Caledonian_crow https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_Caledonian_crow