5 ms·
Is Cultural Appropriation Always Wrong?
- venomsnake 11y agoI prefer the opposite approach - culture appropriation is fine and should be proven otherwise on case by case basis. Makes life more simple.
- djtriptych 11y agoMore simple for whom? Those who'd rather not think about it? This perspective likely varies widely based on the culture with which you identify. Some cultures have been explicitly exploited, generally along the same axes of privilege in modern life.
- debacle 11y agoCultural appropriation is just the outcome of cultures mixing. It's been a part of cultural intermingling for at least the last thousand years, and probably since forever. The problem with modern cultural appropriation is anemic cultural identities coupled with one-directional appropriation. But that's only a problem for some cultures.
- djtriptych 11y agoYeah so let's limit the discussion to "modern" appropriation. Is it fair for any culture to complain about this? Isn't it drastically easier for people of more privileged cultures to assume identities of less privileged cultures? Is that directionality ok?
- debacle 11y agoI honestly think that in the Internet age no one should claim ownership of a particular cultural phenomenon. Cultural identity in the world is the weakest it has ever been, and as we homogenize our upbringings more and more through digital means, culture and ethnicity will matter less and less.
- djtriptych 11y agoThe Internet is 20 years old. Calm down lol. Also does humanity win when cultural tradition, cultural _information_ is lost forever? Are we sure we are capturing all that is useful? Is it really inevitable or could we _choose_ to assign more value to the preservation of extant culture?
- venomsnake 11y ago> More simple for whom? Those who'd rather not think about it? For the people that know that you cannot own a culture and there is no central authority which to determine how it can be used.
- djtriptych 11y agoYour position requires exactly zero definable instances of negative cultural appropriation. Can you really defend that position? Can you defend the Nazi's co-opting the swastika, for instance? Can you explain why cultural appropriation tends to be directed along privilege vectors? Male-female / gay-straight / white-black / rich-poor / etc. No. Simpler (for you) not to consider these things :) Cultural interchange is inevitable yes, but is its effect on the human condition negligible? No. So why not talk about it.
- venomsnake 11y agoOf course I can defend the Nazi swastika - it looked badass and it was easily recognized. When you go to war having a badass easily identified symbol on your flags is efficient and boost morale. Also they didn't appropriate it because it was fucking Germanic to begin with. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fylfot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fylfot
- djtriptych 11y agobadass, easily recognized. These are subjective terms. YOU think the swastika is badass. YOU find it to be an "easily-recognizable" symbol (at the time of it's introduction). You can't prove things like that, so why do you believe this stuff? Why do you present it as fact?
- Nadya 11y ago>These are subjective terms. So? All culture is subjective. What is offensive in one culture can have a completely different meaning in other cultures [0]. Cultures are the result of human opinions and by definition that makes them subjective. Human interpretation of actions, symbols, words, or what have you that defines is a culture is the direct result of a group of peoples' collective opinions given to those actions, symbols, words, or what have you. Cultural appropriation is taking something away from a culture and trying to give it a new meaning, particularly with a meaning that the original group dislikes. Which is little more than "Our opinion on this thing came before your opinion. You're being rude by ignoring our opinion on this thing and we don't like that." [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V_sign#As_an_insult https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/V_sign#As_an_insult
- lwhalen 11y agoTo co-opt and mimic is completely normal human behavior that cuts across all cultures, nations, sub-groups, etc. The article even acknowledges this right up front, "It’s a truth only selectively acknowledged that all cultures are mongrel". The premise smells like just another manifestation of outrage-culture to drive clicks. Don't let your humanity be redirected into anger, downvotes, etc.
- djtriptych 11y agoViolent overthrow of other people can also be described as "normal human behavior" as is polyamory, and hunting and gathering. Is it ideal behavior? Is it civil? Your sense of smell smells like another manifestation of privilege. Don't allow yourself to believe you do not operate from a position of extreme privilege. Be human, but not delusional.
- venomsnake 11y agoThe fact that GP operates from a position of extreme privilege, doesn't mean that what he says is not true or invalid.
- djtriptych 11y agoTo the question of whether something is wrong, it being "normal human behavior" is not an argument for or against. Normal doesn't mean fair or right or harmless or good. That's what the article is about. So why did he say it?
- venomsnake 11y agoFair is meaningless in context of culture exchange. So is right. Harmless - in the majority of the cases it is. So is with good. A person whining against somebody using "his" culture, blindly ignores the fact that "his" culture is crossbreed that is constantly changing and evolving.
- 11y ago
- tunesmith 11y agoI think the difference between true appropriation and cultural borrowing is the level of inherent abuse - whether purposeful or not. And then it's more a matter of degree than black/white. So, wearing a native american headdress as a fashion accessory is more probably wrong; wearing cornrows as a fashion choice is not really all that wrong (at least, I haven't heard of cornrows being an actual cultural symbol, I just always thought it was a hairstyle); and a more recent example, yuppies drinking out of mason jars is very probably not a "wrong" appropriation of "poor" culture. The level of abuse can definitely be ignorant rather than purposeful - for instance, there might be good points about why a white person wearing cornrows might actually be wrong. The baldest examples of wrong appropriation have been the attempts to take meaningful cultural symbols and then deliberately pervert their meaning as a weapon. Possible examples are the pagan symbols of christmas, or the swastika - although it's unclear to me whether the nazi appropriation of that was a direct purposeful attack on the meaning of the eastern symbol.
- civilian 11y agoRich people drinking out of mason jars isn't cultural appropriation of poor class! IDK about your family, but my family is wealthier because we have a long habit of being frugal. There's no need to buy something new if you can use goo-be-gone on the leftover salsa jars. Fuck!
- djtriptych 11y agoIt's an absurd statement: "My family is wealthier because we have a habit of being frugal". How do you know poor people aren't frugal, let alone that they are _historically_ not frugal?
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- civilian 11y agoRight, I meant it as clarification for how my family got wealth, not as a reason why poor families are poor. "Civilian's family became wealthy because we had good jobs and were frugal with our money. As oppose to other families, who started a massively successful business."
- forgottenpass 11y agoThe concept of "Cultural Appropriation" (and the desire to avoid it) strikes me as something created out of benevolent racism that promotes cultural segregation. I understand not wanting to step on toes and put salt in old wounds, but telling me I can't (metaphorically) walk around other neighborhoods out of respect seems a bit much. Something has gone awfully wrong to get to this point and playing along instead of unwinding the stack is misguided.
- gizmo686 11y agoI think I might be mis-reading your comment but, to me, "cultural appropriation" sounds like a re-branding of integration. If would follow from this view that arguing against cultural appropriation is arguing for segregation.
- forgottenpass 11y agoI made a poor choice of words, as realize I could be conveying the the opposite of what I meant. I've re-written the line to better present that my thought that the drive to avoid cultural appropriation can look a lot like cultural segregation.
- djtriptych 11y agoThis is a false dichotomy.
- strangecasts 11y agoI was disappointed that the article seemed to enforce this dichotomy as well, by bringing up the possibility of asking the people in question: > But it has never been easier to proceed with good faith and Google, to seek out and respect context[...] and then seemingly striking it down with the Shamsie essay: > The moment you say, a male American writer can’t write about a female Pakistani, you are saying, Don’t tell those stories. but leaving out the part immediately preceding the quote: > But it should be clear that the response to this is for writers to write differently, to write better, to critique the power structures rather than propping them up, to move beyond stereotype—which you need to do for purely technical reasons, because the novel doesn’t much like stereotypes. which doesn't at all preclude discussion.
- civilian 11y agoCultural appropriation is a bunch of SJW & white-guilt bullshit. It's not wrong or an act of an oppressor, it's just how cultures collide. And there's nothing wrong with that.
- djtriptych 11y agoTotally bro
- civilian 11y agoI'm open to having a real conversation about this. Persuade me otherwise!
- Nadya 11y agoThe idea of cultural appropriation inevitably leads to racism by those who try to enforce some sort of moral code against it. If you don't look like most people of your culture - you're suddenly a racist. Even when you're just practicing your own culture. Anyone remember the story of the half-white, half-Japanese woman who was derided for culturally appropriating the Japanese because she, ethnically, looked closer to Caucasian/white than Japanese? I especially loved the part where the overly aggressive PC hate mob apologized to her. Except the apology never happened. Instead, they doubled down on her being in the wrong... Increasingly, learning about a culture is becoming "cultural appropriation" to the PC extremists. Identity politics, of all forms, is a disease - from what I have seen it has only ever lead to negativity and conflict.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- eduardoveiga 11y agoThere's no such thing as cultural appropriation.It's a nazi leftist concept.