4 ms·
I think there are two separate hierarchies, one based on wealth (desperate, nervous, coasting) and one on education (reads nothing, reads Time, reads The Econom
by pg 19y ago
I think there are two separate hierarchies, one based on wealth (desperate, nervous, coasting) and one on education (reads nothing, reads Time, reads The Economist). Hundreds of years ago the two hierarchies were tied together because only the rich could afford education. In the 20th century they drifted apart. The interesting question is whether they will converge again, pushed from the opposite direction-- i.e. not because wealth causes education, but because education causes wealth.
- ivankirigin 19y agoNo, they won't converge. It will get easier to live comfortably. With less effort required to live, fewer people will seek out education.
- __ 19y agoDo more people forgo education today than did in the past?
- pchristensen 19y agoMore people go to college now than ever. It's getting easier to live comfortably if you're educated. If you're not, it's getting harder and harder.
- ivankirigin 19y agoEducated != went to college, I'm afraid. Economics professors would probably be mortified by the number of economics grads that don't bother reading the economist. Getting harder and harder if you didn't go to college? Have you ever been to a best buy? It's getting easier and easier for someone of meager standing to have an entertainment center that only the rich could afford two decades ago.
- ivankirigin 19y agoCollege today is a lot about entertain and fun. Huge student centers, little emphasis on the "boring hard parts". It is inevitable that standards decrease as more people go to college to meet the ridiculous college-education requirement of button-pushing jobs.
- pg 19y agoStandards rise too, though. When I was poor I was way better off materially than most rich people were 200 years ago. But I still felt poor, and felt like I had to get a lot more money to have a comfortable life.
- rms 19y agoWe're still a long way from solving the logistical and sociological problem of getting food to everyone that is starving. Here's hoping that we converge towards that.
- wumi 19y agoI would argue that wealth causes wealth, and that's how its truly been for thousands of years. Although education can cause wealth in some cases (and only in the "developed" world at that) in most cases wealth is passed down generation to generation. Go to several "lesser developed" countries around the world, where people are educated to the tooth and are still not wealthy. Or go to our nation's universities and see the wealth (monetary not information and knowledge) there versus the corporate world (say Enron) where it is not education but greed that causes wealth.
- byrneseyeview 19y agoIf wealth causes wealth, why don't dynastic fortunes even keep up with inflation? The Kennedys are poorer than they were fifty years ago, the Rockefellers are poorer than they were 70 years ago, the Du Ponts have long since peaked, the Mellons are pretty marginal, etc., etc., etc. "Although education can cause wealth in some cases (and only in the "developed" world at that) in most cases wealth is passed down generation to generation." Empirically false. The US real GDP has more than doubled in the last thirty years, so half of our total wealth didn't even exist a generation ago.
- pchristensen 19y agoI agree. Wealth begets wealth, but unearned wealth begets expensive taste :) Looking at the uberwealthy is deceptive, because they're a product not only of their own skill and ambition but the circumstances where they made the fortune. 5 years earlier or later and Bill Gates wouldn't be a billionaire (ditto most computer billionaires - they were the right person in the right window of time). They are outliers, black swans, etc. Hard to make theories based on them. If you look at (to draw an arbitrary line) people making more than $100,000/yr, I'll bet they are either a) business owners or b) highly educated (college and above).
- wumi 19y agoFor example, 44% of all STEM degrees (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Mathematics) are going to foreign nationals, who comprise only 10% of all students studying domestically, yet that number is not reflected in the world-wide distribution of wealth. As the average person becomes more educated, there are and will be other barriers to wealth (isn't it not what you know, but WHO you know?) In fact, I would say Y Combinator recognizes and institutes those very principles: offering potential participants a network of expertise, mentoring, and access to venture capitalists the recipe for success doesn't seem to be based on education, or knowledge, but on wealth, and the proximity to that wealth. If you look at all these recent tech-made millionaires, one thing is strikingly similar: they knew someone wealthy who chipped in large amounts of cash. Do you think a Ph.D, or even a guy with a bachelor's half-way across the world will have access to this wealth (monetary or otherwise)? I don't think so.
- sayrer 19y agoThe Economist has gotten a lot dumber in the past 5-10 years.
- rms 19y agoThey still tell it like it is more than any other print publication I know of. Do you have something else you would recommend?
- sgoraya 19y agoI would recommend Harvard Business Review - The economist is still a good read in my opinion though; Similar to the argument that Economist is not as strong as prior years, people have been trashing Scientific American as well, saying that the content has diluted, but I'll keep reading it ;)
- falsestprophet 19y agoI think that The Economist is a much more than adequate source of news and (centrist libertarian) opinion. But, from time to time, I stop by my school's library to read some scholarly journals of political science and international affairs to try to understand a little more about how the world works. I think it is also valuable to read the work of non-mainstream thinkers. Noam Chomsky, in particular, says some important things (alongside some bizarre things to be sure). To be honest, I am much less familiar with and sympathetic to polar ultraright opinion. I recommend all of these things.
- rms 19y ago>Noam Chomsky, in particular, says some important things (alongside some bizarre things to be sure). I wish there was a publication of the anti-CFR set that wasn't fringe and crazy...
- asdflkj 19y ago"Like it is"? Have you read their "Case for War"? Thanks to the English magazine's clever rhetorical strategy, calibrating an effective mixture of aristocratic contempt, two-notches-smarter-than-Newsweek diction, and occasional anti-elitist populism to pander to its majority-American readership, readers trust The Economist. They - particularly American readers - trust it because they think it knows more than they do; this is its entire appeal. They even get a sick thrill being talked down to by a dirty old aristocratic prig. For Americans in particular, accustomed to the lifeless, dumbed-down, least-common-denominator prose in their own media, reading The Economist is its own reward, giving them the sense not only that they're smarter than the average Time subscriber, but that it even makes them vaguely decadent, in a literary-aristocratic sort of way. They become smarter by osmosis simply by being in the imagined drawing room of The Economist's wit-slinging editorial offices. http://www.exile.ru/articles/detail.php?ARTICLE_ID=10127&IBLOCK_ID=35&PAGE=1 http://www.exile.ru/articles/detail.php?ARTICLE_ID=10127&... The Exile, a tabloid though it may be, had predicted exactly what would happen in Iraq.
- far33d 19y agoIf you read Derrida, but work in a coffee shop, you are still upper class.
- deleted 19y ago[deleted]