7 ms·
>> The fact of the matter is in today’s state prisons, which hold about 90 percent of all of our prisoners, only 17 percent of the inmates are there primarily f
by Nursie 11y ago
>> The fact of the matter is in today’s state prisons, which hold about 90 percent of all of our prisoners, only 17 percent of the inmates are there primarily for drug charges. And about two-thirds are there for either property or violent crimes.
Hmmm. This is unsatisfying. How many are there for crimes that were committed to feed drug habits? How many for crimes related to but not directly involving drugs (turf wars, drug-money related offences etc)?
Sure, these are crimes and we should definitely still bring people committing these to justice, but I wonder how many just would not have happened without the WoD?
Clearly it's not the whole picture, but it might be a little more complex than the article makes out.
- iamzultan 11y ago>only 17 percent of the inmates are there primarily for drug charges. This is either false or misleading because of how it is worded. The percentage of people serving time in state prison for drug offenses is ~53% http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Prisons_and_Drugs#sthash.eHLcf6VP.dpbs http://www.drugwarfacts.org/cms/Prisons_and_Drugs#sthash.eHL...
- rayiner 11y agoYou're reading that source wrong (understandable because the wording is awkward). 53% is for violent crime.
- JackFr 11y agoFrom your source: Almost 16% of state prisoners were convicted drug offenders (208,000 inmates), including 24% of all females in state prison (22,000 inmates) and 15% of all males in state prison (186,000 inmates).
- swalsh 11y agoI'd guess most of these records are open to the public. Maybe it would be possible to use some AI to read the records, and collect better data?
- Nursie 11y agoI'm not sure why you'd be downvoted for saying that, it's not objectionable... But it might miss the point. Someone convicted of burglary may have been burgling to get money for their addiction. That may or may not be recorded. Although you might be right, maybe that sort of stuff is routinely recorded. I have no idea!
- swalsh 11y agoI'd guess if they have court transcripts, or some kind of description in a plea deal, it's possible it was mentioned. That might be valuable data, but having a person scrape through that data would take ages. I too am confused why I was down-voted, but i guess you can't please everyone :\
- maxerickson 11y agoThe BJS studies it: http://www.bjs.gov/content/dcf/duc.cfm http://www.bjs.gov/content/dcf/duc.cfm
- derekp7 11y agoDon't need an AI, just use a statistically valid random sample, then use human intelligence to analyze that smaller data set.
- GolfyMcG 11y agoAdditionally, I don't like the percent increases on absolute numbers. I feel like some normalized data (either per capita, or per capita in specific metropolitan areas) would be very helpful. Ie. Fake example, The crime in San Francisco shot up by 400% - woah! So much more crime. The population in San Francisco also shot up by 10,000%. Oh, so you're telling me that the ratio of criminals to non-criminals dropped by 95%?
- GolfyMcG 11y agoPs. I don't know why I expect a better analysis from this article since it's in Slate...
- skwirl 11y agoHaving seen the numbers, they are actually referring to the crime rate, and not raw crimes.
- JackFr 11y agoYour cognitive bias is showing. Common sense should tell you that a 400% increase is outstripping population growth, but here are the numbers: US population went from 183M to 252M during that period.
- talmand 11y ago>> Ie. Fake example
- mason240 11y ago>How many are there for crimes that were committed to feed drug habits? Legalizing drugs will not make them free, and they will still lead to addiction.
- Nursie 11y ago>> Legalizing drugs will not make them free, and they will still lead to addiction. Indeed they will. But if addicts have easier access to medically supervised maintenance doses (for instance), without risking jail time, then there may be less crime committed to feed these habits. Stuff I've seen has suggested that (for instance) when heroin users know where their next hit is coming from (the clinic) they are better able to handle their addiction and able to make some progress in the rest of life (hold down a job, etc). I'm not saying I definitely have all the answers, the picture is complex.
- rayiner 11y agoLegalizing drugs are one thing (though 80-90% of Americans still oppose legalization for stuff like heroin). Spending non-prison public dollars on peoples' heroin addiction (while potentially a good idea), will never happen in the U.S. before the heat death of the universe.
- zardo 11y agoYou would still have non-profits willing to provide treatment, even if the government is unable to do anything.
- vidarh 11y agoThe cost of medical heroin to feed the typical daily consumption of heroin for an addict costs in the $10-$20 range, as far as I remember. We know the costs because because heroin is manufactured and regularly prescribed as a pain killer in a number of countries, e.g. in the UK you sometime get diamorphine (heroin) prescriptions for post-operative pain. In other words, even if it was not paid for, but just made available on prescription, chances are substantial proportion of users would be able to afford to maintain their addiction without much, if any, crime.
- zombees 11y agoI thought the same thing and I totally agree that this should be covered. Thinking more about it though, the media has kinda clung to The War on Drugs any time they need to fill airtime and any time it comes up, they're pretty hand wavy about the underlying statistics. If someone had hard data on this that clearly supported WoD accusation, I feel like I would have seen it already.
- roc 11y agoWhat I wonder is how many people were originally detained/investigated because of the WoD, but arrested/prosecuted for the non-drug offenses. (i.e. resisting, gambling, tax evasion, etc.) Unless you know why these people were in front of the cops to begin with, you can't speak to whether any given policy change will or won't affect arrest or imprisonment rates. e.g. Stop-and-Frisk is a War on Terror policy, but regularly results in weapons and drug charges. Are the people ultimately sentenced for those offenses in prison because of weapon or drug laws, or anti-terror laws?
- rayiner 11y agoStop and Frisk is not a war on terror policy. It's a "New York used to be Gotham City in the 1990's"-era policy.
- happyscrappy 11y agoNY was Gotham City. Why is there so much animosity for the 'Broken Windows' policy when it clearly worked?
- roc 11y agoBecause cities without New York's policies saw the same drop in crime?
- happyscrappy 11y agoChicago?
- JackFr 11y ago> Hmmm. This is unsatisfying. It's unsatisfying not because it's wrong, but because it replaces a tidy narrative, (a narrative which suggests a public policy many of us would like to support) with "it's complicated". I think you have the picture reversed -- the article is saying the problem is nuanced and complex when we'd rather believe it was simply the war on drugs.
- Nursie 11y ago>> I think you have the picture reversed -- the article is saying the problem is nuanced and complex when we'd rather believe it was simply the war on drugs. I disagree. I think it's unsatisfying because it naively minimises the wider effects of the WoD. I'm not American so I don't really have a vested interest in your prison population and why it's there, I only really know that compared to your population size it's huge. I am quite pedantic though, and it looked to me like firstly it wasn't complete in its reasoning and secondly like 300K people out of 1.7M is still a very significant amount.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 11y agoRayiner's comment seems like a strong rebuttal to this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10319918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10319918
- Nursie 11y agoIt doesn't have a strong rebuttal, because it doesn't actually have any exact figures. It has trends which suggest it's of little relevance, sure, but nothing particularly concrete. For all we know the homicide rate in the mid 80s (for example) may have dropped to a historic low without the WoD.
- tptacek 11y agoDoesn't that require you to argue that transitioning from "no war on drugs" to "war on drugs" back to "no war on drugs" would reduce the murder rate, lower than it was before the war on drugs? If not, can you help me understand why?
- rayiner 11y agoThe problem with the "drug war causes violent crime" theory is the timeline. Here is a graph of U.S. violent crime rate from 1960: http://www.newgeography.com/files/cox-crime-3.png http://www.newgeography.com/files/cox-crime-3.png. Here is a graph of just homicide rate since 1900: http://madeinamericathebook.files.wordpress.com/2010/05/homicides-1900-20062.jpg?w=430&h=340 http://madeinamericathebook.files.wordpress.com/2010/05/homi.... Violent crime was steady up to about 1960 then started spiking up in the 1960's until about 1995. The homicide rate at its peak in the 1990's was only about 25% higher than what it was in 1900, long before prohibition or the drug war. The modern controlled substances act was passed in 1970, and drug war spending started ramping up through the 1970's, and didn't really get going until the second half of the 1980's: http://blurbrain.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/drugs-vs-spending.jpg http://blurbrain.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/09/drugs-vs-spe.... So what does the data tell us? Crime started spiking up about 10 years before the drug war even started. The big jump in drug war spending in the 1980's happened after two decades of rising crime, when crime rates were already near their peak. So if anything, the federal drug war (or peoples' appetite to wage it) seems to be a reaction to rising crime, rather than a cause. Now, you could also say rising crime was the result of prohibition itself, not just the drug war per se. But narcotics began to be heavily regulated and effectively banned in 1915: http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/library/studies/cu/cu8.html http://www.druglibrary.org/schaffer/library/studies/cu/cu8.h.... Now, compare crime rate to incarceration rate and the timeline of the drug war: https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/48/U.S._incarceration_rates_1925_onwards.png https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/48/U.S._inc.... The incarceration rate is basically flat until 1975. By that time violent crime had increased by over 2.5x. The mind-blowing thing is that our incarceration rate doesn't catch up to our crime rate until after 1995! I.e. even though our incarceration rate quadruples from 1950 to 1995, in that time violent crime more than quadruples. It's only after the big drop in crime in the late 1990's that our incarceration rate started to become disproportionate to our violent crime rate.
- Nursie 11y agoThe problem with using trends, IMHO, rather than actual recorded figures, is that you may miss out on what's going on beneath the pretty lines and curves. I ain't saying you're wrong because I don't have the figures to rebut that. I'm not even saying that the WoD is the major cause of violent crime, definitively, because I don't have those figures either. Literally all I'm trying to say is that the analysis in the article seems short-sighted and incomplete because it only takes into account convictions directly for drug offences.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoOr cases where an initial arrest for something non-violent (such as drugs) resulted in a drastic change in life course, such as losing their job and making it very hard to find legal work, after which (combined with what they learned in prison the first time) resulted in them turning to property/violent crimes?