3 ms·
> "Making email and PGP easier to use is not only a UX issue." Yes, but UX is still the biggest issue. By all means develop next gen crypto tech: but first, ma
by nailer 11y ago
> "Making email and PGP easier to use is not only a UX issue."
Yes, but UX is still the biggest issue. By all means develop next gen crypto tech: but first, make what we have now usable by people who aren't Unix people.
I would pay money for binaries of an Open Source GnuPG for OS X which wasn't awful to use.
Not in a tarball, not assuming I want to use the command line, on gnupg.org (with the angry SHA1 certificate warning fixed), not linked to from there for 'people who want GUIs'.
- hedgehog 11y agoThe problem runs deeper than UX in plugins for mail clients. Offline key exchange is inconvenient enough that it prevents GPG from being used as encrypted-by-default mail. Identity and key management is really the underlying issue, something in the spirit of CONIKS might be good enough to build a working system though. As OP points out even then you have issues with multi-device support.
- Programmatic 11y ago> Offline key exchange is inconvenient enough that it prevents GPG from being used as encrypted-by-default mail. I would love to simply sync users' keys between their devices and encrypt opportunistically like OTR does. Offline key exchange would only be necessary for verification purposes at that point. I see user key management as the harder problem than exchange.
- nailer 11y ago> The problem runs deeper than UX in plugins for mail clients. UX runs deeper than software interfaces. > Identity and key management is really the underlying issue Yes, that's a UX issue. So: - Get GPG key from Facebook (which has them as part of the standard profile today) - Say to person: you should contact this person by a means you trust and confirm this is their key (since we don't trust anyone by default). - Once they click OK, they can now send messages to that person. Nothing stopping other mainstream sites from adding GPG, it's jus that FB is the only one I know of. Obviously GitHub doesn't count since most people aren't software developers.
- zbyte64 11y agoWhich brings us back to trusting a 3rd party to not tamper with the key exchange...
- nailer 11y agoWell yeah, that's why I addressed it in the post you're replying to. Offline key confirmation is still the best bet for most people, it's just that people don't use it because they don't use crypto because crypto tools are awful.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- digi_owl 11y agoWhile offline exchange is needed for proper security, for casual snoopers having a the clients generate the pair, embed the public in every outgoing, grab publics from incoming, and encrypt by default for outgoing from that point on, would be a major step up from the status quo.
- aroch 11y agoThat's what GPGTools is for (formally MacGPG): https://gpgtools.org/opensource.html https://gpgtools.org/opensource.html (You can build and use your own gpg binaries if you're concerned about their modifications)
- nailer 11y agoGPGTools is precisely the awful state of current of affairs I'm talking about. - GPGTools isn't sure what's called. GPGTools? OK where do I download GPGTools? There's no button to do that. What's GPGSuite? Do I want that instead? Installed, there's nothing called either Applications/GPGTools or Applications/GPG Suite. - Its app is called 'GPG keychain' or similar. Nobody outside crypto folk care know what a keychain or, not should knowledge of a keychain app be required to send someone a message encrypted with their public key - The apps main focus is key management, and it's really poor at that. There's no way to discover people's GPG keys AFAICT - It's a plugin for Apple Mail and a command line app. Most people using Macs don't use either of those. And it's not promoted as a Mac mail plugin, which means most people will be disappointed when they use it. - It seems to choke on common GPG output with some chars. That output is probably not encoded correctly, that shouldn't matter. Be liberal in what you accept.
- aroch 11y ago1) If installing something is enough of a hurdle that you can't complete it, then no amount of simplification beyond bundling is going to solve that 2) Everyone and their mother understand that keychains hold keys. You have to get to a key somehow, the onboarding process is a simple wizard. Again, if you can't follow prompts to enter an email, enter a password, and wiggle your mouse around; no amount of simplification is going to solve the problem. 3) You use the search for key button... 4) I'd argue that the vast majority of Mac users, especially the ones that are not technically inclined enough to use GPG on cli but want to, use the built in Mail.app. 5) gpg seems to have a slew of text encoding gotchas, I'm not sure how those can be fixed without a lot of core dev effort
- oceanofsolaris 11y ago