4 ms·
Ok, so this is taking on the feeling of an Internet Meme, "Your <noun> has less/more <property> than the testing said it had." Is there anyone here who doesn't
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Ok, so this is taking on the feeling of an Internet Meme, "Your <noun> has less/more <property> than the testing said it had."
Is there anyone here who doesn't believe if you make a testable property a price effecting feature of a product, the manufacturer will find a way to optimize for the property value they want, at the expense of the consumer or testing agency?
- guscost 11y agoEven that is just a special case of Goodhart's law: > When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart's_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart's_law
- modoc 11y agoInterestingly many auto manufacturers UNDERSTATE horsepower and torque numbers. I can understand that a little, due to variances in actual engines, but these days that variance is low and the spread between specced power and dyne'ed power is pretty big on many cars.
- famousactress 11y agoI'd always heard that was to keep insurance premiums lower for those cars, but have no idea whether that's true.
- drglitch 11y agoAlmost no manufacturers do it - historically, BMW and MB have been "caught" doing this, with 335i and C-class AMG engines. A commonly accepted explanation for this is that the "cheaper" model is made to appear less powerful on paper to entire a buyer to upgrade to next model up (i.e. M3). Relevant tests from 2010 ~ when this meme started: http://www.automobilemag.com/reviews/driven/1009_bmw_335i_335is_dyno_test/%20-%20/ http://www.automobilemag.com/reviews/driven/1009_bmw_335i_33... In reality, almost all cars "produce" far less ponies at the wheels than stated on spec sheets because HP is "[S]ampled [A]t [E]ngine" - so by time it reaches your wheels, about 20-30% are lost to drive train. Edit: formatting
- matthewmcg 11y agoYou're correct, but one minor point: SAE is actually an abbreviation for "Society of Automotive Engineers," a standards and certifying body. The difference you are describing is between "gross" horsepower (SAE J1995 spec.), essentially horsepower measured at an unloaded crankshaft and "net" horsepower (SAE 1349 spec.) or the horsepower measured at the wheels.[1] The difference is due to drivetrain losses and power used to drive non-engine components. [1] See http://www.edmunds.com/car-technology/horsepower-gross-vs-real-world.html http://www.edmunds.com/car-technology/horsepower-gross-vs-re...
- rconti 11y agoThere was the supposed Japanese "Gentleman's agreement" of 276 (286?)HP to keep the government off their backs. There's also the common saying "German horses are stronger" because acceleration and dyno tests (long before the turbo 335) have shown them to be faster than they "should" be, in particular to certain American muscle cars. I'm not sure how much reality there is behind this, though.
- beeboop 11y agoWhat you might be thinking about is the agreement between manufacturers to not make motorcycle top speeds more than 300KPH (186MPH). There are no limits on horsepower, though, and the top speeds are simply electronically limited. This also has no relation to car models.
- jimjimjim 11y agoNo, there WAS an agreement between Japanese car makers to limit the HP of their vehicles. Even the GTRs, Evos and Imprezas left the factory with approximately the the same stated HP figures. They could then be reasonably easily tuned to produce ludicrous amounts of power.
- grecy 11y agoBoth of you commenting in this chain are correct. The Japanese "gentleman's agreement" was a limit on power of 207Kw. Towards the end, many of the cars hit by this were making more than that at the wheels, let alone the crank. It was possible to gain 50Kw on certain WRXes and Evos with a different air intake and exhaust, they were so restricted. Also, for a while there was an "agreement" that sports bikes wouldn't go faster than 300km/h - they didn't limit them, the end of the speedo was 300km/h. Lots of R1s and Hyabusas will be revving somewhere in the middle of their rev range at 300km/h in top gear, then you can wind on another 4-5-6 thousand rpm, while the speedo stays pegged at 300km/h. You are, of course, going faster than that.
- snaily 11y ago
- buro9 11y agoThere are big differences in the impact of misleading tests though. For a TV, meh. It's a little more energy used, and financially barely is noticeable by the owner. When you're done it's essentially disposable. For the cars though... oh wow. It hits taxation levels in some countries, and fuel cost everywhere. It hits resale value, which likely hits financing companies. It actually causes additional pollution in crowded cities. It crosses thresholds in which large swathes of the market would choose not to purchase the vehicle based on those numbers (business leases). Everyone knows that advertised numbers are approximations based on ideal conditions on a very small sample. The question is really how misleading those approximations are, and what the impact is on the consumer and any third parties.
- marze 11y agoThe whole point of testing is to give consumers data, so if the test can be gamed by companies like Samsung, it is a bad test. There are so many TVs and they run so many hours a day the aggregate energy use is non-negligible. Consumers should avoid products from firms that game tests such as these. Toyota, for example, was singled out in the fuel consumption report as a company that did not cheat on the tests.
- Asbostos 11y agoAny kind of improvement motivated by the test is kind of "gaming" the test. There's no clear boundary line between optimizing for test conditions and optimizing for something broader. I think the onus is on the designers of the tests to make sure they reflect realistic use. It can't help but be a cat and mouse game but at least the effects of cheating can be reduced to small enough levels that it's OK. An analogy is a student studying for the exam. That's gaming it somewhat too. The exam is supposed to test what they learnt during the semester and retained over a long period, not what they crammed the night before and will forget by next week.
- at-fates-hands 11y ago>> Ok, so this is taking on the feeling of an Internet Meme. Maury Povich meme : http://memegenerator.net/Maury-Povich-Lol http://memegenerator.net/Maury-Povich-Lol
- TeMPOraL 11y agoThis recent string of news stories makes me wonder, how many other products do also cheat on tests like this? Does this mean that our energy usage projections are seriously underestimated, and we're even more fucked than we thought?