3 ms·
You describe them as workarounds, but often this the intended design. If you only have manual control, then perhaps a driveshaft must be made larger and heavier
by HeyLaughingBoy 17y ago
You describe them as workarounds, but often this the intended design. If you only have manual control, then perhaps a driveshaft must be made larger and heavier for the case of the ham-fisted user. If the transmission is under software control, the software can be careful about accelerations to avoid overstressing the driveshaft.
The point is that when you consider the system as "mechanical, electrical and software" you get a lot more flexibility than if you think of it as "mechanical and electrical" but we do some stuff in software.
- djcapelis 17y agoCertainly I agree the system is more complex and we could have designed it to work this way. But the stark reality was that these components were supposed to be wired a certain way in our design and the drive system was supposed to stand up to a lot more torque, as per the intended design. So I think it is fair to call these particular fixes workarounds. Your point that it is silly to look at these systems as anything other than integrated (often quite deeply) is well taken however. The fact that one can fix a mechanical defect using the software section of the system speaks volumes about just how integrated they are.