3 ms·
I have a form of cystic fibrosis. People with cystic fibrosis sometimes die from infections that normal people simply do not get. I looked up some of these infe
by Mz 11y ago
I have a form of cystic fibrosis. People with cystic fibrosis sometimes die from infections that normal people simply do not get. I looked up some of these infections, and some of them are used by scientists to biodegrade petrochemical spills because they eat petrochemicals. Plastics come from petrochemicals.
So I quit driving and I avoid styrofoam, etc. My hypothesis is that people with CF get these infections because we hang onto petrochemical residues greater than average. I want as little as possible to do with them. I have gradually gotten healthier.
Based on that, my guess is that if you do not have CF and do not have an inordinately high level of plastics/petrochemicals in your system, you are probably not at risk from microorganisms that biodegrade such things. For most humans, these microogarnisms are not dangerous. In fact, some of the infections that kill people with CF are incredibly common -- literally as common as dirt and found in dirt -- and are generally deemed harmless to normal humans.
- AnthonBerg 11y agoI have a hunch that my psoriasis is in some way related to plastics or plasticizers.
- Mz 11y agoOne way to test your hypothesis is to start reducing your exposure to soft plastics and materials that offgas VOCs at high rates. See if that makes any difference. However, do realize that common wisdom in alternative medicine groups (and South American tribal medicine men, etc) is that first the bad stuff has to come out. Kind of like with drug withdrawal, if this helps, it will get worse before it gets better. Much like drug withdrawal, that interim transition stage can be hellish. I do consume sodas sold in 2 liter bottles. So I don't completely avoid all plastics. But I try like hell to avoid styrofoam and other soft plastics. When offered a choice at the deli, I ask for the hard plastic container instead of the styrofoam one. /unsolicited advice
- zo1 11y ago"One way to test your hypothesis is to start reducing your exposure to soft plastics and materials that offgas VOCs at high rates. See if that makes any difference." No, that's a very bad way to test your hypothesis. Assuming your goal is to really get to the root of a problem, you really shouldn't be allowing/asking individuals to test their ideas on themselves. Have you spoken to doctors about your issues with plastics? It could very well be that your problem is to do with something else, but you're masking it by making premature assumptions based on what you think might be the cause. Perhaps even on faulty causal links that could do with some domain-knowledge, rather than guessing.
- Mz 11y agoI have a completely different condition than psoriasis. Someone else replied that they think their psoriasis is related to plastics. I made a suggestion on how they can explore their own hypothesis about their own condition, if they so choose/desire. I am not asking anyone to test my hypothesis about my condition.
- zo1 11y agoThat's what I was referring to: >"I have a form of cystic fibrosis. People with cystic fibrosis sometimes die from infections that normal people simply do not get. I looked up some of these infections, and some of them are used by scientists to biodegrade petrochemical spills because they eat petrochemicals. Plastics come from petrochemicals." You self-diagnosed based on what appears to be a rather shaky link. And it appeared like you were suggesting to the other person to do the same for their condition because of an argument that appears to look like this: P1. "People with cystic fibrosis sometimes die from infections a,b,c" P2. "Some of the a,b,c 'infections' are used by scientist to biodegrade petrochemical spills" P3. "Plastics come from petrochemicals" P4. "People with CF hang on to petrochemicals (why? because of their condition?)" C1. Therefore plastics make cystic fibrosis worse. or C2. Avoiding plastics makes cystic fibrosis symptoms better. Either way, shaky links means assumptions are being made. Rather seek medical attention, or at the very least read the literature regarding any causal links between these things.