6 ms·
I think the real scary question is what happens if we do. One of the main reasons we use plastics is because they are great barriers against bacteria and other
by munificent 11y ago
I think the real scary question is what happens if we do.
One of the main reasons we use plastics is because they are great barriers against bacteria and other grossness. We wrap food in plastic, put dirty diapers and dog poop in plastic, put garbage in plastic, wrap raw meat in plastic, use plastic for medical equipment. All because it reliably keeps out (or in) the bad stuff.
What happens if there are plastic-eating bacteria all over the world? Imagine what it would feel like if everywhere we currently used plastic we were using uncoated paper instead? What kind of sanitization problems would we be experiencing?
- smt88 11y agoAssuming they're not airborne and can't live long away from specific environment(s), this wouldn't be a problem. Also, there are plenty of other things to hold food that can be used instead of plastic. I doubt sanitation would be the main problem.
- novaleaf 11y ago"Nature finds a way"
- pyrocat 11y ago"Life ᵘʰ finds a way"
- novaleaf 11y agoAhh, my movie quote mastery skills pale compared to you. (also HN markup skills it seems)
- wyldfire 11y agoIt's funny you should bring that line up -- "The Andromeda Strain" (also by Crichton) features a microbe that's able to decompose plastics and rubbers.
- novaleaf 11y agoI suppose it's a well traveled trope. To quote Aristotle: "Nature abhors a vacuum"
- mediaman 11y agoIt's pretty easy to defeat this. No bacteria would likely be able to indiscriminately consume all different types of plastic, regardless of the substantial differences in molecular composition. It is very common in the plastics industry to make multi-layered plastics (for things like oxygen barriers to protect meat, for example), so it would be a simple task of producing film with a thin layer of nonconsumable plastic protecting the consumable material.
- jakob223 11y agoBut then we're back where we started, with materials that can't be easily decomposed and stay in landfills forever.
- yincrash 11y agoTo degrade the plastic, all you need is mechanical action (shred) to increase the surface area of the edible plastic. 98% biodegradability is better than 0.
- Mz 11y agoI have a form of cystic fibrosis. People with cystic fibrosis sometimes die from infections that normal people simply do not get. I looked up some of these infections, and some of them are used by scientists to biodegrade petrochemical spills because they eat petrochemicals. Plastics come from petrochemicals. So I quit driving and I avoid styrofoam, etc. My hypothesis is that people with CF get these infections because we hang onto petrochemical residues greater than average. I want as little as possible to do with them. I have gradually gotten healthier. Based on that, my guess is that if you do not have CF and do not have an inordinately high level of plastics/petrochemicals in your system, you are probably not at risk from microorganisms that biodegrade such things. For most humans, these microogarnisms are not dangerous. In fact, some of the infections that kill people with CF are incredibly common -- literally as common as dirt and found in dirt -- and are generally deemed harmless to normal humans.
- AnthonBerg 11y agoI have a hunch that my psoriasis is in some way related to plastics or plasticizers.
- Mz 11y agoOne way to test your hypothesis is to start reducing your exposure to soft plastics and materials that offgas VOCs at high rates. See if that makes any difference. However, do realize that common wisdom in alternative medicine groups (and South American tribal medicine men, etc) is that first the bad stuff has to come out. Kind of like with drug withdrawal, if this helps, it will get worse before it gets better. Much like drug withdrawal, that interim transition stage can be hellish. I do consume sodas sold in 2 liter bottles. So I don't completely avoid all plastics. But I try like hell to avoid styrofoam and other soft plastics. When offered a choice at the deli, I ask for the hard plastic container instead of the styrofoam one. /unsolicited advice
- zo1 11y ago"One way to test your hypothesis is to start reducing your exposure to soft plastics and materials that offgas VOCs at high rates. See if that makes any difference." No, that's a very bad way to test your hypothesis. Assuming your goal is to really get to the root of a problem, you really shouldn't be allowing/asking individuals to test their ideas on themselves. Have you spoken to doctors about your issues with plastics? It could very well be that your problem is to do with something else, but you're masking it by making premature assumptions based on what you think might be the cause. Perhaps even on faulty causal links that could do with some domain-knowledge, rather than guessing.
- pixl97 11y agoCoal... Or I should say lignin was once like plastic. Nothing could break it down, and huge coal formations were formed because of it. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/mushroom-evolution-breaks-down-lignin-slows-coal-formation/ http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/mushroom-evolution... But, nothing lasts forever. There will come a day when plastics can be broken down much more easily than they are now.
- lostlogin 11y agoDeal with it like the food industry does. Put antibiotics into/onto plastics.
- duaneb 11y ago> Imagine what it would feel like if everywhere we currently used plastic we were using uncoated paper instead? Probably what it feels like now when people predominantly use paper bags and paper wrap. Plastic is great, material-wise, but it's hardly our single defense against health problems.
- MengerSponge 11y agoThese bacteria aren't going to be Andromeda-strain like superbugs that can eat through plastic in seconds. Plastic that is dense and strongly crosslinked will take much longer to decompose, fortunately. Instead of uncoated paper, what about waxed paper? It's impermeable on a reasonably long timescale, and is fully biodegradable too.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoIt doesn't have to happen that fast to be bad. Such bacteria would be like rust to metal. A lot of our things are based on plastics; it would not be good if suddenly everything started to "rust" and break.
- userbinator 11y agoThen again, some companies might like the fact that it could be another form of forced obolescence... Personally, the inertness of plastics really suggests recycling and reusing; it's somewhat sad that we've invented materials that can last almost forever, and yet so many people are treating them as disposable and creating waste in the process.
- TeMPOraL 11y agoI was thinking more along the lines of contagious plastic-eating rust destroying civilization by attrition, but yours is a scary thought as well. As for plastic waste, I just vented out about it yesterday. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10308556 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10308556.
- hinkley 11y agoThe best example would be cars, especially the bits that get wet and stay wet. Also, don't forget what the clearcoat is.
- technotony 11y agoThere are already plenty of microbes which have evolved to eat plastic in the sea [1]. Luckerly for us Nature finds a way, as otherwise the ocean would be in even worse shape than it is. [1] http://news.discovery.com/earth/oceans/plastic-eating-microbes-help-marine-debris-sink-140619.htm http://news.discovery.com/earth/oceans/plastic-eating-microb...