3 ms·
Rational people tend to be progressive and "left leaning" (by American standards; by world standards this country is a right-wing powder keg). The sheer idiocy
by bitwize 11y ago
Rational people tend to be progressive and "left leaning" (by American standards; by world standards this country is a right-wing powder keg). The sheer idiocy of the American right is certainly relevant to hackers as an interesting and difficult problem, just like the housing situation in San Francisco or that malaria and Alzheimer's continue to exist.
- pauleastlund 11y agoI rarely take the time to comment on HN or submit content but I'm occasionally really tempted to earn enough karma that I can down-vote arrogant, condescending, asinine posts like this one. Neither side of the political spectrum has anything like a monopoly on "rational people" and "the sheer idiocy of [people who disagree with bitwize]" is not "relevant to hackers as an interesting and difficult problem."
- hfourm 11y agoWell... I am not agreeing that his comment was a bit cray. But isn't it common knowledge that generally more educated areas of the country are also more "progressive/left leaning"? Obviously there are exceptions, but even an intelligent man can cling to the wrong idea ;)
- 0xFFC 11y agoThat is not true . At least in my experience . All the rational people I've ever met in my whole life was liberal and big chunk of them were disappointed in political system (which makes them out of spectrum in left side ). For example even Noam Chomsky (which is far left in today US definition) prefer Obama (despite he knows Obama is just another politician who work for wall street instead of people ,but at least he is not going to put country in danger) to some crazy person at the other hand. I was fairly disappointed when I saw that comment down voted in HN . And I am from other country , I can see (in compare to my country) how exactly Right wing using deceive people with its control over money/media. About the monopoly maybe your left wing is Clinton ( which don't have any monopoly on rational people , because all know she is clown of wall street) , but true left wing (like Lessig Lawrence / Bernie Sanders / etc ) completely have monopoly on rational people in compare to right side , specially academic people in human science branches.
- maratd 11y ago> Rational people tend to be progressive and "left leaning" Rational people tend to be rational. And rational people don't dismiss the views of others because they don't share them.
- ansible 11y agoRational people tend to be rational. And rational people don't dismiss the views of others because they don't share them. Well, rational people can and should dismiss the views of others because they don't share them... if they've taken the time to investigate the validity of those views. Isn't that the point of being rational?
- maratd 11y ago> Well, rational people can and should dismiss the views of others because they don't share them... if they've taken the time to investigate the validity of those views. You can only make that kind of a conclusion assuming two things: 1. Perfect information. You are aware of everything there is to know which might be tangential to the matter at hand. 2. Identical environment. You share the same exact circumstances as everyone else. Neither #1 nor #2 are ever true. You never know everything there is to know. Frequently, we know very little and more important, what little we know doesn't overlap with the knowledge of others. So every person has a little bit, never the entire picture, and we all have very different little bits. We also don't exist in the same environment. We have vastly different backgrounds, circumstances, motivations, etc. which lead to wildly diverging self-interests. When you dismiss the views of others because you don't share them, you're not being rational ... you're just being stupid.
- ansible 11y agoYou can only make that kind of a conclusion assuming two things: 1. Perfect information. You are aware of everything there is to know which might be tangential to the matter at hand. Perfect information is not at all necessary for rational thought. There's a whole field of research about probabilistic reasoning that helps with that. 2. Identical environment. You share the same exact circumstances as everyone else. That's really just a special case of point 1. When you dismiss the views of others because you don't share them, you're not being rational ... you're just being stupid. That's not what I said, either. I explicitly talked about investigating those views. Suppose my friend comes up to me and says "Blue cars are more reliable than red cars." I inquire further as to how he came up with that statement, and he gives me nothing useful. "Its just my opinion / feeling / premonition / whatever." Is it rational for me to believe my friend's statement? No, because there is no evidence. Now suppose that one of the workers in the car factory hates the color red. And he's been subtly sabotaging those, and taking extra time to make sure the blue ones are better. There's that perfect information you're talking about that I'm missing. However, even in that case, should I be believing my friend's statement about blue cars? No, because I don't have evidence, and neither did he. Until someone collects at least some evidence, it isn't reasonable for me to believe that blue cars are more reliable, because I don't have any basis in theory (that the color blue can actually affect mechanical reliability) or in practice (the statistics for the cars)... even though my friend's statement is actually true. Rationality is a tool we use to discern truth from falseness. But we still have to do the work.
- msandford 11y ago> The sheer idiocy of the American right Yes conservatives bad, progressives good. Except when it comes to tax policy, right? Because SV wouldn't exist at all if the investment returns were taxed at a 50%-80% rate. Then instead of looking for a 1000x unicorn, everyone would be hunting 5000x-10000x unicorns. Which are rarer still.
- aaronbrethorst 11y ago> Because SV wouldn't exist at all if the investment returns were taxed at a 50%-80% rate I suggest looking up how long term capital gains work, and what top tax rates for cap gains have been in the past (hint: much higher than today—even under Reagan). No one has ever suggested taxing cap gains "at a 50%-80% rate".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]