3 ms·
We still don't know what consciousness is. So I think it's naive to state that it's "just a question of time" before we can simulate it.
by scott_s 17y ago
We still don't know what consciousness is. So I think it's naive to state that it's "just a question of time" before we can simulate it.
- rbanffy 17y agoNow knowing exactly what it is does not preclude one from speculating whether it could be simulated on a computer. Unless consciousness involves some magical phenomena, it's all physics and physics can be simulated on a computer.
- scott_s 17y agoSaying "it's just a matter of time" is not speculating whether it could be simulated. It's assuming that it can, and saying that it's inevitable. Consciousness is probably an emergent phenomenon of some kind. But until we know exactly what physical processes cause the emergence, then we have no way of knowing if our simulation will encompass it. Without that knowledge it's just a guessing game if our simulation is sufficient. My own personal guess is that attaining that knowledge will require an upheaval somewhere in science orthodoxy - much like solving the black body radiation problem required an upheaval in physics in the form of quantum mechanics. Such disruptive discoveries are inherently unpredictable. Hence, I think it's naive to claim that simulating consciousness is inevitable since we can't predict when we'll even understand it.
- rbanffy 17y agoBut if it's only physics, then it can be simulated and if it can be simulated, then it is a matter of time until someone cracks it and makes it work. Your mind is already running on your meatware brain. There are no magical properties to it. We may not understand them all fully, but that too is a matter of time, since there are no magical entities at work within it either.
- scott_s 17y agoWe're going in circles. My point, stated as simply as I can: since understanding what exactly consciousness is will probably require an upheaval in scientific knowledge, it is naive to say it is "simply a matter of time." It's possible that we will never figure it out, that the necessary scientific upheaval will never happen. Further, since what is required is unknown, it's possible that nothing we are ever capable of building will be up to the task. I am only willing to use the phrase "it's a matter of time" on scientific and technological improvements that are iterative. This is not iterative. It is disruptive. Also, it's not a given that all physics can be simulated. We have never encountered a non-computable physical phenomenon, but we also can not prove that all physical phenomenon is computable.
- rbanffy 17y agoWe are going in circles. I see no reason to believe understanding how the lump of meat inside my head works would require an upheaval in scientific knowledge. Given our current progresses, I would say it's an overly pessimistic position to believe we will eventually discover stuff that makes simulating neurons impossible for any significant period. There is no need for a huge breakthrough - just the incremental improvement in processing speed and scanning accuracy. Remember - nobody said the process wouldn't be destructive to the brain being transcribed into a simulation.
- scott_s 17y agoAt the end of the 19th century, many physicists thought they nearly had all of nature figured out, and that things like the black body problem were "just a matter of time." I don't see consciousness fitting into any of our existing theories. Hence, I think understanding it will require a scientific revolution much as understanding the black body problem required a scientific revolution.
- rbanffy 17y agoI don't see cracking time travel, faster-than-light or zero-point-energy as a question of time. Nuclear fusion power is one. We disagree in that I regard consciousness as a much simpler problem than you do. It only looks complex when we look at it from the inside.