2 ms·
I am not sure what you are getting at here. The models you propose are not what most if any designers use as the purpose is not to manually select best color c
by ThomPete 11y ago
I am not sure what you are getting at here.
The models you propose are not what most if any designers use as the purpose is not to manually select best color combinations (there are other ways to do that) but to approach colors a little more structurally.
Whether you calibrate your perception to understand one model or the other doesn't seem to be relevant.
I am glad to be taught something I didn't know, but for now it sounds more like a theoretical claim than an actual useful one.
- theoh 11y agoI think the parent was referring to the lack of properties like perceptual uniformity in RGB or HSV colour spaces. Check out the "Advantages" section on this Wikipedia page: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lab_color_space https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lab_color_space
- ThomPete 11y agoYou but in this context it seems wrong, but maybe thats just me.
- jacobolus 11y ago> not what most if any designers use This is because tool builders originally created their software tools for graphics workstations of the 1970s (at PARC, NYIT, MIT, etc.) / desktop computers of ~1990 (e.g. Adobe Photoshop), and on such slow hardware it was impractical to use better models. Also, the early tool builders were not color scientists, but computer programmers with an amateur understanding of human vision. It’s inexcusable that designers are still using such poor tools today. Hooray for historical inertia!
- ThomPete 11y agoUnless you can prove that the results are worse of by using the current model this point is moot.
- jacobolus 11y agoI personally use my own custom software for many design tasks, and I can tell you from personal experience that better color models make a dramatic improvement. But my methods are currently highly technical and idiosyncratic and closer to experiments than polished tools for non-programmers. Since the “proof” here involves low-level changes to design tools that have had millions of man-hours of work put into them and don’t provide end-user-accessible hooks into their low-level guts, it isn’t easy for me to “prove” anything to you via Hacker News comment: your “proof” would basically need to be a rewrite from scratch of these complex tools, and I haven’t yet spent the several years of implementation work it would require. It is a long-term goal of mine though to make a series of products. Knock on wood. If you want to see real-world examples, some professional color-grading software aimed at film production (for instance Apple’s Final Cut Pro) uses the IPT model. Even in Adobe tools, there is certain limited support for CIELAB, which is not perfect but far better than RGB. Here’s a book about it http://www.amazon.com/dp/0321356780 http://www.amazon.com/dp/0321356780 .... unfortunately these all still have shitty user interfaces for interacting with colors, but it’s better than nothing. In the physical world, artists and designers have been using the Munsell Book of Color in various incarnations for >100 years with great success. You can buy your own for $1000: http://www.pantone.com/munsell-book-of-color-matte-edition http://www.pantone.com/munsell-book-of-color-matte-edition
- ThomPete 11y agoGreat that you found a model that you like. To claim that the one others use is wrong is whats wrong with your claim IMO.
- jacobolus 11y agoWhat’s your point? You might just as well say “Great you folks decided to use positional notation, but I’m happy with my Roman numerals”, or “Great you folks found bézier curves, but I’m happy with my straight-line-segment paths”, or “Great you discovered electric motors, but I’m happy with my windmills and draft animals”, or whatever. Sure, there’s nothing ”wrong” with using shitty archaic tools. It’s just ineffective.