3 ms·
> I've had showdead=yes for a while and haven't seen anything that made me suspect live banning was employed for pleasure by Hacker News moderators." I don't t
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
> I've had showdead=yes for a while and haven't seen anything that made me suspect live banning was employed for pleasure by Hacker News moderators."
I don't think they get off on it, no, but the purpose of a hellban is to trick a user into thinking they're visible when they're not, so they get frustrated by the lack of response and give up. That's a mean and dishonest thing to do to someone, even if it may arguably be the best way to deal with certain kinds of trolls.
> One difference between regular banning and live banning is that the banned person is kicked out of the community with a regular ban, but not with a live ban.*
Hellbanned users are not part of the community. The entire point is to remove them from the community without them realizing it.
(BTW, what's a "live ban"? That doesn't even make sense. Did we really need a euphemism for shadowban/hellban?)
- brudgers 11y agoWhen the user gets frustrated by lack of response, what is it that the user gives up?
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoThey give up trying to harass other users. You need to understand that hellbanning was invented as a mean of dealing with commercial spammers and malicious trolls--people who have no interest in good-faith discussion, only in provoking a reaction; if they receive a normal ban, they'll just start a new account and continue, because they have none of the investment in the community that would make them care about their old account. Hellbanning prevents them from doing that, and in the old days it was often discussed with no small amount of sniggering over the idea of some asshole troll trying and trying to piss people off and wondering why it wasn't working anymore. A hellban works for those people; it may be the only thing that does. It is an entirely inappropriate tool to use against a user who wants to participate earnestly but is sometimes excessively rude/short-tempered, and my impression is that HN uses it that way often. (Based on the number of times I've seen commenters say "XXXX, you may not realize that you're shadowbanned, which is a shame because you've got a good point." A person who sometimes has good points is someone who should receive informed bans/suspensions, not hellbans.)
- brudgers 11y agoOne of the features [in the technical sense] of HN is that the costs of meanness trump the value of being correct. To me, it's better if someone decides to spend their time posting where their unique brand of earnestness is acceptable and perhaps appreciated. There are a lot of experts floating around HN. I'm ok with forgoing a few pearls to maintain the health of the oyster bed. If I wanted something else, there's the Linux kernel mailing list and a whole internet full of things like it. Live banning as instituted on HN via showdead=yes, allows the community to see good content, acknowledge it and engage the banned community member constructively. Because regular bans and suspensions are all or nothing, they don't leave space for those things to occur. I invented or reinvented "Live Banning" in my post to preempt a potential argument vector over terminology. I think it has the advantages that accrue to technical terms: neutrality in particular. "Hellbanning" suggests the deliberate creation of misery that often forms the backbone of internet fora. I supposed "shadowbanning" means something slightly different, and I may known what it was at one time but those brain cells are apparently repurposed. Anyway, "live banning" has the advantage of not necessarily connoting snickering among its side effects and it takes indicting HN's current mechanisms based on bad behavior by moderators that happened elsewhere on the internet off the table when deciding on the here and now. I fully confess to deliberately reframing HN's moderation mechanisms. Reframing may be one useful abstraction for thinking about live banning. Live banning is a closure, an execution frame, a continuation, where constructive behaviors are still possible and the effects of negative behaviors on the community are mitigated.