3 ms·
Or, even more specifically, we could patch the rules regarding "voluntary" donations to religious-affiliated organizations so that people cannot receive any mat
by derefr 11y ago
Or, even more specifically, we could patch the rules regarding "voluntary" donations to religious-affiliated organizations so that people cannot receive any material or social (rank within the church, respect from congregation, etc.) benefit for having donated. Require that all donations to religious organizations be anonymous, for example. This would wipe out the "attack vector" the Scientology organization uses to stay so large and powerful overnight (nobody would be allowed to follow those "donate $x to become level N+1 in the church" strictures), without really materially affecting the faith, or doing much to any other organization that doesn't raise money that way.
- nmrm2 11y ago> that people cannot receive any material or social (... respect from congregation, etc.) That seems totally impossible. People donate for social prestige all the time (those silly bricks with people's names on them, placards in classrooms, etc. wouldn't exist otherwise)
- derefr 11y agoYes, but this would specifically outlaw the organization recognizing donations only if the organization was also considered religious-affiliated (i.e. getting the particular tax breaks a church gets.) You could still donate to regular charities, companies, etc. (And before you say "but then the religion would just create a separate charity for people to donate to, which would recognize people with some sort of token, and then the church could acknowledge people who have that token": creating a shell company to avoid a restriction on commerce like that is pretty much the definition of money laundering!)