7 ms·
Lighting a room using 900+ RGB LEDs
- dvt 11y agoBuilt something very similar earlier this year (on an Arduino[1]). Lights are fun :) Excellent job, OP. [1] https://www.adafruit.com/categories/168 https://www.adafruit.com/categories/168
- ChuckMcM 11y agoI always cringe a bit when folks approach hardware like they do software but I'm encouraged that more and more people are building things. Unlike with software, bugs in hardware can have much more interesting (and for some definitions, exciting) failure modes. That said, using the outer edge of the room to source the lighting is good for accent lighting but not really a good overall lighting scenario. Of course a simple way to get started is with something like the Hue or LiFX bulbs (I've got some Hue bulbs) and I find that things like persistent notifications (I can have my lights go a different color for time when I'm voluntarily not drinking any caffeine, or to indicate 'stand' and 'sitting' times. ) But for overall room lighting I find there is really a relatively small gamut of colors that make "sense". From deep red, through orange and then right into yellow then white (perhaps with a bluish tint). Brown, Purple, Orange, Green, and Magenta lights? I can't really stand them for very long.
- joosters 11y agoI always cringe a bit when folks approach hardware like they do software Not sure what you mean - was there some terrible mistake in what the author was doing?
- astrodust 11y agoSoftware doesn't short out and burn down your house, for example. Low voltage systems are a lot safer, but not immune to trouble. Even USB ports occasionally catch on fire if there's a damaged cable or crossed pins.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoActually, they're not because the current is so high. You can easily start a fire.
- astrodust 11y agoI mean mostly safer from electrocution. The risk of fire is still there.
- cadr 11y agoBut software might have a race condition that causes you to get zapped by a lot of radiation. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Therac-25
- astrodust 11y agoMost people don't have one of those in their house. Also a case could be made that it wasn't software that irradiated people, but the hardware. If there was the potential for danger, the hardware should have had a limiter built-in. We have fuses in equipment for much the same reason.
- ChuckMcM 11y agoConsider the following quote, which concludes the discussion on power -- "The wires we use to provide the power also have resistance. Allright, so what do we do? Let's split the four strips into two segments, and power each one in the middle. This makes the situation much more palatable. On one side I used a PC power supply, and on another two parallel 5V15A supplies. They are both well isolated, so there was no potential difference between grounds or signal integrity issues." So I don't doubt this works for the author's setup, but it is by no means the correct solution to distributing power across his lights. There are three problems with this, first the PC power supply (being unspecified) may, or may not, actually regulate the 5V line when the 12V line is unloaded. So someone reading this might spend hours trying to figure out why their supply isn't producing 5V when the answer in the general case is to load the 12V supply with a 15W load (a 12V lightbulb works well for this). Next up he adds two 5V supplies that can provide 15A in "parallel" but the "grounds are isolated". So he is assuming there might be ground cross talk, but what he really should be concerned about is whether or not the power supplies are designed to run in parallel. If supply A produces 5.05V (well within spec) and supply B provides 4.95V, then supply A will try to drive all the LEDS and back drive supply B. Of course in so doing its output will come down, and eventually supply B will get a chance to contribute some power, the supply with the slightly higher output however will run at 100% of its rated output, and can then heat up. This can sometimes cause it to go into thermal shutdown, and suddenly supply B will have all the load. Now it over heats and supply A is called upon again to carry the load. Power supplies that are designed to be run in parallel will have a current mirror which lets each supply see what the other is producing and split the load between them, they are essentially current controlled supplies at that point. Third, there are lots of places that sell 60A 5V supplies if you want one, although a more typical arrangement might be to bus a higher power and then run independent supplies with a common return at each group of LEDs. So perhaps a 48V bus, with 5V step down supplies every 5M. The simplest solution is of course to just use a bus bar. Provide a suitable gauge wire (8M of 8Ga wire will have a resistance of about 10 mOhms. Less than .5V drop over the length. Have the bus wire go 8M along two walls, and then out the other direction 8M along the other two walls. That solves his power supply issue caveat he needs a 300W 5V power supply. Since high power GPU boards are so common, if he wanted to use a PC power supply he could run 12V on one half of the room and 12V on the other half split into two 150W feeds, with 12V->5V supplies to down convert at the LED strips. However since he missed all that (and I think its just missing some of the EE basics) and may (or may not) get a fire in his dual 15A supplies, I cringed.
- ConceptJunkie 11y agoYeah, except it occurred to me that for the price of Hue bulb, I could buy a RasPi and a Unicorn Hat that could be controlled via Wifi. OK, I don't know the brightness difference, so maybe I'm talking out of my hat, but those high-tech controllable RGB LED light bulbs are still way out of reach for anyone without a lot of disposable income.
- olympus 11y agoFor a lot cheaper you can use an esp8266 and a ws2812 LED strip. The esp8266 is <$5 and includes wifi and a microcontroller that can be programmed in JavaScript, Lua, or C. Various ws2812 forms (strips, rings, matrices) are available for cheap on eBay. You can reproduce the functionality of an Phillips Hue for less than half the price. This is assuming that you can write your own smartphone app to communicate with the esp8266 and have decent soldering skills. What I've noticed about the maker community isn't really related to disposable income. Most people with skills like programming and soldering have disposable income. The people that could benefit from saving money by making their own stuff don't usually have the skills to do so because they didn't have good schooling.
- ConceptJunkie 11y agoActually I think price does have a significant role in the Maker mindset. I'm sure when they see one of these cool, but really expensive products, like the Hue, a lot of folks will say, "Oh, I could make my own for much, much less." and some will inevitably add "With blackjack and hookers!" Anyone could benefit from saving money by making their own stuff, if they are interested (i.e., their time is worth it) and they have the knowledge and skills... and the project I suggested wouldn't take more than hardware skills than plugging things in and no more software skills than a few lines of Python. I can't imagine the maker movement is made up of the idle rich, but of everyday people, some with mortgages and kids (like me), or some who are themselves kids. Given how much one of the main selling points we hear about neat new devices like the Pi is the price, I think your characterization isn't correct. I'm sure in 10 years, something like the Hue will cost as much as a regular light bulb does today, but for those of us who don't have hundreds to drop on a cool colored lighting system for their homes, there are other options, just like you described, that are much cheaper and often not complicated at all.
- asteli 11y agoRGB LEDs aren't particularly suited for general purpose lighting anyway. Good white light is fairly broadband, which is why "white light" LEDs use a phosphor to get a broad emission spectrum. RGB+W LEDs exist, but I haven't seen them used in an LED strip configuration yet, unfortunately.
- saidajigumi 11y ago> RGB LEDs aren't particularly suited for general purpose lighting anyway. This. A few years back a client I was visiting had an RGB LED setup similar to this in their conference room, where our team was temporarily "housed" during the trip. It provided monumentally annoying light no matter the settings. If you're doing lighting for a space that will be used as a club or lounge where funky effects are desired and the inability to really see are OK... go for it. But even as "mood" lighting, full RGB control provides a vast, vast range of options that are truly terrible and only a few that maybe aren't. The thing is, the good current white LED bulbs are using blue+phosphor approaches to get broadband color in the warmer end of the spectrum. This trounces RGB approaches thoroughly, and they're getting remarkably good at this. Philips even has a dimmable "white" bulb that gets warmer as it's dimmed.[1] It looks fantastic, IMO. It's that kind of light quality manipulation that I find really interesting, much moreso than the effects-oriented lighting. [1] http://www.lighting.philips.com/us_en/lightcommunity/trends/led/warmglow/ http://www.lighting.philips.com/us_en/lightcommunity/trends/...
- jacobolus 11y agoThe “blue” part of blue + phosphor is unfortunately a huge spike, and for any bulbs bluer than about 2500K CCT, ends up being awful at night. Unfortunately there are now many such (sometimes even up to 5000K) being used as street lamps and other outdoor lighting at night, and the result is extremely unpleasant. The bluish “white” LEDs might be okay for daytime task lighting though, or for help waking up in the morning. The one in your link that goes down to 2300K sounds more reasonable, but not too many people are using those as far as I can tell.
- 11y ago
- ableal 11y ago> The room is 4 x 4 meters. > The strips require a 5V supply, and will consume 57.6 Amperes at full brightness. [later, really -5% or so, fine] > The light created looks very cool, even if a bit eerie. Nothing in the room casts a shadow. I can believe that, tossing over 250 W of LED light (some 2kW in old incandescents) into a 160 sq. foot room ... P.S. In other news, this week I saw a youngster playing with a Bluetooth 4.0 controlled 9W LED lamp (replacing a 60W incandescent). Bought from Bee Wi, via a local FNAC sale, 23 euros. Not homemade, so less virtuous, but perhaps more practical ;-)
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- miander 11y agoA better power-supply system would be to use a step-down DC-DC converter on each strip or each group of strips to step down from a higher voltage (say, 24V). These converters can be had for ~$1 apiece on eBay. This would reduce the current requirements down to ~20A, which is within the realm of what you can buy inexpensively (also on eBay).
- PhantomGremlin 11y agoThese converters can be had for ~$1 apiece on eBay. Yeah, that's exactly the type of hardware I want hanging on my wall. Because eBay is the world's preeminent source of UL certified electrical devices. /sarcasm
- threefour 11y agoThe chip tune soundtrack is perfect.
- olympus 11y agoThe song is by Ronald Jenkees: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0O2aH4XLbto https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0O2aH4XLbto If you like that song, you should definitely check out his other songs. He's pretty good.
- rebootthesystem 11y agoYears ago we built what we jokingly called a "light canon". It had 504 very tightly packed 1 Watt RGB LEDs for a total of 1512 W. This thing was so bright it was actually dangerous to look at directly. Truly scary amounts of light. That project then evolved into something else. Still, I have the prototype off in a corner of our R&D shop. Every time I look at it I think about adding a Fresnel lens in front of it. One day...