3 ms·
I would love to teach a software ethics course, and it wouldn't be me standing up saying "be good" over and over. We would study contemporary ethics questions:
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
I would love to teach a software ethics course, and it wouldn't be me standing up saying "be good" over and over. We would study contemporary ethics questions:
- what should you do if your government demands you secretly backdoor a specific user?
- what if your easiest recruiting channels yield a higher proportion of white males than other, costlier recruiting channels do?
- if your startup is struggling to even survive, should you invest time in infrastructure that protects users' privacy from your employees?
- how do you find nonprofits and companies that are aligned with your values and need your help?
Those are just four questions off the top of my head. I think there are plenty of thugs to talk about to fill a semester, let alone an hour.
- kbenson 11y agoI would pass on attending your class, but I wouldn't mind watching a feed of the proceedings. The fistfights would be especially entertaining.
- chroma 11y ago> - what should you do if your government demands you secretly backdoor a specific user? They've got a warrant or a court order? OK. > - what if your easiest recruiting channels yield a higher proportion of white males than other, costlier recruiting channels do? If you're a good person, you try to correct for that. If you're a money-grubbing sociopath, you try to correct for that. This may sound unusual, but think about it from the sociopath's point of view: If other companies are neglecting some potential candidates, you can hire those people for less pay. Recruiting is cheap compared to salaries, so it's worth the upfront cost. In the long run, even if everyone is a money-grubbing sociopath, all demographics end up being paid the same. > - if your startup is struggling to even survive, should you invest time in infrastructure that protects users' privacy from your employees? Probably not. A dead company can't defend users' privacy very well. Also, assets (such as user data) tend to get sold off when a company shuts down. Best is the enemy of good, and all that. > - how do you find nonprofits and companies that are aligned with your values and need your help? Givewell.[1] These are not hard questions to answer. More importantly: Your hypothetical course, even if taken by every software engineer, would not have prevented the Volkswagen emissions cheating. That was obviously wrong, but the people involved didn't care. 1. http://www.givewell.org/ http://www.givewell.org/
- logfromblammo 11y agoI believe this falls under the "Louis Armstrong Rule". If you have to take a class on ethics, you don't have them. (Q: What's the "Louis Armstrong Rule"? A: Man, if you have to ask, you'll never know.)
- erikpukinskis 11y agoIf you have to take a class on math skills, you don't have them. I fail to see what your point is.
- logfromblammo 11y agoIf you already have enough ethics, you can work out on your own what would be ethical for any given situation. You don't need the class. It may save you a bit of time in reflective contemplation, but it's not going to give you anything you didn't already have. If you don't have enough ethics to figure it out yourself, the class is just teaching you how to pretend to have ethics. And like jazz, you will fail just as soon as you are called upon to improvise.
- erikpukinskis 11y agoTo me, there is an ethical "operating system" which is what you are describing, very low level principles that you apply. But your ability to be ethical in a specific situation depends on your database of "ethical considerations" about possible decisions you might make that will have serious ethical ramifications and how those things are wired up. The purpose of a course is to build up that database. You might have a deep and earnest desire to be kind to someone, but without a cultural framework for understanding their feelings, for example, you could be completely unable to do that.