5 ms·
"Model X is the safest, fastest and most capable sport utility vehicle in history." From any other company I would roll my eyes at the ridiculous hyperbole. He
by leephillips 11y ago
"Model X is the safest, fastest and most capable sport utility vehicle in history."
From any other company I would roll my eyes at the ridiculous hyperbole. Here, it's probably just a statement of fact.
- dagw 11y agoSafest and fastest seem possible, but I'm rather doubting its off road capabilities. Unless of course being capable of driving off road isn't something we expect from an SUV these days.
- threeseed 11y agoYou can tell from the photos you won't be taking this off road. It's more akin to a people mover with the 7 seat option and the ground clearance being limited. If you look at the most popular SUVs i.e. BMW X3/5, Mercedes M, Land Rover they have a lineage in proper 4WDs. But let's be honest almost nobody who drives an SUV actually takes it off road.
- nmrm2 11y agoRight. SUVs in this category are going after the need-a-van-but-want-a-sportcar market.
- bengoodger 11y agoThe irony is that a van will often handle better than a SUV with a car based platform and a lower center of gravity. My wife has a BMW X5 and it drives like a piece of industrial farm equipment. We also own a Honda Odyssey which IMO handles significantly better - it's basically an Accord with a taller roof.
- dublinben 11y agoThe current X3, X5, and M-Class are all built on unibody car platforms. Only the Range Rover models have a remotely "proper" lineage in 4WD vehicles.
- Zaskoda 11y agoThis. There's a fine line between SUV and minivan. At best, the X is sitting on top of the line.
- Coincoin 11y agoDo people actually go off road with SUVs? You just need to stand near any speed bump, pot hole filled road or construction zone for five minutes to realise that the cars that slow down the most are usually SUVs. People with SUVs want a smooth and "safe" ride, not to throw themselves down a mountain and conquer nature like in TV ads.
- Idontagree 11y agoUgh this is the worst, I genuinely do not understand buying that huge car and being so incredibly afraid of a pothole.
- jkestner 11y agoCool thing is, they could actually claim "safe" in a bigger sense of the word that most companies do not. Zero emissions is safer for everyone over the long term. I'd want to see a cradle-to-grave carbon footprint analysis first, though.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoGood point. Maybe there's an asterisk in there somewhere stating this claim is predicated on successfully launching used batteries into space and having them crash into a dump on the moon.
- anon4 11y agoOr building that giant solar array around Mercury that beams energy for free to every Tesla car.
- JoeAltmaier 11y agoBuild it around Earth of course. Get about 10X the solar density outside atmosphere. Even with 50% losses due to translating to/from laser, still magnitudes more efficient than ground-bases. And Mercury-based orders of magnitude harder yet!
- talmand 11y agoNah, just get them to orbit and then gently nudge them towards the sun. After the cost of getting out of the gravity well, let physics take care of the rest. We will need the moon one day, no point in trashing it beforehand.
- hollerith 11y agoDoesn't work that way. It take about 3 times as much delta v to crash something into the sun from low-earth orbit as it does to put it into orbit in the first place. If you gently nudge something in orbit, it will continue to be at risk of crashing into other orbiting thing or falling back to earth. (Of course there's also the fact that it's very unlikely that launching even the most dangerous kinds of wastes into space is a net environmental win.)
- 6stringmerc 11y agoThe only other company than Apple, in my opinion, that consistently slathers on more self-adulation and importance than reasonable on their own products, is Tesla. Safest? Hummer H1. Fastest? Brabus 800 G. Most Capable? Toyota Land Cruiser. Edit: Every downvote is sweet with your tears of being confronted by actual facts, just letting you know.
- mikeash 11y agoI really doubt the H1 is safer than the Model X. Just because it's big and strong doesn't mean it's safe. On what basis do you make that statement? I'm having trouble finding much info on the Brabus 800 G, but from what I can dig up it looks like it does 0-60 in 4.2 seconds with a top speed of 155MPH. Model X P90D with ludicrous upgrade does 0-60 in 3.2 seconds with a top speed of 155MPH. Most capable is a vague term that can mean almost anything, so that can't really be argued either way on anything objective.
- 6stringmerc 11y agoThanks for responding and I'll chime in. I'm using the 8,100 pound vehicle weight of the H1 as an off-the-cuff reference point in physics, because in practical terms, yes, bigger tends to be safer in the real world. If somebody can find the NHTSA numbers for the H1 that'd be relevant to clearing that up. Oh, and I'm talking about the military converted version that was road legal, not the GM product. Until we get the official test numbers from a 3rd party, I'm not going to believe Tesla's numbers. For all I know they could be better than advertised, but they could also be worse. I saw the 800 G having a top speed closer to 170, which would make it faster. Also, having been on the road with 50+ Teslas, I can assure you that the speed of the vehicle absolutely does not matter, because they don't use it. Anecdotal, sure, but there's always a bragging rights speed metric to brag about, which means it's not really worth bragging about. So basically on the last point you agree with my premise, that Tesla likes to pick terms to hype itself along the lines of Apple and how "revolutionary" their products are. Basically the Model X hasn't proven itself capable of anything yet, because it's a year behind and I haven't seen any 3rd party tests of it...unlike the Land Cruiser, which is highly regarded worldwide for being, you know, capable of handling normal and abnormal conditions.