2 ms·
An HTML5 page with no stylesheet or javascript is hugely functional, legible, and responsive, adapting itself to any device. If there is a problem with a websit
by leephillips 11y ago
An HTML5 page with no stylesheet or javascript is hugely functional, legible, and responsive, adapting itself to any device. If there is a problem with a website it's because a "web designer" or front-end developer broke it.
- sanderjd 11y agoThis seems to be a civil war taking place purely amongst software developers. Some developers want the web to be used for hypertext documents as it was originally intended, and others want it to be used for anything for which there is demand amongst a sizable group of people, technical and non-technical alike. I see the appeal of the first viewpoint, and it's likely I would share it if I had the luxury of working on non-web software, but as it is, most of us go where the users are and work on what the users want, and that question has been settled: they want rich functionality that looks nice and is delivered through the web on their desktop and a mix of web and native apps on mobile. Only other programmers (and only a small subset of programmers at that) complain about javascript and stylesheets. In most cases, it doesn't make sense to pander to such a tiny audience.
- acdha 11y agoI think the situation is more nuanced than that: users may not know the terms to complain about JavaScript and stylesheets but they know when a page is slow or broken. The discussion really should focus on how well apps degrade, which is really reaffirming that progressive enhancement is still the best approach to building web apps. While only a small percentage of users have intentionally disabled JavaScript entirely, it's effectively disabled for everyone while it's downloading and a larger percentage of users (particularly on mobile) will have errors which prevent those downloads entirely. If you build a rich application which still has the core functionality working, you've done a much better job than the people who make sites which take minutes or don't even render when their shiny framework hits a non-perfect network connection.
- sanderjd 11y agoThis is a really good point, and the better conversation to have than broad brush dismissal of anything but raw hypertext like the comment I replied to. Graceful degradation is a user-friendly, competitive, and all around fantastic feature. It is also expensive, and may or may not belong at the top of the list of things to optimize to improve user experience. Eliminating everything but raw hypertext may be a cheaper solution, but it isn't a good one.
- leephillips 11y agoI did not advocate eliminating anything but raw hypertext. I like CSS and javascript when they are used well. I like web apps.
- sanderjd 11y agoFair enough! I misread.