3 ms·
The goal isn't pretty lines. The goal is maximal competitiveness. Which boosts voter participation. Which gives legitimacy to the results. https://en.wikipedi
by specialist 11y ago
The goal isn't pretty lines.
The goal is maximal competitiveness. Which boosts voter participation. Which gives legitimacy to the results.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Citizens_Redistricting_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Citizens_Redistrict...
"While the long-term results will bear out over time, independent studies by the Public Policy Institute of California, the National Journal, and Ballotpedia have shown that California now has some of the most competitive districts in the nation, creating opportunities for new elected officials.[12][13][14]"
- ClayShentrup 11y agoIndependent redistricting commissions don't work. http://scorevoting.net/GerryComm.html http://scorevoting.net/GerryComm.html
- caf 11y agoApparently they don't work in the US. That link says that they work in Canada, and they work in Australia too. Without an underlying reason identified, this conclusion is somewhat unsatisfying.
- Frondo 11y agoThe link also gives unsatisfying reasons for why it says they don't work, e.g. incumbents keep winning elections. I haven't studied the matter really closely, but from what little I do know of the issue, it makes me wonder--are Arizona, Washington, and NJ examples of the hyper-gerrymandered states that citizen redistricting is supposed to prevent? Could it be that, in those states, they're already starting out from a pretty equitable district layout, such that when the citizenry gets to redraw the layout, it doesn't actually matter much? Or, put another way, how would a citizen redistricting panel work in Florida or North Carolina or Texas?