3 ms·
Yup. Quoting Sarah Jeong's The Internet of Garbage: "The strict 'hacker' definition of 'dropping dox,' as it was initially phrased, involves the publication of
by geofft 11y ago
Yup. Quoting Sarah Jeong's The Internet of Garbage:
"The strict 'hacker' definition of 'dropping dox,' as it was initially phrased, involves the publication of documentation (or 'docs'/'dox'). As Schneier points out, these can be addresses, phone numbers, financial information, medical records, emails, and so forth. The part where the definition of 'doxing' gets murky is that the word's prominent appearances in the media haven't involved dropping dox at all. Rather, it's come (sometimes!) to signify the unmasking of anonymous internet users without their consent. ....
"The idea that a 'full name' can constitute a dox represents an understanding that in some contexts, the publication of a legal name serves as an incitement to drop a full dox. Through Google and other databases, a full name can lead to other details...."
While I absolutely think no good would have come out of de-anonymizing SLJ, it wouldn't really be doxing (unless they had somehow attracted people that had an interest in attacking their home, embarrassing them in front of their employer, etc.).
- nailer 11y agoWhat an odd thing to say. Documentation can certainly include real identity. Those things are a set/subset relationship, not two different things. In both cases the desired outcome is achieved: the 'war' is expanded, taking on either new dimensions (personal knowledge of the doxxing victim) or new avenues to attack them with.
- geofft 11y agoWell, the context here is that "doxing" is not about identity in the first place: it's about encouraging harassment/crime, by facilitating identity theft, leaking embarrassing photos, giving contact info of family members, giving the information needed to conduct SWATting, etc. Identity happens to be involved in all of these things, but it's not the goal. That section of the book argues for distinguishing them because, in some cases, de-anonymizing someone (but no more) is legitimate self-defense by a community, but doxing always intends harassment (which is not legitimate self-defense). If there are rules for actual war, there are absolutely rules for "war" in scare quotes; not inciting crime is one of them. I don't think I can make the full argument here concisely, but it is well set-out in the book. (While she has a blog post saying much the same thing, I actually thought that was a much poorer defense of de-anonymization, since it's missing context.) Obviously in this specific case there is not even "war," just curiosity, so that defense of de-anonymization doesn't apply. But we've gotten on a tangent about the term itself.
- nailer 11y ago'Context' does not change facts or logic: identity is part of documents, the war gets bigger. You've written a lot, it's mostly true, but nothing actually addresses the comment you're responding to. Regarding 'unmasking': many doxxers use this argument: when they do publish people's information, they're unmasking bad actors, when their opponents do it, they're doxxing. For example Sarah Jeong, the author of the book you mention, wrote for The Verge, which tacitly endorses doxxing by ignoring it when performed by political groups it supports.
- PhasmaFelis 11y ago> "The idea that a 'full name' can constitute a dox represents an understanding that in some contexts, the publication of a legal name serves as an incitement to drop a full dox." In some contexts, a full name is a full dox, to anyone who has Google access and 10 minutes to spare. There's not really a functional difference. The presence or absence of malicious intent may determine how we judge the doxer, but the potential effect on the doxee is the same either way.