4 ms·
Had to read past many paragraphs of historical filler and other teaser trash to get to the meat: > Economists have long said that the rational thing to do is t
by jessriedel 11y ago
Had to read past many paragraphs of historical filler and other teaser trash to get to the meat:
> Economists have long said that the rational thing to do is to buy an annuity. At retirement age, you could pay an insurance company $100,000 in return for some $5,000-6,000 a year in guaranteed payments until you die. But most people don’t do that. For decades, economists have been trying to figure out why....James Poterba, an economics professor at MIT who has extensively studied American retirement, says it’s still a mystery why annuities are so unpopular. ...But there’s also some evidence that people just irrationally dislike annuities. As behavioral economist Richard Thaler wrote in the New York Times: “Rather than viewing an annuity as providing insurance in the event that one lives past 85 or 90, most people seem to consider buying an annuity as a gamble, in which one has to live a certain number of years just to break even.” ... Here is where tontines come in. If people irrationally fear annuities because they seem like a gamble on one's own life, history suggests that they irrationally loved tontines because they see tontines as a gamble on other people's lives.
Right, so the answer is completely known, and now we're just speculating on what weird financial device will best play to people's economic ignorance. Luckily, the author sounds almost as confused, since you couldn't have a handle on economics and write this:
> Retirees often object to annuities because they worry about not living long enough to make the money back. This is the nightmare scenario: If someone dies the day after she buys an annuity, the insurance company walks away with the cash scot-free. In a tontine, that money passes on to help fund other people's retirements.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoAnother reason people are reluctant to use annuities is they don't trust the companies selling them to remain in business for 10 years or more....
- jessriedel 11y agoNot sure about folks' actual reasoning, but I don't think that can be consistently squared with the popularity of life insurance. "The most common terms are 10, 15, 20, and 30 years."
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoYeah, but most people don't "expect" to collect term life. And even if it does pay, you'll be dead! You do expect to collect your annuity payments.
- mikeash 11y agoAlso, if your life insurance company goes under, then you can just buy a new policy from a different company. You only get screwed if you die after the insurance company goes under but before you can buy a new policy. With an annuity, if your insurance company goes under then you are capital-S Screwed.
- jessriedel 11y agoSo you're saying people don't care if their life insurance pays out? I guess they're just buying it to look caring to their family, then?
- aianus 11y agoSurely you would have a claim on their assets in this case? Any lawyers / accountants who can chime in?
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Surely you would have a claim on their assets in this case? Sure, along with all their other creditors. If you don't trust them to remain solvent, you don't trust that claim to be worth much. EDIT: But I don't think that this is actually the problem, just that the claim on assets wouldn't really negate it if it was.
- tsotha 11y agoInsurance companies are pretty heavily regulated for just this reason.
- phaemon 11y ago> Luckily, the author sounds almost as confused, since you couldn't have a handle on economics and write this: Indeed. The author only has degrees in Mathematics and Economics from MIT.
- jessriedel 11y agoWell then he panders to his audience's ignorance, which is even worse. EDIT: Strike that. He doesn't have a PhD. I took the undergrad Econ courses at Princeton, and you could easily leave as confused as the author appears to be in this article.
- kqr2 11y agoOne of the reasons that annuities are unpopular is that there are many types and potential pitfalls: http://apps.suzeorman.com/igsbase/igstemplate.cfm?SRC=MD012&SRCN=aoedetails&GnavID=20&SnavID=29&TnavID&AreasofExpertiseID=107 http://apps.suzeorman.com/igsbase/igstemplate.cfm?SRC=MD012&...