7 ms·
Tontines may make sense despite their history of disrepute
- krisroadruck 11y agoIsn't this basically exactly how social security works? The longer you live the more profit you receive? It's why social security has been repeatedly called sexist. Women tend to live longer, thus draw more social security, yet men tend to contribute more in social security taxes during their working years than women. A double loss prospect for men and a double win for women.
- lisper 11y agoNo, a tontine is structured differently. In a tontine there's a fixed pot of assets allocated to a fixed population of beneficiaries. In social security, neither of those is fixed.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoSocial security is more like car insurance, this is more like Russian roulette.
- jonnycowboy 11y agoDouble win for women, because they get paid less for the same work throughout their life??
- aianus 11y ago> because they get paid less for the same work That's not true, women earn less than men overall because they choose to do different jobs.
- Gibbon1 11y agoI've come around to an old critique I read thirty five years ago, which is women tend to do a lot of economically important yet uncompensated work; child rearing and house keeping. Something economists and policy makers tend to studiously ignore because you can't easily assign a dollar value to it or pin it to a particular quarters GDP.
- krisroadruck 11y agoIntentionally obtuse much? Its a double win because they both pay less in and take more out. Gender wagegap is another discussion entirely but I'll just leave this video here as my answer to THAT discussion: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwogDPh-Sow https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EwogDPh-Sow
- panic 11y agoHow is what you describe sexist? From your perspective, what would be a non-sexist way of paying out social security?
- jeremyt 11y agoYou fund your own personal social security account.
- aianus 11y ago> what would be a non-sexist way of paying out social security? Increase the payroll deductions for women seeing as how they live longer, same way my car insurance costs more than if I were a woman.
- boxy310 11y agoWomen also tend to earn less money, being dependent on their husband's income for much of their working-life. The SSA has actually studied this issue, and women tend to be much more likely to exhaust all other forms of retirement savings and subsist exclusively on Social Security benefits: http://www.ssa.gov/history/reports/women.html http://www.ssa.gov/history/reports/women.html
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- AnimalMuppet 11y agoYour car insurance would cost more if you were a woman? Citation needed. My impression is that most car insurance costs more for a man, because men tend to be more aggressive behind the wheel, and that translates into a higher incidence of accidents. At least, that's certainly the case for young drivers. I attempted to prove it with a quick quote from Progressive, but they want a real name so they can check credit history, and I wasn't willing to give it to them. So I can't (easily and quickly) prove that you're wrong, but I'd like to hear why you think you're right.
- jff 11y ago
- usefulcat 11y agoNo, SS is similar to an annuity, at least in terms of how the distributions are structured. SS payments don't vary much (or at all?), whereas payments from a tontine would vary over time.
- quotemstr 11y agoIsn't this headline a little clickbaity?
- dang 11y agoMore than a little. We changed it to a representative sentence from the article. If anyone suggests a better (i.e. more accurate and neutral) title, we can change it again.
- jessriedel 11y agoPlease keep this up. This is a great service.
- zeveb 11y agoThe problem with this title is that it's the anti-clickbait, like 'Unusual Incident in New Jersey' would be for an article covering the Hindenburg. I liked the original title; it's a good, well-written and engaging article, and the title drew me to it.
- thesteamboat 11y agoOn a couple of stories I've noticed discussion about changing the title, which is not always universally agreed with. Is there a way to make this process more transparent, e.g. on changing title posting a comment "Changed title from [x] to [y] because it was clickbait". I don't mean to disparage the great work you're doing moderating, and I don't want to throw pointless tasks at you for no reason, but I'm curious about the former titles (and wondering if others are wondering as well).
- dang 11y agoIn cases where we replaced the article title I don't bother repeating it, since you can see it there. In cases where we replace a submitter's rewrite, I usually quote those in the thread. I'm reluctant to add features to HN's software for this. It doesn't feel in the spirit of the site.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- boxy310 11y ago> But the new urban factory jobs were completely different. “These were often debilitating, strenuous occupations,” Sutch says. “People couldn't work in their old age.” Isn't the problem with post-industrial societies that many office workers are capable of working for much longer? While life expectancy is definitely going up, it's growing unequally, with the highest wage-earners (and thus most likely to have office jobs) gaining life expectancy the fastest: http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2012/11/21/why-rich-guys-want-to-raise-the-retirement-age/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonkblog/wp/2012/11/21/wh...
- derekp7 11y agoThis sounds a lot like longevity insurance (a form of deferred annuity) which from what I've read is available now. Normally when you retire (with a decent size 401k or IRA balance), you have to take a guess at how long you will live, and draw it down at a rate that will last you. The safe bet is to guess you will live to 100, and that the fund will grow at 4-5%, but that may not leave you with enough annual income. The idea of longevity insurance, is you buy something like a $50K policy at age 65, and the insurance company will pay you $70K a year for life after you turn 85. So you buy the policy up front, and adjust your 401k withdrawals so that fund runs out a age 85. Then the annuity takes over after that.
- gwern 11y agoIt doesn't directly compare with longevity insurance, but to me it sounds like all the advantages against annuities would carry over: > Annuities are expensive to administer, and so their payouts are rather low. The costs stem in part from paying the insurance company to shoulder all the risk. To guarantee it can make good on all its annuity contracts, the insurer has to set aside a lot of money in reserve — just in case people live longer than expected, or in case the market crashes. A tontine does away with all that overhead, so more money is available to the retirees. By Milevsky's calculations, a tontine might offer a 10 percent to 20 percent premium over an annuity — a bigger pie to be divided among the group. The downside is that retirees would see their payouts fluctuate depending on the various times other people in the tontine group died. Compared to an annuity, a tontine abandons certain payouts for much higher returns...Such a system would be cheaper to operate and would always, by definition, be fully funded. The funny thing is that some retirement systems already carry out a version of that process. As Milevsky documents in his book, there is "tontine thinking" embedded in various national pension schemes, and even in a product offered by TIAA-CREF in the United States. These plans adjust payments according to mortality. They just don't use the word tontine.
- derekp7 11y agoJust for reference (and to see if longevity insurance is a good deal), I ran some numbers using the SSA actuary tables (at http://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html http://www.ssa.gov/oact/STATS/table4c6.html). I ran a few scenarios as follows, assuming no administrative overhead: 1) If everyone in a given pool puts in $50k at age 65, the surviving members can withdraw $18k per year starting at age 85 -- any more and the fund runs dry. 2) If the fund is invested at an interest rate of 2%, they can withdraw $30k annually starting at 85 without the fund running out. 3) At 5% interest, that number goes to $62k. For comparison, according to a random article on longevity insurance, Met Life quotes a payout of $15k per year (at 85) if $50k is invested at age 65. Also, as another point of reference, if you invest 50k at 65 and get 5% returns, and withdraw 13k staring at 85, you will have enough to last you till age 96. So the longevity quote above really isn't that great of a deal.
- legitster 11y agoI like the idea. It's funky. It could do to retirements what HSAs have done for health insurance. It also seems unnecessary that they are still illegal.
- deutronium 11y agoWhat happens if the tontine has a hitman as part of the group ;) Reminds me a bit of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market
- TrevorJ 11y agoAn episode of the show "Archer" covered this fairly hilariously.
- patio11 11y agoTontines don't solve the elephant in the room, which is that people are substantially undersaving for retirement. There exists no financial innovation which will provide for fully-funded retirements for 100 retirees each having $100k to invest. (Sourced below.) There is no way to slice that pool of $10 million in such a way that it increases the NPV of it to more than $10 million. It's underfunded by a factor of 10. >> The agency found the median amount of those savings is about $104,000 for households with members between 55 and 64 years old[.] http://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/03/most-older-americans-fall-short-on-retirement-savings.html http://www.cnbc.com/2015/06/03/most-older-americans-fall-sho...
- aianus 11y ago> There exists no financial innovation which will provide for fully-funded retirements for 100 retirees each having $100k to invest. You could start a retirement community in a third world African country where costs are lower. $100k is stretching it but $250k and they'd be fine for the rest of their lives.
- Apofis 11y agoShip old people to Cuba, now that we're removing restrictions. Cuba will be the new Florida.
- tsotha 11y agoWhy not? Florida was the new Cuba after the revolution.
- joshuaheard 11y agoIsn't that the plot of The Best Exotic Marigold Hotel?
- zeveb 11y ago> Tontines don't solve the elephant in the room, which is that people are substantially undersaving for retirement. If they encourage people to save more, then they'll reduce the problem. They won't, however, solve the problem that people are simply spending too much. I don't know if anything can.
- zeveb 11y agoThis reminds me a bit of the concept of lottery savings accounts, in which principals are untouched and winners receive interest: it turns the common human desire to gamble towards good, rather than evil. I like it, too, because it just seems fairer than an annuity: there's an upside as well as a downside.
- herbig 11y agoI like the idea of building this into bitcoin, where one only has to check into the blockchain somehow each year to continue receiving payments.
- jessriedel 11y agoHad to read past many paragraphs of historical filler and other teaser trash to get to the meat: > Economists have long said that the rational thing to do is to buy an annuity. At retirement age, you could pay an insurance company $100,000 in return for some $5,000-6,000 a year in guaranteed payments until you die. But most people don’t do that. For decades, economists have been trying to figure out why....James Poterba, an economics professor at MIT who has extensively studied American retirement, says it’s still a mystery why annuities are so unpopular. ...But there’s also some evidence that people just irrationally dislike annuities. As behavioral economist Richard Thaler wrote in the New York Times: “Rather than viewing an annuity as providing insurance in the event that one lives past 85 or 90, most people seem to consider buying an annuity as a gamble, in which one has to live a certain number of years just to break even.” ... Here is where tontines come in. If people irrationally fear annuities because they seem like a gamble on one's own life, history suggests that they irrationally loved tontines because they see tontines as a gamble on other people's lives. Right, so the answer is completely known, and now we're just speculating on what weird financial device will best play to people's economic ignorance. Luckily, the author sounds almost as confused, since you couldn't have a handle on economics and write this: > Retirees often object to annuities because they worry about not living long enough to make the money back. This is the nightmare scenario: If someone dies the day after she buys an annuity, the insurance company walks away with the cash scot-free. In a tontine, that money passes on to help fund other people's retirements.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoAnother reason people are reluctant to use annuities is they don't trust the companies selling them to remain in business for 10 years or more....
- jessriedel 11y agoNot sure about folks' actual reasoning, but I don't think that can be consistently squared with the popularity of life insurance. "The most common terms are 10, 15, 20, and 30 years."
- gwern 11y agoFulltext links to the two cited papers: http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2393152 http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2393152 , and https://www.dropbox.com/s/8ubxv59z524fq5s/1987-ransom.pdf https://www.dropbox.com/s/8ubxv59z524fq5s/1987-ransom.pdf / http://cyber.sci-hub.bz/MTAuMjMwNy8yMTIyMjM2/10.2307%402122236.pdf http://cyber.sci-hub.bz/MTAuMjMwNy8yMTIyMjM2/10.2307%4021222...
- rmason 11y agoThe Barney Miller show had an episode in season 8 where the plot revolves around two surviving members of a Tontine. http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0519144/ http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0519144/
- Turing_Machine 11y agoThere was also a very amusing British comedy on the subject, with Michael Caine, Ralph Richardson, Peter Cook, Peter Sellers, Dudley Moore, among others. http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/wrong_box/ http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/wrong_box/
- jedberg 11y agoHow do you address the problem that the longest lived participants get the majority of their payout when they are really old? Basically you're just concentrating a lot of wealth into the hands of the long lived and their offspring that they pass it to when they die shortly after getting their large payouts. I'm now imagining a scenario where this catches on and in a few generations the life expectancy has a major bifurcation, as those that were already destined to live longer through genetics now get an extra boost via inherited wealth.
- nostrademons 11y agoThis is already happening, as people with more money, more skills, and better health mate with other people like themselves, passing on their genes/wealth/knowledge to their offspring. (Health, wealth, and IQ are all correlated.) As for what happens next...I think someone wrote a book about that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Time_Machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Time_Machine
- jedberg 11y agoNow you've got me wondering if that was intentional symbolism in the book or not. :)
- shalmanese 11y agoI wonder what effect tontines would have on healthy behaviors. Traditionally, we've found that very little moves the margin on getting people to enact healthy behaviors but perhaps the motivation of beating your peers for financial gain might actually move the needle.
- njloof 11y agoThis seems related to what corporations were doing when they were taking out life insurance on their employees.
- Camillo 11y ago> This is because royal financing in the late Middle Ages was a tricky thing. I'd just like to point out that no part of this story has anything to do with the Middle Ages. De Tonti and Louis XIV lived in the Modern age.
- teslaberry 11y agoall insurance of all types are a scam. worse, they are tax subsidized. gambling is also a scam. gambling is a version of 'insurance' for the activity of 'entertainment' that is called 'gambling'. there is NO gain to be had for the gambler in the long run. similarly, the insured will lose MORE money in the long run paying for insurance as he would , statistically, in the short run. the idea that insurance would prevent you from sudden ruin in case of an accident is also a lie. plenty of insurance companies don't pay out entirely or resist paying enough to prevent ruin. by paying for insurance, society is guaranteed higher overhead in the long run , higher litigation costs, and higher moral hazard as well as the rise of scammers of insurance companies. all this activity is a total waste and only works because of the tax subsidy of the insruance industry scam. if working people simply didn't have to pay ANY tax on labor including the scam of payroll ss. and healthcare tax on labor than you would see how rich the working classes would become how quickly. insurance companies have stolen the right not to pay tax on a scam, which guarantees that their scam's attract even more investors. it's called the FIRE economy. READ ABOUT IT.
- saretired 11y agoThe idea is you give up return of principal for a bet on the NPV of coupons during your life. Which is a gamble, and quite tidy too: nothing to leave to one's heirs for all but one of the participants[1]. But also a gamble on a particular pool of assets. "At retirement, you and a bunch of other people each chip in $20,000 to buy a ton of mutual funds or stocks or whatever." But these "whatevers" are volatile assets that will produce losses in some years--the opposite of the usual advice to lower volatile asset holdings at retirement. So now it's a double bet: first on NPV/longevity, and second on the health of the underlying assets. Exactly the kind of thing that Wall St would love to sell to the public. [1] All of the underlying assets being transferred to the last survivor is one type of tontine; in another, certain to be a favorite of Wall St., the underlying would be transferred to the plan manager after the death of the last participant.