3 ms·
The online barter systems seem to be de facto creating an alternate currency. IIRC, the one profiled in the article uses "points" that are the equivalent of Eur
by Mz 11y ago
The online barter systems seem to be de facto creating an alternate currency. IIRC, the one profiled in the article uses "points" that are the equivalent of Euros (scanning, I can't verify this atm, but I read more than one article before submitting this one, so maybe I read it elsewhere). So if you have 600 points in your online account, you have the equivalent of 600 Euros to work with.
I think it isn't Greece's monetary policy that is out of whack. I haven't really studied it, but my impression from casual reading is that the economy is being crushed by things like high benefits packages for government workers. So when you engage in barter, you side step that. You trade THIS thing for THAT and there is no cost tacked on for putting money into a retirement account or paying for disability insurance etc. You just need tires and need food or you have meat and need tires, and you make the trade to meet your needs in the here and now and let tomorrow worry about itself, thus you don't reduce the value in the here and now of what you traded by setting aside one of your four tires "in case something happens" and driving on three good tires and one bad or whatever. (Trying to come up with a goods based equivalent of the overhead of retirement and so on benefits.)
Anyway, I thought it was neat that a) barter is being facilitated in part by online services b) those services are engaging in some of the same practices PayPal engages in to make sure it is secure and c) it is de facto creating a virtual currency without any intent to create currency. In fact, the intent is to side step the need for currency. Nonetheless, the tracking of points that you can spend is the essence of a currency. The single biggest real value money has is it lubricates trade by creating something universally accepted so you don't have to ask dozens of people if they will take Thing You Have in exchange for Thing You Need. You can just sell it to Person Who Needs It and then turn around and buy what you need.
- LoSboccacc 11y agoD) evading sales tax
- Mz 11y agoI thought about this overnight. I don't know Greek tax laws, but in the U.S., if you earn less than (iirc) $600/year from one source, you do not need to report it on your taxes. If you earn more than that, even from barter, you do need to report. A lot of people will not, a lot of people won't even realize they should, but at least in this country, you are supposed to. If you are using an online service for this, there are records. That makes it easier to report or to be caught if you didn't report. So I am not going to automatically assume that all people engaging in barter a) need to report it (maybe they are below the reporting threshold) or b) won't report it. Also, given that you can only get 420 Euros/week out of the bank, it looks to me like the main thing barter is doing is getting around that bottleneck. These transactions would not be happening at all without barter. So while in some sense, yes, it may make it easy to skirt around the question of taxes, it is not like it is some tax loophole and people are doing this to actively hide profits. They are doing it because they straight up do not have access to enough money to get their needs met. Perhaps over time the tax issue will get worked out. Perhaps not. But these folks are just trying to survive in spite of economic collapse impeding their ability to do so. I see no reason to act like they are just criminal scum, trying to screw the government of tax dollars.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- wutangson1 11y agoThis. >"criminal scum trying to screw the government out of tax revenue." Umm, so you feel the same way about American Colonists with that whole Boston Tea Party thing, right?
- LoSboccacc 11y agowell there was a war about that and winners decided it was fine :D we'll know how this play out in the next decades.