3 ms·
Eric Cantor lost due to activism by the Tea Party, but no, the EFF is not feared by any candidate (I've never found a reference in any news service of any fear)
by protomyth 11y ago
Eric Cantor lost due to activism by the Tea Party, but no, the EFF is not feared by any candidate (I've never found a reference in any news service of any fear). You would think with all the money in tech and all the lip service to these issues that wouldn't be true.
- tptacek 11y agoI'm not sure what Eric Cantor has to do with this issue. Clearly some candidates do lose primary challenges. Is it your argument that "Your Rights Online" advocacy has as much of a grassroots as hard-right-wing conservatism? How well-attended was the largest Y.R.O. demonstration? How would that compare to conservative demonstrations? Obviously, my subtext is that the belief that there's a potent grassroots waiting to be activated over Y.R.O. issues is an online echo-chamber fallacy.
- protomyth 11y agoEric Cantor proved its possible to primary out a incumbent if you have a group focused on an issue. YRO doesn't have to numbers the Tea Party has, but FreedomWorks does Tea Party issues and has done YRO issues. I actually believe there are the numbers. I just believe that an organization that has the discipline to attack candidates in the manner, for example, of the NRA is just not there in the YRO space.
- tptacek 11y agoIs there any numeric evidence you can find for the latent support for YRO issues you claim exists? My immediate reaction is that the NRA speaks to core identity issues for 100% of rural voters and the overwhelming majority of the half of the country that identifies as "conservative", as well as a pretty big chunk of non-conservatives who see guns as a constitutional bulwhark issue or who just like to nerd out on guns. So it's not surprising to me that NRA activism generates attendance and financial support that dwarfs that of YRO issues, which have none of those features. Again: there may have been YRO-type demonstrations that generated big numbers that would rebut this argument. Maybe you can find one? Otherwise, this is a bit like saying "you can boot a candidate over abortion issues", which handwaves away the fact that abortion is a much, much, much hotter issue in the electorate than YRO issues are. I'm not, like, personally invested in the idea that YRO lacks broad support. I'd probably like a lot of YRO reforms. But I am invested in the notion that we are all talking and debating inside of an echo chamber that is only loosely connected to reality.
- protomyth 11y agoThe NRA has around 4.25 million members, but as you state there is a lot of people invested in this issue. FreedomWorks claims 2,867,538 members. It too has a very large group of aligned people. I have no idea how you find the membership numbers of the EFF. It looks like the EFF received $13.4m and spent $7m in expenses with $5.3 million in salaries. Is there a lobbying arm that I am missing (FreedomWorks has a $5 million lobbying arm, the NRA is, I do believe, 6x that)? I would imagine getting public number for SOPA protests would be a good starting place. If the EFF is the lead organization and its money numbers are it, then you are correct.
- tptacek 11y agoFreedomWorks is the institutional wing of the Tea Party coalition. It isn't a YRO advocacy organization in any meaningful way.
- protomyth 11y agoI was using it for a comparison to establish a medium size organization designed to advocate issues. It does do some YRO because that overlaps with some "small government" advocacy see http://www.freedomworks.org/content/sopa-and-pipa-would-destroy-internet-freedom http://www.freedomworks.org/content/sopa-and-pipa-would-dest... but mostly they have some effectiveness and are around where I thought the EFF might be size wise although that is debatable.
- nsnick 11y agoSenator Bennett was also primaried out in Utah.
- tptacek 11y agoAlso by the Tea Party.