2 ms·
Asset forfeiture suits are structured as in rem proceedings. You are not charging the presumed owner with a crime, nor accusing that person of a civil offense.
by logfromblammo 11y ago
Asset forfeiture suits are structured as in rem proceedings. You are not charging the presumed owner with a crime, nor accusing that person of a civil offense. You are literally accusing an inanimate object of being involved in a crime.
For instance, you might charge a $20 bill with being used to buy methamphetamine. So you take the $20 from the person who was holding it. The identity or presumed innocence of that person is entirely irrelevant. Then you set the $20 bill down at the defendant's table in court and loudly accuse it of being a very, very naughty banknote, who ought to be punished severely, then reformed utterly by being spent for a righteous cause. The judge then casts a severe gaze down upon the money from the bench, and asks the money if it has anything to say in its own defense. Andrew Jackson remains mute.
Meanwhile, everyone else--those who had not been rendered permanently insane by their forfeiture classes in law school--look on and think to themselves "WTF? This is nucking futs."
The (former) owner of the $20 then has to prove that they have standing to represent the $20. Then they have to prove its innocence, because it is not a human, or even a corporate fiction of a person, and therefore does not have the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty.
Everyone outside the existing system sees it like this: the cops stole $20 from some guy, who was never convicted, or even charged with a crime. Then they put him through the legal wringer before even giving him the opportunity to get it back.
A fine has an accused party, and the accuser has to show evidence that the accused was violating a law, regulation, contract, or some other agreement before that fine can be collected. The fine would then be collected after the criminal conviction or civil judgment happened.
The logical place to use forfeiture is where no owner or presumed owner can be found, and there is clear evidence of criminal activity. If you find an abandoned car with stolen plates and a missing VIN, and it had 20kg of cocaine and a stolen AR-15 in the trunk, the state would probably forfeit the car. Anyone coming forward to claim ownership would presumably be charged criminally. You only resort to in rem when no actual person can be found to take responsibility.
That makes some amount of sense.
Unfortunately, forfeiture has warped into a legal mechanism for highway robbery.