5 ms·
I agree that this is a legitimate intelligence target. All of the allies spy one one another all of the time, that's how we keep trust. I think the biggest sca
by Someone1234 11y ago
I agree that this is a legitimate intelligence target. All of the allies spy one one another all of the time, that's how we keep trust.
I think the biggest scandal that isn't discussed often enough (in the US) is not spying on foreign government officials for legitimate security-related reasons (e.g. this), it is spying on foreign government officials to give the US an advantage in trade negotiations or worse passing on "tips" to US-based private companies so they can gain an advantage during negotiations/bidding.
The US constantly beats the capitalism drum, and that's fine. But it seem hypocritical to beat the capitalism drum with one hand, while with the other quietly subverting capitalism by giving certain favored entities tips and advantages.
Even people in the US should be asking why large US corporations are given these tips/advantages/etc while small-medium US businesses are not. Let alone the immorality of helping a US company win against a foreign one due to state supplied corporate espionage.
The justification "well China does it!!1!" while true, is just kind of pathetic. China does a lot of things, doesn't make it right for a country that claims it is the beacon is capitalism and democracy to do the same.
- sayhar 11y ago> The US constantly beats the capitalism drum, and that's fine. But it seem hypocritical to beat the capitalism drum with one hand, while with the other quietly subverting capitalism by giving certain favored entities tips and advantages. For many of us, "capitalism" involves precisely this -- the wealthy using their wealth and power to cement their position.
- wnevets 11y agocapitalism, if you're not cheating you're not trying.
- cpursley 11y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism
- Someone1234 11y agoFair enough. But let me ask you this: Why is the government helping large corporations to cheat more than small or medium companies? Even if we decide cheating is acceptable, shouldn't everyone be on an even footing in terms of this type of help? Seems like the ultimate result is the big get bigger while the small get smaller.
- cryoshon 11y agoThe large corporations give more campaign donations (bribes) to the individuals who make up the political class, which gives the large corporations massive preference when their interests are addressed. Large donations equals political preferences made into reality. Our reality is a result of this going on for almost a century. It is this simple.
- jazzyk 11y agoI agree, but I can't help thinking that the sheer scale/shamelessness of corporate bribery is a recent phenomenon.
- digi_owl 11y agoNever mind that anyone in office can trade on info gleamed while there without being slapped for insider trading, iirc...
- drjesusphd 11y agoThis is true. They removed the exception of insider trading for Congress a few years ago, but put it right back in a year or two later. It's disgusting.
- cpursley 11y agoThe correct definition is "cronyism", not "capitalism". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism
- task_queue 11y agoLeninism/Stalinism/those fucking Trots/Maoism isn't true Communism.
- monstruoso 11y agoIt isn't. It is state capitalism. It is still capitalism.
- deciplex 11y agoIf pure capitalism isn't robust enough that it won't devolve into cronyism then it's just as worthless an ideology as "communism", and for much the same reason. It's not enough that something sounds good and works in theory - humans have to be able to implement it too.
- mindcrime 11y agoFor many of us, "capitalism" involves precisely this That's not capitalism at all. That's just corruption / cronyism and it can live "on top of" any economic system.
- fauigerzigerk 11y agoThe lines between national interests, immigration restrictions, inherited wealth and cronyism are very blurry though, and not just empirically or historically.
- wil421 11y ago>or worse passing on "tips" to US-based private companies so they can gain an advantage during negotiations/bidding. >But it seem hypocritical to beat the capitalism drum with one hand, while with the other quietly subverting capitalism by giving certain favored entities tips and advantages. Do you have any sources for this? I am genuinely curious. If there was anything in any of the leaked Snowden slides detailing any US companies they give info to that would be greatly appreciated.
- jazzyk 11y agoThere are more, but this is the best known instance, because Boeing lost a lot of money as a result. http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/20/us-boeing-brazil-insight-idUSBRE9BJ10P20131220 http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/20/us-boeing-brazil-i... "Snowden's documents, many of which were published by Brazil-based U.S. journalist Glenn Greenwald, revealed that Washington had spied on Rousseff's personal communications, those of state-run oil company Petrobras - which Rousseff once chaired - and countless Brazilian citizens".
- tedunangst 11y agoAnd what information was provided to US companies? That's an article about a US company losing business, not an article about a US company benefiting from NSA provided secrets.
- jazzyk 11y agoYes, about a company losing business, but also about surveillance of foreign business entities (Brazil in this case) Also France (below), and yes, the information was shared: From http://techcrunch.com/2015/06/29/new-wikileaks-documents-reveal-nsa-spied-on-top-french-companies/ http://techcrunch.com/2015/06/29/new-wikileaks-documents-rev... "According to an economic espionage order, the NSA intercepted all French corporate contracts and negotiations valued at more than $200 million in many different industries, such as telecommunications, electrical generation, gas, oil, nuclear and renewable energy, and environmental and healthcare technologies. A second economic espionage order called “France: Economic Developments” shows that information was then shared with other U.S. agencies and secretaries, including the Secretary of Energy, the Secretary of Commerce, the Federal Reserve and the Secretary of Treasury. Eventually, this data could have been used to help sign export deals."
- roymurdock 11y ago> it seems hypocritical to beat the capitalism drum with one hand, while with the other quietly subverting capitalism by giving certain favored entities tips and advantages Capitalism is a regulatory and economic framework that allows for the private ownership of capital and assets and is driven by selfish profit motives. In a purely capitalistic system, we wouldn't even have a government to redistribute wealth and provide oversight, or in this case - to spy on other countries and provide information to a few select corporations. The socialistic thing for the government to do would be to distribute these secrets evenly among all US businesses. So government favoring big business is actually another triumph of capitalism.
- cpursley 11y agoI believe you mean "cronyism" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crony_capitalism
- radmuzom 11y agoGiven that there is no perfectly capitalist society, and in practice, all capitalist structures degenerate into crony-capitalist structures without strong government regulations, I would say there is no difference.
- deciplex 11y agoYou sound exactly like people who insist that communism has never "really" been tried. Look, if a framework for running a society and an economy is so fragile that it immediately devolves into something else, then it's worthless. It doesn't matter if you can point to all the mistakes that were made along the way - if humans can't implement it and make it work, and if there are countless examples of them trying and failing to do this, then it's broken.
- duaneb 11y agoDoesn't spying indicate a de facto lack of trust?
- kazinator 11y agoDoesn't it indicate a lack of trust to have an agency like the NSA in the first place? (And, really, why would the US government and its agency trust some Germans overseas, when it doesn't trust its own people at home?)
- Nadya 11y agoNo. We don't trust each other. But if we all know we're all spying on each other we're a lot less likely to act up fearing that someone else will find out. It's not a super friendly close relationship like you might have with a sibling or your lifelong best friend. But it's "I know you're not doing anything bad. You know I'm not doing anything bad. So until one of us does something bad, we can 'trust' each other and continue business like usual."
- duaneb 11y agoThat's not trust, that's just continual observation.
- caskance 11y agoTrust means something different in every context. I don't trust my wife the same way I trust Digicert, but I "trust" both. This is what it means for nations to trust each other.
- duaneb 11y agoYou trust your understanding of the math underlying Digicert. I don't see how we trust germany at all if we are spying on them. It's one thing to collect signal intelligence within bounds, and it's quite another to continually exploit an ally's vulnerabilities to your own advantage. What about the trust we have for our government? I don't recall anyone justifying the NSA's existence with anything other than the threat of soviets (and then... terrorists, which has frustratingly increased dramatically domestically since the beginning of this practice.)
- tptacek 11y agoThe irony here is that the European Union states are famously among the worst industrial espionage offenders, particularly between Germany and France. This isn't a "US and China" thing.
- justicezyx 11y agoNo it's just US and China, and actually it is just China... Before Snowden, no one admits these stuff, or talk it in public...
- wahsd 11y agoIts really all just a show. Our economy runs purely on the perceived confidence built through illusion and leveraging the immense natural resources we have.
- linkydinkandyou 11y agoI'd expect my Government to spy on other Governments. We have a need to. Any American who objects to this is short-sighted. What we shouldn't do is spy on American citizens within our borders as a routine practice.
- caskance 11y agoAgree that American citizens are not legitimate targets in and of themselves, but they will routinely communicate with people other than American citizens and those communications mean that citizens will be spied on. That's globalization for ya.
- kra34 11y agoI don't understand what you mean when you say "spy on American citizens" do you mean court order/warrant approved surveillance? Even your local police can do that, its generally how criminal investigations are conducted.
- happyscrappy 11y agoThis story doesn't work to berate the US so move the goalposts. Maybe submit a story you have?