11 ms·
OS X 10.11 El Capitan: Review
- carlob 11y agoNo Siracusa?
- danbee 11y agohttp://hypercritical.co/2015/04/15/os-x-reviewed http://hypercritical.co/2015/04/15/os-x-reviewed
- cowsandmilk 11y agoretired from writing the reviews: http://hypercritical.co/2015/04/15/os-x-reviewed http://hypercritical.co/2015/04/15/os-x-reviewed
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- jfb 11y agoIt's a shame he's retired from doing them, given the grievous collapse in the quality of the writing at Ars Technica, but he's got a life to live. I suppose.
- untog 11y agoHere's hoping my Macbook will successfully reconnect to Wifi when waking up. I'm not optimistic, though.
- jkimmel 11y agoHere's to hoping Bluetooth on my Macbook won't stop working every time I put the computer to sleep. Then hanging the entire system when I try to toggle it off/on.
- jmduke 11y agoOh man, I thought I was the only one. I've searched a bunch about this online but couldn't find anything. This mainly happens when I'm connected for an audio speaker. Weirdly, connecting it to my Bluetooth keyboard after the fact sometimes helps?
- xenophonf 11y agoOh man, the buggy Bluetooth stack in 10.10 is a huge source of frustration for me. At first I thought it was my peripherals, but they work without any trouble within EFI or Windows on the same hardware. I even tried poking at the stack using Bluetooth Explorer (part of Xcode), to no avail.
- xenophonf 11y agoWell, to answer my own question - nope, still having problems with Bluetooth in 10.11. Normally, I wouldn't complain about something so basic, but it's really, really annoying when something that I use every day (like my BT mouse) only works sporadically in Mac OS X. Edit: I've tried creating a new network location, resetting PRAM, resetting SMC, deleting Bluetooth PAN, re-installing the OS. Nothing seems to work reliably, and I don't know what else to try at this point.
- archseer 11y agoTry this: http://osxdaily.com/2015/02/18/remove-bluetooth-pan-wi-fi-conflict-os-x-yosemite/ http://osxdaily.com/2015/02/18/remove-bluetooth-pan-wi-fi-co...
- thought_alarm 11y agoYou shouldn't be optimistic. I own a number of different machines running the same software and one of these machines just has flaky wifi. Random disconnects or stalls during large downloads. No software update is going to fix that machine.
- MrJagil 11y agoWhy did you have to phrase it like that? I don't feel it benefits discussion. It doesn't feel like the HN way. If you had done an inquiry into the matter, linked to a stack exchange discussion on this bug persisting or being fixed that would've been a lot more useful. Maybe some technological quirks would surface that we could learn from. It's such a shame submissions like these, which the author clearly has spent a lot of time on, will get derided with snark like yours. Now jkimmel continued in this vain; your comment has anchored the discussion in what i feel is a negative way.
- Sean-Der 11y agoBecause it is frustrating to debug a closed system. I am all for starting a stack exchange discussion when working on things that built communally and not locked down. However, when you are paying Apple for a product, it is frustrating to deal with things being broken and on top of that you have to circumvent their restrictions.
- untog 11y agoBecause it is frustrating. Judging by my post getting positive votes as opposed to negative ones, it appears I am not alone in this. Incremental improvements to the Mail app are lovely, but I (and many others) do not use it. I use wi-fi all the time. If you Google "macbook wake up wifi does not work" there are plenty of complaints, a couple of half-hearted solutions, but not much else. I didn't link to any of them because it isn't worth anyone's time to have to read them. Yes, I am technically minded. As such, I could debug this further and further, but: 1) I can only go so far. This problem requires Apple to issue a fix, and they're definitely aware of it. 2) it's a little like asking a car mechanic to do some car repairs in his spare time for fun. My Macbook is a tool, I want it to just work.
- MrJagil 11y agoYeah, I totally get where you're coming from. I'm not asking for you to debug and fix the problem. I get that this is deep-seeded, and the ball is on Apple's court. I just don't want HN to be a place of one-liners. In your original post you were complaining without adding any substance. Sorry if I sound harsh, it just really irks me. Maybe I should've left it at a down-vote, this back-and-forth is not particularly fruitful either.
- fogleman 11y agoJust do what I did. `brew install sleepwatcher` and then make a script at `~/.wakeup` to turn wifi off and back on again: networksetup -setairportpower en0 off networksetup -setairportpower en0 on I finally did this after the El Capitan GM didn't fix my issue.
- sgtnasty 11y agoI will try this, thanks.
- untog 11y agoI'll have to give this a try. Thanks!
- oostevo 11y agoI made a quick little zsh alias for the wifi commands: wifi () { local opt=$1 case "$opt" in (on) networksetup -setairportpower en0 on ;; (off) networksetup -setairportpower en0 off ;; (toggle) networksetup -setairportpower en0 off networksetup -setairportpower en0 on ;; (scan) /System/Library/PrivateFrameworks/Apple80211.framework/Versions/A/Resources/airport en0 scan ;; ("" | -h | --help) echo "Usage: wifi <option>" echo "option:" echo "\ton\tSet Airport adapter on" echo "\toff\tSetAirport adapter off" echo "\ttoggle\tTurns wifi off and then on again" echo "\tscan\tList available wifi networks" return 0 ;; esac } Note that this is only tested on my computer, ymmv, etc.
- shanemhansen 11y agoI'm so glad I use linux so I don't have to mess around with shell scripts to get my laptop working.
- pravka 11y agoI remember using Linux on a laptop; <sarcasm>everything worked so well without any tweaking whatsoever.</sarcasm>
- letitgo12345 11y agoI'm just praying that my wifi doesn't start disconnecting again every 1 minute...seriously wifi is one of the most basic things to have in a laptop. Why is it so hard for Apple to get this right?
- fauigerzigerk 11y agoIf you have a router that supports 2.4ghz and 5ghz networks, try using the 2.4ghz one and give each network its own SSID. That's what worked for me, but it's obviously a shot in the dark.
- FireBeyond 11y agoThis. Create "MySSID 5" and "MySSID 2.4" (or however), and then rank the two in priority order, 5 over 2.4. Then the OS will prefer the (usually less crowded, but shorter range) 5GHz network and fall back as needed. I used to have the two on the same SSID, but I found my adapters (or the OS) would gain an 'affinity' for 2.4 as the stronger signal and never use 5.
- mozumder 11y agoThis happened to me. I just upgraded my router to a new Airport Extreme, and all those problems magically went away.
- no1youknowz 11y agoI have not rebooted my macbook (late 2012) running yosemite for 9 months. I always put the lid down after work and in the morning lift it up. I never have any problems with performance, nor do I have issues with wifi. I'm a full stack dev, so always running with a vm, sublime, irc app, chrome and terminal. Everything just works fine for me. Will be upgrading tomorrow. Like I did for Yosemite and Mavericks.
- FireBeyond 11y agoNo problems with performance, no issues with Wifi... ... but probably significant security issues, given that you've missed 10.10.2 + 4 security combo updates. And 10.10.3 + 1 security combo update. And 10.10.4. And 10.10.5. (which isn't to be snarky, but more 'odd' that a confessed Day 1 Updater then doesn't touch system updates until the next major release).
- jasonjei 11y agoWhat's the recommendation if you're using command/shell utilities on upgrading vs. clean install from Yosemite to El Capitan? I usually do a clean install, but would an upgrade be advisable?
- asdfjkln 11y agoI've upgraded my Macbook Air since Lion without issue. There's no reason to expect trouble coming from the new security features as homebrew/macports as well as sane make scripts default to installing outside system directories anyway. In the worst case, you'll just have to reinstall the offending applications. Of course you still do a backup before in case the universe blows up.
- nieve 11y agoHomebrew installing outside system directories hasn't protected it in the past and the directory/root lockdown isn't the only change, remember the tun/tap CF that got dropped in their lap? The 10.9 to 10.10 transition broke a lot of things and more than a few were caused by the security changes. Do not trust homebrew to work properly on 10.11 until they can find & stomp on all the bugs Apple has graciously handed them, it's not a safe bet at all and more than a few network apps (for example) do need root at some points.
- acdha 11y agoI've done upgrades since 10.1 was released without issues. If you've followed Apple's filesystem layout and haven't altered system files or rely on some exotic kernel extensions, you'll be fine. The one annoyance I've encountered is that the installer will move everything in /usr/local out of the way before doing the upgrade and moving it back. If you have a large Homebrew install, it will be much faster to move the directory first and restore it later rather than waiting for the file-by-file copy to complete, even on when using SSDs.
- to3m 11y agoI only did upgrades on my old MBP too, and always found it fine. I went from Leopard to Snow Leopard to Lion to Mountain Lion to Mavericks. Nothing serious went wrong at any point (though I did have to reinstall or update the odd program), and there was no noticeable deterioration in performance over time. There was the odd infuriating bug (I'm not convinced it's tested as thoroughly as Windows is...), but overall it was fairly trouble free and the smooth upgrade process played a part in my decision to buy another. It certainly wasn't the price, at any rate.
- on_ 11y agoIs there any way I can get this today without being a "certified apple developer" or whatever the language is. I have to reformat anyway and really don't want to reinstall yosemite and then have my settings ovcerrun on the upgrade in 2 days.
- guywithabike 11y agoYep, Apple has a public beta channel now: https://beta.apple.com/sp/betaprogram/ https://beta.apple.com/sp/betaprogram/
- on_ 11y agoWhile that took minimal effort on your part, I want you to know that it was really really helpful. Thanks a lot. Is this new or something? I couldn't find it a few weeks ago when the GM was released?
- carlosrg 11y agoI stopped caring about OS reviews after virtually every Yosemite (10.10.0) review failed to mention the drop in performance and battery life and the discoveryd and Wifi problems last year. These were not isolated issues and a lot of people suffered them, I'd say in a much higher proportion than any first release of OS X since 10.0. At least the Ars Technica people are smart and recommend people to wait until 10.11.1 if they can (although last year Yosemite 10.10.1 didn't solve anything). I have to chuckle when I see some reviews saying "UPDATE _RIGHT NOW_! THIS IS THE BEST OS EVER!". They said the same last year, what a coincidence. Personally, I feel that Yosemite 10.10.5 is very stable now, and I'll wait at least until 10.11.2 to upgrade, no matter how many times people tell me how wonderful El Capitan is.
- kingnight 11y agoIt's tough to hold out on major OS upgrades as they come up with a number of new app features and enhancements that are coupled with the OS.
- cake 11y agoSame here, Yosemite is the new Windows Vista ! I'm finally stable enough with 10.10.4 after many kernel panics, not gonna rush it to upgrade. I'll wait for 10.11.1. El capitan seems promising though.
- dr_win 11y agoYou are late. El Capitan GM which was released mid Sep to developers has been already marked as 10.11.1 (build 15B17c).
- X-Istence 11y agoI've got the 10.11 GM running on my 2012 Mac Mini (Core i7) with spinning rust, and it has made such a huge improvement over 10.10 in terms of snappiness and how fast the entire OS feels. It is a world of difference, to the point that I am happily using my Mac Mini for stuff again, whereas before I would avoid it as much as possible and instead reach for my MacBook Pro Retina to get anything done.
- 11y ago
- pjmlp 11y agoAs expected, being on the Khronos board doesn't mean anything. http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/09/os-x-10-11-el-capitan-the-ars-technica-review/7/#h2 http://arstechnica.com/apple/2015/09/os-x-10-11-el-capitan-t...
- FraKtus 11y agoOpenGL is not improving in El Capitan and it's a problem for cross-platform developers.
- pjmlp 11y agoKind of, it is a problem for the developers that write their own engines, instead of using middleware. For the middleware companies, it isn't a problem to write multiple backends, as it is the reason why they exist in first place. Also OpenGL never had much use in the consoles, for example. However, it just goes to show that company X will do Y, because they sit in some Y organization isn't given.
- outworlder 11y agoThis is worrying. It reeks of Microsoft's DirectX strategy from a decade ago. I suppose I should be happy that Apple does not anywhere near the same market share that Windows did when Microsoft came up with that.
- pjmlp 11y agoNo, it is Apple back to being itself. The old Apple was even more proprietary than Microsoft was. All hardware and software were Apple specific.
- duaneb 11y agoAnd another version release updating apps I don't use, ushering in new interfaces nobody wants, while leaving core infrastructure (e.g. containerization, a better launchd interface for an amazing init system, an ancient filesystem, allowing things like rendering contexts across process bounderies, etc) leave me scratching my head. I feel like they're trying to convince me to abandon my tools because they have been messing with them for next to no reason since snow leopard. (exception: I love the app store and sandboxing.)
- msbarnett 11y agoWhile it's true that this release doesn't touch your pet issues, I'm left scratching my head as to why you expect that Apple will ever address some of those issues. Containerization is unlikely to ever get a big push from Apple -- whatever half-hearted designs they had on the server space are long-since abandoned, and it's clear they favor far less heavyweight security measures for end-user apps. "Rendering Contexts across process boundaries" doesn't even sound like it has a good use-case for any direction Apple's been working on.
- duaneb 11y ago> "Rendering Contexts across process boundaries" doesn't even sound like it has a good use-case for any direction Apple's been working on. Well web sandboxing for one, and running opengl through your terminal for another. Containerization seems like a no-brainer to me since a) sandboxing naturally follows, b) it's a developer's heaven in terms of deployment, development, and testing, c) mac os x is now the only major OS in existence without any containerization capabilities controlable by anyone but apple. And these aren't just pet issues, no developer I know (except perhaps iOS developers, for obvious reasons) welcome them. Even the non-technical users I know see them as "pretty" PITAes. And it's not that I don't get why they do it, I just wonder about how they view the *nix-ey developers who use the platform. I'm sure there must be plenty at the company itself.
- msbarnett 11y ago> Well web sandboxing for one, and running opengl through your terminal for another. Sharing OpenGL contexts is about the opposite of sandboxing. It's unsafe. And you can run OpenGL apps from your terminal just fine? > Containerization seems like a no-brainer to me since a) sandboxing naturally follows, But it's a sandboxing that isn't useful on a Desktop machine. A mail app which sees a completely different container filesystem than my word processor does not improve my life. > b) it's a developer's heaven in terms of deployment, development, and testing Except it's not, because OS X on servers is dead and gone, so what I'd really need is a container that works on my server, aka a Linux server aka I need a VM locally because it's not like OS X is ever going to be LXC compatible. A container I can only use on my dev box isn't worth beans. > c) mac os x is now the only major OS in existence without any containerization capabilities controlable by anyone but apple. I get that Docker has grabbed a lot of hype by reinventing jails to be venture capital compatible, but honestly, for OS X it makes absolutely no sense whatsoever.
- mwcampbell 11y agoI think the review overstates the problems that developers might have with System Integrity Protection. It seems to me that if an application developer has to disable SIP, then that app developer is probably doing something wrong. Better to accept SIP as good for everyone, like app sandboxing.
- outworlder 11y agoExcept that app sandboxing excludes a lot of otherwise useful apps.
- tomschlick 11y agoThat the majority of people would never use. Better to secure the 99% and inconvenience us developer for the 1% of apps that need sandboxing removed.
- outworlder 11y agoOh please. Where did you take your 1% from? If your application is not a game, or it does not fit the model of "here be a document, type on it", chances are the sandbox won't allow it. Actually, even if you do follow that model: see BBEdit and Coda. What about Postbox? iStatsMenu? Heck, even Alfred. Or Parallels, Microsoft Office, the Adobe suite? These cannot be sandboxed. Frankly, I could come up with more applications if I did some research, but why bother. Nearly everything that's interesting that's not a game will be crippled or just unavailable. And, for games, Steam is better in every way. EDIT: By "cannot be sandboxed", I mean that they cannot be sandboxed under Apple's current draconian sandboxing rules.
- simonh 11y agoOn the bright side, at least none of Apple's pro apps on the App Store have been excluded due to breaking sandbox restrictions.
- mh- 11y agoBecause app developers can request specific sandbox exemptions (so-called "temporary exceptions") when they submit to the app store. You can view these exceptions by dumping the Container.plist inside a sandboxed app's container, e.g. for Calendar: /usr/libexec/PlistBuddy -c "print SandboxProfileDataValidationInfo" $HOME/Library/Containers/com.apple.iCal/Container.plist Look at the keys beginning with `com.apple.security.temporary-exception`. (Also note that some Apple apps don't have containers, like iTunes.)
- jlarocco 11y ago<rant> Ugh. Apple software quality has been going downhill so fast lately I loathe seeing the "Software Update Available" notification. If I'm lucky everything will still work, and it will merely scramble the interface and hide a bunch of stuff. Unfortunately, my expectation is that on top of the interface scrambling, a bunch of stuff that's worked fine for ages will be broken in some stupid way I can't even imagine how it could happen, like it will start duplicating playlists on my phone again. Oh, and I'm guessing it will try to shove at least one unwanted, half-assed Apple service down my throat, integrate it with everything, and force me to search online for 20 minutes looking for how to turn it off, only to find out there's either no way to opt out, or the option is hidden in some obscure, unexpected location in System Preferences, or via some command line BS. Every new release from Apple I get one step closer to switching back to Linux. Love their hardware, but their software people need to get their shit together. </rant>
- adrianN 11y agoSo, don't update? I'm still running 10.8 on my 2008 Macbook and I only install security updates. If the new version doesn't have any features that you must have, why update?
- lisper 11y agoBecause Apple uses a version ratchet to force you to upgrade. I essentially use only one app on my iPhone. It's a mobile banking app. On a regular basis, my mobile banking app stops working and requires me to upgrade. Sooner or later, to upgrade the banking app, I have to upgrade my iOS, which eventually forces me to upgrade iTunes, which eventually forces me to upgrade OS X. Western civilization has been in decline ever since Snow Leopard was deprecated. I hung to that as long as I possibly could, but even I eventually had to upgrade to Mavericks. Mavericks is tolerable, but the writing on the wall is clear: to use Apple products, you will eventually have to surrender to the software update.
- jeromegv 11y agoYou don't really need to sync your iPhone with iTunes if you don't need to. Everything is supported as a standalone device.
- chmars 11y agoIs Apple Mail in El Capitan playing friendly with Gmail? In Yosemite, it's OK except for drafts. And that's of course a big 'except' …
- chrisBob 11y agoMy wife and I have also seen lots of issues connecting to school gmail accounts. Every update I hope to see some bug fixes about Gmail on the list.
- dchuk 11y agoFor drafts, you can turn off synchronization of drafts to gmail's servers and it will fix your issues: http://www.ivanexpert.com/blog/2013/04/gmail-dont-save-os-x-mail-drafts-to-server/ http://www.ivanexpert.com/blog/2013/04/gmail-dont-save-os-x-...
- xpect0 11y agoDid any one on Yosemite had that random AirPlay icon poping on the bar. issue, even without any apple TV in the network ??
- rhodysurf 11y agoYup I got it all the time and I still get it with El Capitan
- xpect0 11y agohave you paired any iphone over bluetooth., try to remove it and turn off the bluetooth. check if you still getting that issue., I created a local account and turned off bluetooth., havent seen it for a while now.
- newman314 11y agoFor those that use ssh frequently on OS X, El Capitan finally supports ed25519 keys. It was nice and responsive even over a slow connection over the weekend while having to RDP to a remote server.
- fuzzywalrus 11y agoI'm curious how much Metal matters but it seems like they went from GPU to CPU in Yosemite and then back to the GPU. The review sorta skimmed on Metal but reported that it only worked on a Mac Pro 2013, which lead me to wonder why my 2008 Mac Pro couldn't run it with a GeForce 680 GTX, turns out it can. http://netkas.org/?p=1405 http://netkas.org/?p=1405
- lispm 11y agoI fear that this is one of the worse OSX updates. I've seen a lot of issues in the GM. For example my USB audio device (an amplifier) is no longer working. The Wifi connectivity issues are not fixed. The Airdrop connection between my MacBook and the iPad Air does not work. A Lisp system did not start because Apple removed some font protocol. Stuff like Screen split between two apps are non-intuitive. There is lots of good stuff, but Apple created also new problems or failed to fix really annoying old problems (like Wifi connectivity issues, the buggy and unreliable Finder, the annoying slowness of iTunes with larger music libraries, ...).
- Artemis2 11y ago> my USB audio device (an amplifier) is no longer working I have the same issue with my two USB amplifiers! I couldn't find anything about it online though.
- lispm 11y agoThere is a discussion group at Apple where lots of people seem to have the same problem with various different USB audio devices.
- muddi900 11y agoFinally implemented my favorite Windows feature, window snapping.