4 ms·
Tracking, it's been argued, is good because it allows more relevant ads to be served. I've been giving Google huge amounts of data about me and my life for almo
by criddell 11y ago
Tracking, it's been argued, is good because it allows more relevant ads to be served. I've been giving Google huge amounts of data about me and my life for almost 20 years and the ads are still terrible. I spend thousands of dollars every year at Amazon and their recommendation engine doesn't do much better.
How much more do advertisers need to know about me before ads served online are significantly more relevant than the ads I see in People magazine at the doctor's office?
At this point, I'm super skeptical about the ad business. Advertisements don't really bother me that much, but I'm becoming less comfortable with being tracked. I would love to see a study that compares the costs of tracking with the added value of tracking and see who pays those costs and who benefits from the value.
- electricblue 11y agoGoogle benefits, the costs are negligible compared to the revenue they get. Its the entire business model. The problem for content creators is I can't think of much written content that i'm willing to pay a subscription fee for. I doubt I am alone in this.
- criddell 11y ago> the costs are negligible The costs are not negligible. Tracking scripts use a lot of bandwidth and (on mobile) battery power.
- astazangasta 11y agoThe costs are negligible for Google. See here: https://investor.google.com/financial/tables.html https://investor.google.com/financial/tables.html The major stated revenue costs seem to be traffic acquisition costs (payouts for YouTube and the like, I imagine). Bandwidth is probably a minor issue - anyway they are making 60% profits on revenues of $66 billion a year.
- Spivak 11y agoExactly, just because the cost is distributed doesn't mean it's not being paid in one form or another. If ad networks actually had to pay the cost, say $10/GB of traffic they served to mobile devices, ads would be lighter and far less spammy.
- venomsnake 11y agoI would pay 1c for reading Nytimes or rockpapershotgun article. There is no easy way to give 1c though.
- criddell 11y agoI think Google Contributor solves the I-don't-want-to-see-ads problem, but does nothing (AFAIK) for the I-don't-want-to-be-tracked problem.
- vinceguidry 11y agoTaking money directly from end users has never been a really good strategy for individual content creators. It effectively turns each piece of content into its own little product, each requiring a marketing strategy, distribution, payment. The overhead adds up too quickly.
- egypturnash 11y agoIMHO Patreon is probing otherwise. I now make more money per page drawing my weird comic about a robot lady with Philip K Dick problems than many people make drawing stuff for Marvel or DC. And I'm an obscure cartoonist with a tiny following.
- Touche 11y agoLink? Sounds like something I'd want to purchase.
- egypturnash 11y agoAll online for free: http://egypt.urnash.com/rita/ http://egypt.urnash.com/rita/ Also there are links to the store where you can buy the first two printed volumes (kickstarter for the third and final one soon, I have two pages left to finish) and to the Patreon, which will get you PDFs.
- stevenh 11y agoImagine if you didn't just have to pay UPS a small fee to deliver your package, but you also had to pay them the entire cost of the product itself, none of which went to the manufacturer. The manufacturer had to include a ton of ads in the package and hope that it would cover the cost of creating the product. That is the situation we have on the internet today, and it's not okay. Laws should be changed so that half of the portion of your monthly ISP bill that the company used to consider profit instead becomes the money used for this compensation of content creators. Evenly distribute the money based on the time the user spends interacting with a given site in the frontmost tab. Implement a new HTTP header the server can send to indicate where payment can be made. All major browser vendors should agree to respect this, and all ISPs should be legally required to go along with it rather than pocketing everything.
- criddell 11y agoI think that's a terrible idea. Should the people who sell trucks and airplanes to UPS also be entitled to some percentage of UPS' profit?
- marak830 11y agoThats a horrible idea. Wouldnt that require enforced tracking? What about people who put up free blogs? I'm sprry but if your business model isnt working online, then you need a new business model. If its not working, asking for a new system wont save it.
- monochromatic 11y agoThis bothers me too. Google should be able to read my mind at this point. And yet... I can count on one hand the number of times I've bought something via a web ad. (I could probably even do it on a hand that didn't have any fingers.) Showing me an ad for something that's similar to something I bought last week is about as good as it gets, and that's not very good.
- _up 11y agoThis is by design they make more money (long term) if the target thinks his privacy is save. So only a percentage is targeted at you the rest are decoys.
- monochromatic 11y agoBut the percentage of well-targeted ads is zero.
- JulianMorrison 11y agoIntra-site, they can be rather common. My Amazon and Etsy logins have long wishlists.
- monochromatic 11y agoThat's true. Amazon knows what I've bought and what I've thought about buying. But Google knows every damn thing about me. Google ads should be slaughtering Amazon suggestions, and they aren't.
- gaius 11y agoThe location based stuff is creepy until you actually want to use it, then it becomes useless. E.g. they geolocate my IP so they can show me ads that "someone in <your town> makes $3000/hr working from home!!" but if I search for "pizza" it will recommend me a place in Wyoming instead of <my town>. The value add of it to me is less than zero. Not to mention that when you buy something you only want one of, you will be bombarded by ads for the same thing...
- norea-armozel 11y agoI agree. It's been a bit of a let down for me when I disabled ad blocking when I moved from Wichita to Des Moines (and finally to Minneapolis) since nothing really gave me a good idea of what was in the area unless I used sites like Yelp or FourSquare. Google's own ads didn't give a single hint of what was local to me. It seems the whole local ad network concept may be a failure. At least for now.
- jstelly 11y agoIf I type "weather" or "The Martian movie times" into google I get useful local results. But I see it being used for useless and creepy things also.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- pjc50 11y ago(a) too much data and (b) the value is not just in what's included but what's rejected. You can't trust servers to be honest about their own indexes. Google work very hard at anti-"SEO" measures.
- pjc50 11y agoSo who are the tracked ads aimed at? Is this a question of hunting the 1%, the "whales"?
- bunderbunder 11y agoTargeted advertising has been around for a long time without all this creepy tracking. I recently switched car insurance due to a targeted advertisement. It was a billboard on a subway platform. Tracking has also been around for a long time without the creepy stalker stuff. Whenever you redeem a coupon, you're giving companies feedback on whether or not the ad the coupon is attached to is reaching the intended audience. And tracking individuals to get a clearer picture has been around for a long time without the violation of consent. Nielsen families know all about that. What I think is problematic is the individualization. Signaling is an important part of advertisements. With an oldschool advertisement I get some extra information indicating that the company is legitimate and in good shape. Oldschool ads are expensive, so companies that place them are sending a clear message that they can afford them, and that they have enough faith in their product to think it will pay off. Individualization, by contrast, makes it impossible for me to distinguish between a big robust ad campaign and some fly-by-night company singling me out in an effort to sell the equivalent of crap from Skymall. And it does too much to enable parasitic advertising, where a company that wants to sell to people who read Harper's can avoid paying for ads on Harper's because they can instead follow those people to less-glamorous places and advertise to them there.