4 ms·
I won't even touch the political reflexive negativity surrounding Common Core. However, the only non-political (I'm being nice ...) criticism I continue to see
by bsder 11y ago
I won't even touch the political reflexive negativity surrounding Common Core.
However, the only non-political (I'm being nice ...) criticism I continue to see is in the mathematics. And it's always because of "word problems". Common Core likes "word problems" and reasoning a LOT.
I have taught math. With very few exceptions, everybody hates word problems. Most students just want "Give me the question and give me the procedure so I can regurgitate the procedure. Don't make me think." They don't want to reason.
You can see this even in senior year of high school in the US in science. Just try to get the students to explain why they are doing an experiment (In short: "state the hypothesis"). It's almost always a disaster. After a year, you might get a majority up to the point where they can actually state it coherently.
I have this problem even with some really senior engineers when debugging things. "We did X, Y, and Z. They didn't work." "Um, okay, why did you do X, Y, or Z?" "Huh?!?!?!" "Why should X, Y or Z have worked? Is there a relation between X, Y, or Z and the problem? What is it?" <puzzled stares>
So, I see the objections as positive evidence that the Common Core standards are doing their job. The fact that adults have trouble with some of these problems is no surprise. Most of them skated through reasoning and word problems themselves.
- DanBC 11y ago> You can see this even in senior year of high school in the US in science. Just try to get the students to explain why they are doing an experiment (In short: "state the hypothesis"). This starts very young. Most "science for kids" on the Internet is little more than "here's a demonstration of something, and here's a sciency explanation of what's going on". Most sites don't suggest making any changes to the setup, or ask any questions about what happens if you do stuff differently. (I'm keen to find good science content for children that does teach scientific method, so please let me know of any good sites).
- thraxil 11y agoTotally agree on the importance of reasoning. Word problems though are often hated because they're so ambiguous in unintentional ways that don't really relate to the problem. Eg, in the middle school example on the page, when it says "She makes $4.40" do they mean net or gross? In this case, it turns out that only one of those gives you an integer answer, so you can work out what they meant, but it's not uncommon to see problems where that's not the case and you're stuck making a 50/50 guess. With the current emphasis on test scores, that adds a lot of stress.
- bsder 11y ago> Word problems though are often hated because they're so ambiguous in unintentional ways that don't really relate to the problem. Statistical analysis helps this dramatically. I remember all of the SAT prep books I used to have. I could never score much better than just very good. Never understood what the problem was. Then I got actual SAT's from previous years. Perfect scores, no problem. The difference was that the SAT questions had been vetted by statistical analysis. Any question that was ambiguous was removed or reworded.
- malyk 11y agoAs a student I loved word problems and hated the straight equation ones. It always pissed me off that there were 35 explicit 45 - 17 = ? questions and 4 word problems. I wonder what, if anything, that says about people. Should I start asking people which problems types they preferred during interviews? (that's mostly rhetorical...i think).