3 ms·
Here's the paper's first paragraph, matching what the article said: "Jack takes a coin from his pocket and decides that he will flip it 4 times in a row, writi
by DennisP 11y ago
Here's the paper's first paragraph, matching what the article said:
"Jack takes a coin from his pocket and decides that he will flip it 4 times in a row, writing down the outcome of each flip on a scrap of paper. After he is done flipping, he will look at the flips that immediately followed an outcome of heads, and compute the relative frequency of heads on those flips. Because the coin is fair, Jack of course expects this empirical probability of heads to be equal to the true probability of flipping a heads: 0.5. Shockingly, Jack is wrong."
But actually Jack is right. Here are all the possibilities. A "streak" means a head was followed by a head, and a "break" means it was followed by a tail.
Streaks Breaks
TTHT 0 1
TTHH 1 0
THTT 0 1
THTH 0 1
THHT 1 1
THHH 2 0
HTTT 0 1
HTTH 0 1
HTHT 0 2
HTHH 1 1
HHTT 1 1
HHTH 1 1
HHHT 2 1
HHHH 3 0
total 12 12
The paper's argument later is more complex than the first paragraph implies, putting the sequences in groups with fixed numbers of heads. I don't see the point of that but it doesn't seem to help.
They get into some math, but just counting the cases doesn't seem to support their argument at all. If anyone can explain their argument in a simple way, I'm interested.
If they're really confident in this, they should go to Vegas, find a high-rolling gambler, and start betting on coin flips. After each heads, offer 55/45 odds that the next coin flip will be heads. I'm sure it won't be hard to find takers.
- Beltiras 11y agoSee my MC in a post below. I think I understand what they are on about. It's biased against repeating in short runs.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]