2 ms·
Car accidents are still the #1 cause of preventable death worldwide. That strikes me as unlikely, given that car accidents kill something like 50,000 people a
by patio11 17y ago
Car accidents are still the #1 cause of preventable death worldwide.
That strikes me as unlikely, given that car accidents kill something like 50,000 people a year in the US. Just inside the US, an obvious candidate for prevention -- medical mistakes -- kills far more people. (Estimated at 200k per year preventable deaths in hospitals alone.)
Casting our glance worldwide, poorer nations have millions of deaths from causes that aren't even "hard problems", such as clean drinking water, food distribution (solved in Europe in about the 1700s), malaria (solved in America over half a century ago), etc, etc.
- tokenadult 17y ago(Estimated at 200k per year preventable deaths in hospitals alone.) For the United States ALONE? I don't buy it. But prove me wrong by citing an authoritative source if there is one.
- patio11 17y agoCiting an authoritative source doesn't prove you wrong any more than it proves global warming is happening ;) Be that as it may, see generally To Err Is Human by the Institute of Medicine (an arm of the National Science Foundation), which put the tally at 100k back in 1999, or Dr. Chunliu Zhan and Dr. Marlene R. Miller in a research study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) in October of 2003.
- teej 17y agoThe Zhan & Miller study in 2003 supported the IOM's conclusion of ~98k deaths due to medical errors. The 200k number you quoted earlier was "found" by a study by some random website and was not published in any medical journal. Not to downplay the severity of the issue, but there is a big difference between 100k and 200k lives.
- cakesy 17y agoReally, in what way? How much less should we spend to fix this problem if there is only 100,00 deaths? I feel car deaths are much worse. Most hospital deaths affect people who are already sick, and elderly, whereas car deaths can hit anyone at anytime.
- tokenadult 17y agoThanks for the source. That was easy to Google with the clear information you provided. No, several of those causes of death would not fit the usual definition of "preventable deaths." Those patients may not have received the best care that they should have received, but it's overextrapolating to say that they died but for errors in treatment.
- Devilboy 17y agoWorld stats (causes of death) according to WHO: 1) Coronary heart disease - 12.2% 2) Stroke and other cerebrovascular diseases - 9.7% 3) Lower respiratory infections - 7.1% 4) Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease - 5.1% 5) Diarrhoeal diseases - 3.7% 6) HIV/AIDS - 3.5% 7) Tuberculosis - 2.5% 8) Trachea, bronchus, lung cancers - 2.3% 9) Road traffic accidents - 2.2% Although maybe it's more correct to say the leading cause of accidental death is car crashes. I guess 'preventable' is too broad a word.
- shaddi 17y agoYes. In the public health course I took last semester, road traffic accidents were the most common form of death by injury, if I remember correctly. Turns out, tobacco use is the leading cause of preventable death worldwide, a label applied to diseases that can be avoided through the use of vaccination or healthy behavior. "Preventable" has a fairly specific meaning in the public health community, as opposed to its common-use dictionary definition. Obviously, the latter isn't very useful since most ailments are "preventable" if you think broadly enough.
- enjo 17y agoIt appears that the leading cause of death for folks under the age of 35 is auto accidents (the bulk of 'unintentional injuries' if I understand the data correctly). http://www.chdl.org/Projects/10%20Leading%20Causes%20of%20Death%20by%20Age%20Group%202001.pdf http://www.chdl.org/Projects/10%20Leading%20Causes%20of%20De...