3 ms·
"There" is reasonable doubt doesn't mean much. Reasonable doubt is not an observable quantity, like water on Mars; the question is whether jurors in the case d
by bambax 11y ago
"There" is reasonable doubt doesn't mean much.
Reasonable doubt is not an observable quantity, like water on Mars; the question is whether jurors in the case doubted of the culpability of the accused. Obviously they didn't.
If they did, that may save this man's life, but do nothing against death penalty. Death penalty is barbaric; if you can make the case that guilty people should not be executed, I think it's much stronger than if you just argue in favor of the innocent.
... notwithstanding the fact that Scalia argued in 2009 that executing innocent people was perfectly fine: "This Court has never held that the Constitution forbids the execution of a convicted defendant who has had a full and fair trial but is later able to convince a habeas court that he is 'actually' innocent". (You have to love the quotes around the word 'actually').
- - -
Completely OT: inconsistent number of spaces after periods is very annoying (the second paragraph has one, the third or 7th have two for example; the 6th paragraph has both). The correct number of spaces after a period is ONE, but if you disagree, the least you can do is be consistent.
- Peaker 11y agoThe point of the essay is that the incompetence causes reasonable doubt not to mean much. And that's why they end up executing innocent people.