5 ms·
I upvoted this mainly because I think it's healthy that people consider the ethics by which they and their fellow citizens live. But generally speaking, this is
by peterwwillis 11y ago
I upvoted this mainly because I think it's healthy that people consider the ethics by which they and their fellow citizens live. But generally speaking, this is a stupid reason not to kill someone.
The DA basically told this guy point-blank that if you don't want to die, take this deal. If you do want to die, don't take the deal.
He chose not to take the deal.
Is there a chance that "good sense" could have prevailed, and that by some fluke, some part of the system wouldn't work, and so he would be saved from the death penalty? Maybe. But if he had taken the deal, he would definitely not have died.
This guy chose to play russian roulette with a six-shooter with five bullets in it and lost. And this is the reason we shouldn't kill people? Because a guy who can't do the basic math of "which choice is more likely to end in my death" chose poorly?
No. The guy should have taken the deal. Much like the rest of the people on the planet who choose to take huge risks with their life, he's going to lose out on this bet. And that has nothing to do with why we should stop the state from killing people.
Our system of justice is based on laws and rules. They can't be broken arbitrarily, which is why innocent people are put to death. Not because we're mean. Not because we're stupid. We make the rules, and we have to enforce them. In this case, one of our rules is, if you do X, you die.
So, if you don't believe in killing innocent people, by all means, get rid of that rule. But don't tell me we should get rid of the rule because the rules weren't perfect.
- epmatsw 11y agoIf he's innocent, he chose to not go to jail for life for a crime he didn't commit. People shouldn't have to accept unjust punishment to avoid other people's ignorance/laziness/incompetence/half-assedness.
- gohrt 11y ago1. That is blaming the victim. 2. Telling someone that I intend to kill them, means that is would be stupid to not kill them?
- URSpider94 11y agoSo, if I'm innocent, I should take a plea bargain (which, let's not forget, involves me standing up before God and everyone and saying, "yes, I did it," so that I can spend the rest of my life in a maximum security penitentiary, so that I can avoid being put to death? Not sure I agree with your logic there.
- peterwwillis 11y agoHere's a diagram of the logic. Do you want to die? Y -> Reject offer. -> Death penalty. N -> Accept offer. -> Life in prison. I don't know how I could simplify this further.
- gizmo 11y agoLife isn't just about cold pragmatism. Sometimes you have to stand up for you believe is right, especially when the odds aren't in your favor.
- wutwatt 11y agoWhy would anyone ask an innocent person if he wants to die? Your premise is faulty.
- lotharbot 11y agoHere's a simpler diagram: did you do it? Y -> address "do you want to die" question N -> "I don't deserve to either die or spend my life in prison" -> rely on the justice system to do the right thing
- cortesoft 11y agoThat wasn't the choice given. It was "Accept this deal for life in prison" or "Have faith that your innocence will prevail in the court of law and you will be exonerated." If I, an innocent man, was given that choice... I would probably try it out in court. I would assume my innocence would prevent the court from convicting me.
- peterwwillis 11y agoThis is possibly the most naive thing i've read on the internet.
- URSpider94 11y agoNow I'm very, very confused. Are you saying that every person charged with a capital offense should instantly take a plea deal for life in prison? Because that's what your flow chart is suggesting. If so, then that's seriously messed up.
- InvisibleCities 11y agoYou can opine in harsh language about whether or not this guy made the "smart" choice all you want, but why is our "justice" system forcing this man to make such an unfair choice in the first place?
- peterwwillis 11y agoThe justice system isn't for only doing what is just at all times, it is for enforcing the consequences of laws. The point of a law is simply to put down the rules by which order is maintained, and that order is dictated by the morality of the majority of people who hold power in government. The justice system merely upholds the law set down and doles out what the law defines as a 'just' punishment or judgment. A law can say literally anything, like, "Black people may not marry White people", or "Women may not vote", "Gay people may not get married", etc. Or they can say things like "At an intersection, the left-most lane may turn left onto the street it intersects with, but not the right-most lane." It can say anything; it doesn't have to do with "fairness" and "justice", it has to do with maintaining order. The laws, once put down, are enforced, as long as they remain laws. The results of those laws being enforced will only stop once the laws are abolished (and even then, sometimes the states just like to keep going with 'em even if they've been abolished anyway). We can't just selectively enforce or not enforce laws. Then there would be no point to the law. Then literally any local government official, judge, court, president, etc could abuse the rights of citizens or allow people to go free simply because they felt like it. And that's not in the public interest. Therefore, laws which are deemed to be unfair or unjust must be amended or abolished. But - and this is the important part - they must simply be made by decree by will of the representatives of the public, and must not always meet a measurement of justice or fairness. Not only because there are plenty of laws which simply define what the proper procedures of daily life are, but because we'd literally never get any laws passed if we had to have a philosophical discussion about the potential pros and cons of the impact of the law on justice as a general idea. So why are they forcing him to make an unfair choice? Laws aren't designed to be fair. Only the consequence of the law can be fair, according to that law. In this case, if you ask a guy if he wants to live, and he says, "No", is it fair to give him death, assuming he was of sound mind and body and understood the consequences of his decision? Yeah.
- wutwatt 11y agoYour writing presumes Glossip killed Van Treese. Why do you believe this to be true?
- cbsmith 11y agoOmg you are proposing such a hugely distorted justice system. The punishment for making a bad decision on a deal presented to you should not be death. If your crime deserves the maximum sentence, and you are in subway helpful to the criminal justice system, then maybe you deserve a pass. However, if you didn't commit the crime, or if there is reasonable doubt as to whether you did, I don't care if you mooned the DA when they offered a plea bargain: you shouldn't get killed. That's not arbitrary justice. That's just justice. You can't justify punishing innocent people. Now, the nice thing about other punishments is, in the case where justice if misapplied, you can try to make up for it later. With the death penalty, that option isn't available to you, which is one of many reasons people question whether it at all makes sense.
- cbsmith 11y agos/subway/someway/ Missed the autocorrect foo. Sorry.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]