3 ms·
One of the posts illustrates that nicely, I think. http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ There's a s
by DanBC 11y ago
One of the posts illustrates that nicely, I think.
http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/
There's a sheet of a bunch of sums. The student has got them all correct. But we don't know if the student actually understands the concepts, or if the student is using their wrong understanding and an algorithm that coincidentally gives the right answer.
The comments give a good take down of that style of teaching.
- Steko 11y agoI didn't find it to be a particularly convincing "takedown". What's being taught in the example is clearly "the ability to execute a simple algorithm" not "an understanding of the concepts" so criticizing it for not doing the latter seems silly. Maybe it is the case as one commenter says that second graders should be doing the latter and not the former until later grades. OTOH maybe not! I'd be curious as to the evidence either way.
- hn9780470248775 11y ago> But we don't know if the student actually understands the concepts, or if the student is using their wrong understanding and an algorithm that coincidentally gives the right answer. Reminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chinese_room