9 ms·
Declining Student Resilience: A Serious Problem for Colleges
- carsongross 11y agoArticles like this remind me of "old economy steve". Please, Professor with tenure and a pension, tell us how children facing an increasingly winner-take-all world in which failure actually is catastrophic are too afraid to take risks.
- rwallace 11y agoThat's an argument for why it's reasonable to be wary of taking financial risks. It's not an argument for why it's reasonable to call the police and a psychotherapist because you saw a mouse in your apartment.
- pippy 11y agoYou'll always find people like that in University. The interesting thing is the younger generation treating education like a commodity. And given tuition costs, they have a right to. This will inevitably cause tension between the academics and the students. The most damaging cause it will have is on society long term, as higher learning traditionally has been used for demonstrating the capability of an individual. Instead we're seeing the capability for obtaining ~$30k debt.
- thebooktocome 11y ago> You'll always find people like that in University. The point of the article was that we are finding more people like that, on average, than we were in the past.
- 6d0debc071 11y agoPeople's feelings aren't necessarily reasonable. If you grow up almost exclusively in an environment where failure can snowball fairly easily, which school is, and everyone tells you it's really important not to fail in that context, whether or not that's true, then that will be likely to be a large part of the pattern of emotion you have when confronting failures outside that context.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoan increasingly winner-take-all world in which failure actually is catastrophic I find this surprising. In what way is, in today's world, failure any more catastrophic than at any time in the past? Are there very many examples of people who have never failed at anything? For the rest of the population who has experienced failures, am I to understand that we're now doomed?
- Retra 11y agoStudent wages are lower, student debt is higher.
- rndn 11y agoI think a similar development can also be seen in countries without any tuition fees, but my sample size could be too small to say that with certainty.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoBut that's not winner-take-all, that's just a situation where investment must carefully be coordinated against projected future returns. I am also waiting for an explanation of this winner-take-all idea. A couple/few posters have mentioned it. Sounds quite depressing.
- carsongross 11y agohttp://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user3303/imageroot/2014/01/20140102_wealth10.jpg http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user3303... Wealth is increasingly concentrated in the highest brackets. The delta between someone in the top 5% and the top 1% has increased markedly. Competition for that 1% slot has increased dramatically. Tenure-track positions now have thousands of applicants. In tech, Microsoft, Oracle, etc. made tens of thousands of millionaires. Google made, say, thousands. Facebook made, say, hundreds. Instagram made ten. (I exaggerate for comic effect.) I don't entirely disagree with the authors general point: kids are extremely shielded today, but I don't think he is properly sympathetic to the context in which kids (and parents) find themselves in. To the point of a comical lack of self-awareness. (In fairness this is an article in psychologytoday.)
- cryoshon 11y ago"Students are afraid to fail; they do not take risks; they need to be certain about things. For many of them, failure is seen as catastrophic and unacceptable. External measures of success are more important than learning and autonomous development." This is in part a consequence of test-based education. Students have been told for a very long time that failing important tests like the SAT/ACT will have irrevocable consequences that are negative. Most of their learning has occurred in the light of this danger, and so, failure is a big deal. Actual learning or autonomous development are pieces to spruce up the resume after the good scores are in the bag.
- crocal 11y agoI don't think the "irrevocable" part is the main problem of test-based education. You need the test to know where you are. If you prepare well, most important tests in life can be managed. What is really the problem is the systematic punishment of failure. /This/ indeed can have irrevocable consequences for certain personality types. I grew up in France and this "punishment of failure" teaching system is a major problem of France's education system.
- eep_opp 11y agoReally, it sounds to me as though the main problem might be that these kids are coddled before they reach university and maybe have unrealistic expectations of themselves. I think they may not have a fair assessment of their own abilities because of prior hand holding. I haven't seen the emotional catastrophe element that this article talks about. But, I did witness the abuse of the faculty. I saw the entitlement my generation is often accused of first hand. Many students were hostile, rude and lazy. I gained a reputation for sticking up for professors and calling my fellow students out on their behavior. In part I do blame the staff. Though maybe they couldn't gain control because their hands were tied by policy.
- qrendel 11y agoSpeak for yourself; I saw quite a bit of overt hostility from the faculty at my schools. Things like berating and humiliating students in front of the class, refusing to meet with students or sign necessary paperwork for them to proceed, and a frequent attitude that teaching classes and dealing with students was the absolute worst part of their day, an unnecessary burden that they didn't have the time for. Quite frankly if I should end up having kids of my own, I'm doubtful whether I will even want them to attend college if it's still the same environment by then. Worse yet, I'm afraid all these articles about millennial entitlement just work to reinforce and justify these attitudes among teachers and faculty.
- rubidium 11y agoCalling the cops and needing counseling after seeing a mouse... Oh I am soo happy I didn't stay in academia. The professors are the ones who have to deal with the emotional trainwrecks that result from 18 years of overly praised and insulated child raising. It'll be interesting to see the next gen of parenting advice after this gets sorted out. "Have you let your child fail today?"
- ra1n85 11y agoAlthough anecdotal, I've always seen a strong correlation between candidates that are capable of sharing strong examples of past failures and employees that excel. Like anything else, coping and persistence require practice. There is value in failure.
- DanBC 11y ago> "Have you let your child fail today?" That's something that is being taught in some schools. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-16879336 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/education-16879336 (I submitted that four years ago.)
- AlexEatsKittens 11y agoEven more interesting is watching these people trickle into the professional environment. Universities need to accommodate this stuff, to an extent, because the students are their customers. Managers do not.
- kafkaesq 11y agoThe inevitable blowback from helicopter parenting. It will probably take decades for society to fully recover. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Helicopter_parent
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- mfoy_ 11y agoI have a friend who has helicopter parents. The parents would take rotating shifts to fly out and live with them while they were at university (and not in residence) to keep an eye on them. To an extent it's robbed them of their independence and they've lost direction in their life. The parents truly mean well and love their children, but people don't become strong by relying on a crutch their whole life.
- DanielBMarkham 11y agoI have ran into several people who have had parents schedule and come in for (!) job interviews alongside their kids.
- CWuestefeld 11y agoI vow never to hire someone who comes in for an interview accompanied by their parent (unless it's support for a physical disability). Can't such helicopter parents see the perception problem that they're creating?
- Animats 11y agoThis is a side effect of a winner-take-all economy. Merely graduating from college just isn't enough any more. If you're not in the 1%, you're a loser and will have crap jobs for the rest of your life, or at least until the college loans are paid off.
- javert 11y agoI think it's a side effect of the expectation of not having a crap job. For all of human history, 99.9% of people have had crap jobs. Life gets a lot better if you are OK with that, but young people are not OK with that today.
- derekp7 11y agoWhat's worse is that in more recent history, you could get by pretty good with a crap job. You wouldn't have luxury items, but you'd have most of what was needed to live a normal life. But today, if you have a crap job, you don't earn enough to cover even the basics of life. Not because the basics are more expensive (in relation to pay), but for many people there are more basics that are required than previously. For example, either you have a car that constantly needs work done on it, or you have car payments (and often times both). And add in mandatory car insurance (full coverage required if you have a loan). Without the car you can't get to work (unless you are in a major city with good transportation options). In fact, the biggest struggle that I've witnessed people (esp. single parents) having isn't food or housing, but just maintaining a reliable transportation option to get to work and run the kids back and forth to daycare.
- meatysnapper 11y agoThe cost of 1) transportation 2) education 3) healthcare is insane, in the US. Unfortunately, I don't see any of these changing anytime soon.
- PaulHoule 11y agoAlso housing.
- davidw 11y ago"The modulus of resilience and the modulus of toughness were calculated from the area under the engineering stress versus engineering strain curves, as outlined in Appendix C. Both are useful for determining the amount of energy the students can absorb before yielding and fracture."
- 7Figures2Commas 11y agoGeorge Carlin knew what he was talking about. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6wOt2iXdc4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h6wOt2iXdc4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-ryuJDTpEc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=u-ryuJDTpEc Pure wisdom.
- gricardo99 11y agoAlthough George Carlin certainly had some hilariously entertaining things to say about parenting (and no doubt insightful to some degree), it seems he didn't necessarily have such a stellar parenting record himself: http://www.amazon.com/Carlin-Home-Companion-Growing-George/dp/1250058252 http://www.amazon.com/Carlin-Home-Companion-Growing-George/d...
- jackmaney 11y agoI've said it before, and I'll say it again: I'm glad I'm no longer in academia.
- jgrowl 11y ago"There has been an increase in diagnosable mental health problems, but there has also been a decrease in the ability of many young people to manage the everyday bumps in the road of life." Isn't this the bigger deal than student resilience?
- DanBC 11y agoIncrease in diagnosis may not be increase in incidence, but could be decreased stigma, easier access to diagnosis, wider understanding of when to seek help etc.
- tombrossman 11y agoNot directly related to the article content, but did anyone notice the odd caption/credit under the top article image? It reads "Source: Google images approved for reuse." which I haven't seen before. A quick reverse image search reveals that it's by this guy on Flickr (https://www.flickr.com/photos/topgold/6273248505/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/topgold/6273248505/) and carries a CC Attribution license, which this article is clearly not in compliance with. It's a publisher owned website an you would think they know a bit about copyright.
- Futurebot 11y agoHow about instead of placing the blame on helicoptering, which may in fact be part of the problem, we consider something else: students being realistic about what failure means to their future. We're in an era of hypercompetition, increased barriers to entry for even menial jobs, massive wealth concentration, vanished upward mobility (and easy downward mobility), stagnant wages, credentialism, offshoring/outsourcing, and vanished company loyalty. Viewed in this light, reactions of students to every negative statement or bad grade is completely rational: with the incredible number of people applying for each job, and the ever-increasing requirements to get one (looking at GPAs, etc.), students know that even minor issues now can mean large issues in the future. Maybe students aren't hypersensitive; instead they're hyper-attuned to the realities they're facing: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3999248 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3999248 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credentialism_and_educational_inflation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credentialism_and_educational_... http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/11/how_elite_firms.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2011/11/how_elite_firms.... http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/09/ernest-young-degree-recruitment-hiring-credentialism/406576/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2015/09/ernest-y... Another thing I'd add, which is related, is that grit, while important is far from sufficient for success. It would be great if this was more widely appreciated. I wrote a short post on it: https://medium.com/@opirmusic/the-character-hypothesis-necessary-but-insufficient-17c51427dbf4 https://medium.com/@opirmusic/the-character-hypothesis-neces... Side note: I tried to comment on the article, but the spam filter there is incredibly aggressive.
- mklim 11y agoAnecdotal experience vaguely related to this—when I was in college (2010-2014) most people I knew weren't there to learn for the joy of learning, they were there to get a job they could support themselves with. Most of them believed there was no possible way to live above the poverty line without a college degree and were accordingly desperate in their efforts to earn one. A "hard" or "unfair" class was several thousand dollars down the drain and a potential future of eternal poverty, not a learning experience. I often heard the expectation stated by my peers that everyone should pass a class as long as they put in a good faith effort, because that was only "fair." I don't know from personal experience, but I imagine it was much easier to be blase and accepting of failure when you could pay for two semester's worth of classes with one summer job (my summer job paid double minimum wage and still couldn't cover more than 4 credits, and I went to a public in-state university).
- apalmer 11y agogood... this is the purpose of going away to college. Helps to trigger independence and self sufficiency. The amount of people I know personally who had a TOTAL change in personality between the ages of 17 and 23... is just about everyone I know...
- tstactplsignore 11y ago>"Many students, they said, now view a C, or sometimes even a B, as failure, and they interpret such “failure” as the end of the world." After 3+ years of university, this has felt like a form of doublethink on the part of some professors and almost all administrators when it comes to grades and grade deflation. On one hand, you hear that "students shouldn't worry so much about the grade" and "what you learned is more important than what grade you got". On the other, more realistic side of things, they've contributed towards and support a nearly one dimensional system of graduate and professional schools where a high GPA is almost everything for acceptance. Top med schools and graduate schools almost entirely accept students with A or A- GPAs, regardless of the student's other relevant experiences or accomplishments, and often regardless of the quality or rigor of the student's undergraduate institution. Therefore for any student at an elite university with the (honestly modest) goal of becoming a doctor, anything less than an A- (on a curve with the brightest students in the country, no less) is a failure because the same faculty and administrators pushing this kind of study lock them out of achieving their goals for it. Faculty and administrators in education have created an elaborate hoop jumping game of achieving impossibly high and fairly meaningless scores, and then get angry when students (a) are alienated by something they used to enjoy and (b) decide to play the game! The same professors who have the audacity to feel insulted when students merely ask if certain content will be on the test or how final grades will be distributed then turn around and tell students that their B+ average will hugely limit them from achieving their goals when in an advisory role. This is why I'm a huge fan of grade inflation- truth is, university grades are a poor metric of future performance, and generally only serve to creatively restrict, alienate, and limit students at the college level. Grade inflation largely eliminates the fairly useless choking pressures of the grading system.
- gmmeyer 11y agoFaculty grade on totally arbitrary metrics, what is a "curve" and what grade does it mean you get. And then are mystified when students are upset that their grades were arbitrary. How do they know how much to curve it? Who knows, it's basically just a whim. Yes they say they grade on a standard distribution, but that could be equally meaningless--depending on how the exam is scored in the first place.
- 11y ago
- restalis 11y agoI see here all over the place (only) comments about the grading and in general the current state of education as the root of the issue and what is to do about it, but as the title says the issue is the resilience. Although what I'm going to say may sound like a joke, it isn't meant to be one: Our society does not have enough (or any kind of) psychological resilience testing. Currently all of us are allowed to take any kind of risks regardless of the capacity for risk-bearing and its consequences. All of us want the cherry on the top of the cake and therefore jump at it, even the ones of us that do not feel competitive enough. That is reckless, and the consequences of immature decisions then falls on the rest of society which will have to deal with the broken ones. Yes, the education may be too damaging than it has to be and if so an attention in this regard is welcomed, but there also should be a better selection of candidates. It does not have any sense nor it is moral to let ignorant wannabes to throw themselves at something that may clearly surpass their potential.