54 ms·
Math Mistakes
- jamessb 11y agoPeople interestd by this may also be interested in 'The Most Common Errors in Undergraduate Mathematics': http://www.math.vanderbilt.edu/~schectex/commerrs/ http://www.math.vanderbilt.edu/~schectex/commerrs/
- DanBC 11y agoI had a quick look and I didn't see anything on the site about whether dyslexia or dyspraxia have common errors that show up in math. There was an interesting programme on BBC Radio Four this morning about how dyslexia and dyspraxia can show up in art. http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06d2fxf http://www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/b06d2fxf
- Johnny555 11y agoMaybe Math Mistakes needs a related site "Grammar and Spelling Mistakes": I notice that the kid didn’t write them as (x,y) but wrote them as x,y. I wonder how come he did that? Or, more precisely, I wonder if he doesn’t see much of a difference between (x,y) and x,y or if three is some other reason for leaving off the parentheses.
- thieving_magpie 11y agoI think they call that "every internet forum or comment section ever".
- daniel-levin 11y agoIt is interesting to see kids invent their own perfectly adequate, if peculiar, notation. In the first example with the quadrilaterals, the answers were all right. The math is not wrong, just written differently.
- gohrt 11y agoThat gave me mixed feelings. On the one hand, the teacher did an admirable job (for a teacher) of seeing the correct thinking behind the "wrong" notation. On the other hand, the teacher still accused the student of making a mistake.
- Natsu 11y agoIf nobody else understands your right answer, it may not be worth much. At this level, it doesn't matter at all--anyone can see based on the constraints what they're doing and understand them. But this may not always be the case. For example, when they get to intervals and suddenly need to properly discriminate between intervals like (1,2], (1,2), [1,2) and [1,2]. I might ding that by just one point--if you use non-standard notation, you must properly define it. You won't always be dealing with cases where your idiosyncrasies have obvious answers and it's better to form good habits that allow you to communicate clearly with others. There may be many good ways to depart from convention and I'd hesitate to stop anyone from doing that, but I think that if defining your departure from convention is too burdensome to be worthwhile, then you do not have a compelling case to depart from it in the first place.
- Gibbon1 11y agoIf I were a teacher and I saw a student come up with a peculiar but correct notation, I'd be ecstatic.
- jacobolus 11y agoIndeed, developing new notation should be not only allowed, not only encouraged, but even required as an assignment at various points during mathematical training, at every age level. Also to be encouraged is conscientious analysis and critique of existing notations, algorithms, and explanations. Society advances in two ways: in small incremental steps, and in large leaps. When we stick to existing notations and concepts we can make incremental improvements. But the large leaps often come from creating better notations and better conceptual understandings, which can turn substantial amounts of knowledge and logical thinking into obvious consequences of an organized and intuitive system.
- userbinator 11y agoI'd say "the notation x/y means a fraction, and cannot be used for coordinates. Likewise, (x, y) means a coordinate and cannot be used for fractions. They are related but should not be conflated."
- gizmo686 11y agoThat makes it sound way to absolute. You should say something more like "please write coordinates like (x,y)". Incidentally, in some contexts, (x,y) is how we write fractions (they are just an equivalence class based on an ordered pair of integers). As long as I am on the subject, (x,y) also means the inner product of x and one. And I had one teacher for whom (x,y) means f(x,y) where f would change more or less every section based on convience. On second thought, maybe we should be a little stricter in teaching students that math notation is rigid. If we raise a generation of mathematicians believing it, then they might clean up the current mess of notation we have today.
- alextgordon 11y agoIf you want to make a mathematician sweat, just ask them whether ((a, b), c) is the same as (a, b, c).
- mjcohen 11y agoThe answer is "What does '(a, b)' mean?"
- Someone 11y agoAs I once said after someone, after a discussion on some trivial mathematical argument that he didn't grasp, said "OK, but one plus one equals two, right?": "it depends".
- asgard1024 11y agoYes, up to isomorphism.
- DanBC 11y agoFor the future people: http://mathmistakes.org/naming-coordinates-feedback-and-revision/ http://mathmistakes.org/naming-coordinates-feedback-and-revi... (I linked to the site in general, and that's the post currently on that site's front page).
- gizmo686 11y agoIt might be that in reading the teachers comment, he parsed the parentheses as part of English grammar, not the mathematical notation. Similar to how, if the comment said to write coordinates as "x,y", I would not include the quotation marks in my answer.
- tempestn 11y agoThat was my thinking as well.
- falsedan 11y agoHere's the old go-to for English errors: http://public.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/errors.html http://public.wsu.edu/~brians/errors/errors.html
- ggambetta 11y agoThis concept of "teaching with keywords" absolutely terrifies me. I distinctly remember encountering Metric Geometry* in high school. It didn't teach me geometry, it taught me how to think, and I'm forever grateful. Teaching math with keywords is the opposite of this. [*] Probably not the correct name in English. It was geometry without algebra; proving theorems and finding loci based on some axioms about angles, parallel lines and so on. What is this called? Euclidean Geometry?
- vardhanw 11y agoYou may like this: http://euclidthegame.com/Tutorial/ http://euclidthegame.com/Tutorial/
- ggambetta 11y agoI do. Thanks :)
- DanBC 11y agoOne of the posts illustrates that nicely, I think. http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ http://mathmistakes.org/subtraction-algorithms/ There's a sheet of a bunch of sums. The student has got them all correct. But we don't know if the student actually understands the concepts, or if the student is using their wrong understanding and an algorithm that coincidentally gives the right answer. The comments give a good take down of that style of teaching.
- Steko 11y agoI didn't find it to be a particularly convincing "takedown". What's being taught in the example is clearly "the ability to execute a simple algorithm" not "an understanding of the concepts" so criticizing it for not doing the latter seems silly. Maybe it is the case as one commenter says that second graders should be doing the latter and not the former until later grades. OTOH maybe not! I'd be curious as to the evidence either way.
- hn9780470248775 11y ago
- RevRal 11y agoCan anyone think of a "writing mistakes" version of this blog? Making public another's writing may be too far.... But it would be interesting to mine the data and classify non-grammatical writing mistakes, specifically to ease the stress of grading college junior research papers -- some of which are written at a middle-school writing level -- by parsing sentences and auto-applying applicable writing mistake classification, to which I can gently glide my eyes to and convert to something intelligible.
- Sniffnoy 11y agoThis particular entry is quite interesting, it gets at a distinction I'm not sure I had explicitly thought about before: http://mathmistakes.org/recursive-and-relational-thinking-and-the-feedback-each-deserves/ http://mathmistakes.org/recursive-and-relational-thinking-an...
- gizmo686 11y agoI think the author of that post undervalues the strength of the recursive approach. It is, in general, much easier to apply a recursive approach, and once you have done so you can often mechanically convert your solution into a relational one. Even if you cannot, you have still converted the question into a standard notation math problem, which is normally the hardest part of the problem.
- zipbooks 11y agoIt would be interesting to see a new teaching methodology develop around teaching mostly just the concepts that people get wrong with the assumption that most people don't need much help with the stuff everyone is getting wrong.
- deeteecee 11y agohaha i totally remember that "law of sines" example. nothing to do with the "law of sines" over time, i would regularly just exhaust my brain and i would just imaginarily throw random variables to give me solutions, making my homework full of errors lol.
- softprodigy 11y agoAmazing blog!
- tempestn 11y agoIn theory the relatively recent adoption of Common Core math teaching techniques should help with many of these sorts of mistakes. I'm not well versed enough to know whether there's any sign of that already, but certainly the intention of teaching students to actually think about how math works and why a certain technique produces the right answer is laudable.