3 ms·
As another posted commented, there will be a minimum list size to prevent this sort of thing. For example, Twitter already allows targeting to specific individu
by gk1 11y ago
As another posted commented, there will be a minimum list size to prevent this sort of thing. For example, Twitter already allows targeting to specific individuals, but the list minimum is 500 (if I'm not mistaken).
- jtokoph 11y agoBut couldn't I put: youremail@gmail.com fakeemail-1@gmail.com .... fakeemail-499@gmail.com
- gk1 11y agoI should've been more specific. Twitter requires a list of 500 _recognized_ emails.
- ceejayoz 11y agoWhat's stopping me from setting up 500 recognized emails?
- kristofferR 11y agoFor this Google offering they're likely to use the same tech that powers their new CAPTCHA-less reCaptcha.
- ceejayoz 11y agoWhich is trivially broken by having real people simulate a bunch of real Gmail accounts. Services like this already exist for Facebook likes, YouTube views, etc.
- kuschku 11y agoWhich is (a) cheaply broken by hiring a few hundred bored students, and (b) is also even possible to be broken analytically. It is actually easier to break than the highest level of the previous captcha, as now you just need a Google account with semi-normal activity and a JS runtime that pretends to be a normal browser. The semi-normal activity is simple to be possible by running it as a bot and feeding it with search queries for 8h a day, running a query every few minutes. Which, in turn, gets the account marked as active.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- emidln 11y agodef scumbag_targeted_campaign_builder(accounts): for name, users in groupby(accounts, key=lambda x: x['first_name']): users = list(users) while len(users) <= 500: users.append(generate_fake_email()) yield render_template(name), users Some variation of this is pretty easy, and likely will become common.
- JackC 11y agoI wonder how easy it is. Google says they require 1000 "Active visitors." So you need to not only create 1000 fake accounts to target a single real individual, but run 1000 undetected clickfraud bots (and then pay out on your own clickfraud). Not sure of the current state of the clickfraud arms race, but maybe there are cheaper and easier ways of snooping?
- emidln 11y agoI don't imagine targeting any random user is particularly efficient, but when you are dealing with multi million user databases, finding close to a thousand people who share a first or last name probably isn't hard. They don't even have to address it to a person, simply provide some details (details vary based on database). Think "How was you recent trip to Hawaii? Click here for winter deals!"
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]