3 ms·
This is a good point wrapped in a fairly bad article. It conflates source code with machine code, calls the rules "totalitarian," refers to the opposition as "d
by mikeash 11y ago
This is a good point wrapped in a fairly bad article. It conflates source code with machine code, calls the rules "totalitarian," refers to the opposition as "drones," and implies that VW only kept their software secret to hide their scam, despite the fact that every automaker keeps their software secret.
- tajen 11y agoThe cause is pretty easy to defend and I agree they need to make their arguments more explicit. Also, many of those articles mention "If..., we could have done ...", but few demonstrate that there is enough budget and attention to spare for non-corporate inspection of car software. For example it would be very pragmatic to ask "Copyright office, is it now ok to inspect Audi's software even against DMCA rules?" I was told in a French garage that only Renault had an ecological malus whereas the 4 competitors for this car claim to be complying. Should we start inspecting those?
- the_ancient 11y ago>> despite the fact that every automaker keeps their software secret. And that refutes the point they are hiding their scam how? Just because the other automakers were not caught (yet) does not mean they are not all doing dishonest shit with their code
- mikeash 11y agoOK, it doesn't refute that point if they're all cheating. In that case, what refutes the point is simply that businesses usually keep their code secret by default, and require some motivation to open them. They may take advantage of closed source to do bad things, but those bad things are not the reason for closed source.
- ethbro 11y agoIn my experience, embarrassment is usually a larger motivation for keeping code closed-source.