3 ms·
Can I just say, while I have no specific issue with adding critical or traffic light systems in general: > The headsup doesn’t contain any details of the issu
by Someone1234 11y ago
Can I just say, while I have no specific issue with adding critical or traffic light systems in general:
> The headsup doesn’t contain any details of the issues being fixed apart from the maximum severity level and a date a few days in the future.
Maybe it would be advantageous to include a short summary of the issue (DoS, local security, remote security (exploitable), remote security (unexploitable), etc)? The "bad guys" still wouldn't know where to look, and it isn't like people aren't actively working to find exploits in OpenSSL daily. But this gives the "good guys" information which you yourselves say they need to evaluate the risks to them.
- tptacek 11y agoIt's often hard to determine whether a vulnerability is merely a denial of service vector, which is one reason the descriptions are kept abstract.
- Someone1234 11y agoIf that were true then this new critical moniker doesn't make sense. The whole justification for them adding it is that they have (past tenths) made that determination.
- tptacek 11y agoI don't understand your rebuttal. The "Critical" designation confirms that a vulnerability is known to have applications beyond DOS in real-world configurations. "High" does not; it includes memory corruption vulnerabilities that are believed to be capable only of crashing a process, but not known to be so limited.
- Someone1234 11y agoYou said they cannot put broad notes onto their release because they may not know enough. I am saying that the new critical term has been coined because they claim they do know enough to classify it. If they cannot make these determinations then the whole high/critical distinction is impossible. They've made a determination in order to categorise them.
- tptacek 11y agoStill not following. "Critical" is the term they plan to use when they do know enough to say that there are immediately available better-than-DOS exploit vectors.